Dipp3As and its Radical Cation
G
calculations on Dipp3Pþꢃ only converge when planarity is
imposed. We found no difficulty in optimising the non-planar
Dipp3Asþꢃ structure which is confirmed by a frequency calcu-
lation. As Pan et al. also conclude, the bending mode for
flattening this class of radical cation with highly congested
substituents is probably very small.[9] Nevertheless the substan-
tial size of the HFS values measured for such R3Eþꢃ species,
whether E is As or P, strongly supports solution-phase structures
that have minima with pyramidal geometries and indeed sub-
stantial lifetimes in these pyramidal states, however low the
barrier to pyramidal inversion may be.
filtration under vacuum. Thin layer chromatography (TLC) of
the tan coloured residue after solvent removal indicated two
components. Column chromatography on silica with hexanes
eluted the leading band, which was recovered and recrystallised
from hot n-heptane to afford crystalline Dipp3As (1.59 g,
2.76 mmol, 43 % yield), mp 339–3458C, determined to be pure
by NMR spectroscopy. A second crystallisation from n-heptane
afforded blocks suitable for X-ray diffraction. For NMR data see
Table 2. m/z (ESI, CH3CN) Calc. for C36H51As (Mþꢃ
)
558.32012. Found 558.31885. Anal. Calc. for C36H51As: C
77.39, H 9.20. Found: C 77.41, H 9.23 %.
The calculated spin density on P in Dipp3Pþꢃ is 0.858
(Table 7), compared with 0.787 on As in Dipp3Asþꢃ (the
remaining spin density is distributed over the C and H atoms,
which contributes significantly to line broadening) (R. T. Boere´,
Y. Zhang, unpubl. data). The ratio of the solution phase isotropic
HFS of 23.9 mT in Dipp3P and 26.1 mT in Dipp3As, is 0.916.
The ratio of the calculated full-spin hyperfine parameters Aiso
for 31P and 75As of 474.79 and 523.11 mT is 0.908.[37,42] The
similarity in these values also suggests that the amount of
s-orbital spin density on Dipp3Pþꢃ and Dipp3Asþꢃ is more
congruent than indicated by the (relatively low-level) DFT
calculations.
X-Ray Crystallographic Study
A colourless prism of Dipp3As (0.24 ꢂ 0.18 ꢂ 0.15 mm3) was
coated in Paratone oil, mounted on a glass fibre, and cooled to
ꢀ1008C for data collection on a Bruker Apex II CCD area
˚
detector diffractometer (MoKa1, l 0.71073 A) using v–f scans
(y range ¼ 2.458 to 28.818), followed by data correction and
reduction using SAINT-Plus.[45] A total of 9509 reflections were
measured of which 2635 were unique (Rint 0.05). The structure
was solved with dual-space methods (SHELX-M) and refined
with SHELX-L.[46] The compound, C36H51As, formula weight
558.69, was found to crystallise in the hexagonal space group
˚
˚
R3 (#146) [a 16.6193(16) A, c 10.1772(16) A], with three
molecules per unit cell. A semi-empirical absorption correction
Experimental
Materials and General Methods
(SADABS) from equivalents was applied (m ¼ 0.14 mmꢀ1
,
transmission factors 0.856 and 0.784).[45] The data is complete
Unless otherwise stated, all work was carried out under a dry
nitrogen atmosphere, using standard Schlenk techniques or an
MBraun Glove box. AsCl3 (Aldrich) was used as received.
Magnesium turnings (Aldrich) were stored in a glove box and
activated by grinding before use. Solvents for synthesis were
collected from a solvent purification system (MBraun) or dis-
tilled under an N2 atmosphere and degassed by freeze–pump–
thaw degassing. Drying agents for solvent purification include
sodium/benzophenone (tetrahydrofuran) and sodium (n-
heptane). 1H and 13C NMR spectra were recorded on a Bruker/
Tecmag AC250 spectrometer (1H, 250.13 MHz; 13C, 62.9 MHz)
and referenced relative to 0 ppm for tetramethylsilane (1H, 13C)
using either deuterated chloroform or deuterated benzene as
secondary references. Electrospray ionisation (ESI) mass spectra
were measured using a Thermo Instruments Exactive orbitrap
spectrometer. For the electrochemical experiments, dichlor-
omethane (BDH, reagent grade) was purified by distillation from
CaH2 and was purged with dry argon before use. Electrochemical
grade tetra-n-butylammonium hexafluorophosphate [nBu4N][PF6]
(Fluka) was used as the supporting electrolyte and was kept in
a desiccator before use. Bis(cyclopentadienyl)cobalt(III) hexa-
fluorophosphate (Aldrich) was used as the potential reference.
˚
(99.9 %) down to 0.77 A; R1 0.0494, wR2 0.1138 for 2635
observed data and a goodness of fit (GOF) of 1.064, with
largest peaks and hole in the final difference map of 0.29 and
ꢀ0.28 e Aꢀ3. In the course of refinement the distribution
˚
of intensity data was found not to match that expected for
this chiral space group. Subsequently, the structure was suc-
cessfully refined as a racemic twin (twinning by merohedry) in
a 61 : 39 ratio. Mercury 3.1 was employed for crystallographic
figures and post-refinement data analysis.[47] CCDC 937361
contains the supplementary crystallographic data for this paper.
These data can be obtained free of charge from The Cambridge
Cyclic Voltammetry
Cyclic voltammograms were obtained at room temperature in
CH2Cl2 containing 0.4 M [nBu4N][PF6] as the supporting elec-
trolyte. These solutions were purged with dry argon for 10 min
directly before use, and argon gas flowed over the solutions
during experiments. The cell design utilised a conventional
three electrode setup with a 3.0 mm diameter GC working
electrode, a Pt wire auxiliary and a silver wire quasi-reference
electrode. The working electrode was polished with a 0.3 micron
Al2O3 (Buehler, 0.05 mm) slurry on a clean polishing cloth,
rinsed with distilled water and acetone, and dried with tissue
paper before use. The reference electrode was separated from
the bulk solution by a fine porosity frit. Experiments com-
menced with initial background scans to characterise the size of
the electrochemical window and provide an estimate of
the likely background current. Cyclic voltammograms were
obtained over scan rates of 0.050–20 V sꢀ1. All potentials are
Preparation of Dipp3As
Activated (grinding and heating in vacuum) magnesium turn-
ings (0.56 g, 22.5 mmol), dibromoethane (0.1 mL), and tetra-
hydrofuran (20 mL) were heated at reflux for 30 m. To the
cooled mixture, DippBr (5.41 g, 22.5 mmol) was added, fol-
lowed by vigorous stirring and heating at reflux for 2.5 h. The
mixture was then stirred overnight at RT. The resultant solution
of DippMgBr[44] was cooled to ꢀ708C and CuCl (98 %, 2.40 g,
23.8 mmol) was added followed by stirring for 1 h at ꢀ708C, and
then warmed to RT and shielded from direct light. AsCl3 (98 %,
1.19 g, 6.44 mmol) was added and the mixture was stirred for
30 min at ꢀ708C, warmed to RT and heated to reflux overnight,
and then cooled to RT. Precipitated CuCl was removed by
reported versus the operative formal potential, E8 , for
Fcþ/0
the Fcþ/0 redox couple. The Ccþ/0 (Cc ¼ cobaltocene) redox
couple is known to appear at ꢀ1.35 V in CH2Cl2; data have been
converted into the Fcþ/0 scale by subtraction of 1.35 V.[31]