Journal of the American Chemical Society
Communication
reasoned that systematic alteration of the stereoelectronic
component at the TET−2KG−5mC interface could modulate
the transition state barrier toward a more controlled product
distribution (Figure 1C).
To test our hypothesis, we generated a panel of TET2
mutants by replacing several hydrophobic and polar residues in
the active site with alanine, one at a time (Figure 2A).17
most notable difference was observed for the V1395A mutant,
as it generated 5caC as the dominant product (>90%) (Figure
2C,D). To the best of our knowledge, such an activating TET
mutant is yet to be reported. Collectively, our systematic
screening experiment identified TET2 variants that could
significantly modulate 5mCox distribution by either stalling the
oxidation pathway at the first step to exclusively generate
5hmC or accelerating to the fully oxidized product. The
V1395A mutant is particularly important given that 5caC is
rare in the mammalian genome.
We further analyzed 5caC formation using base-resolution
sequencing. It has been shown that 5caC is deaminated upon
treatment with bisulfite and read as T during sequencing
(Figure 3A).21 In contrast, 5mC and 5hmC remain as C due to
Figure 2. Active site engineering toward novel TET2 variants. (A)
Structure of TET2 bound with 5mC DNA (PDB: 4NM6).17 (B)
Percent intensities of MALDI-MS signals for a range of mixtures of
5mC DNA with either 5hmC, 5fC, or 5caC. (C) Heat-map
representation of % 5mCox furnished by TET2 mutants. (D)
MALDI-MS spectrum showing activating effect of V1395A to
generate 5caC.
Figure 3. Analysis of 5mCox using Sanger sequencing. (A) Scheme
showing bisulfite-mediated 5caC deamination and decarboxylation.
(B) V1395A-catalyzed 5mC oxidation followed by bisulfite treatment
and PCR, confirming 5caC as the major product based on Sanger
sequencing data. BS = bisulfite.
Employing a MALDI-MS-based assay, we examined the
oxygenase activity of these mutants toward a short dsDNA
substrate, CAC5mCGGTG.18,19 To analyze the product
distribution in a quantitative manner, we first examined if
the DNA segments carrying various 5mCox intermediates
displayed comparable ionization potentials. For this, we
synthesized three additional DNAs (CACXGGTG; X =
5hmC, 5fC, and 5caC) (Figure S1, Schemes S1−3). 5mC
DNA was mixed with each synthesized 5mCox DNA separately
in different ratios and subjected to MALDI-MS. Peak intensity
of the individual DNA reflected their known ratio in the
mixture, indicating equivalent degrees of ionization in MALDI
analyses (Figures 2B, S2−S4).
their inertness toward the reagent. We subjected a duplex 76-
mer DNA carrying a central 5mCpG unit to TET-mediated
oxidation followed by bisulfite treatment, PCR amplification,
and Sanger sequencing. While 5mC in samples exposed to
either no protein or wild-type TET2 read as C, the equivalent
site in the V1395A-treated sample emerged as T (Figures 3B,
S6). These results demonstrate the ability of the mutant to
predominantly generate 5caC.
In an in vitro assay, wild-type TET2 converted 5mC DNA to
5hmC, 5fC, and 5caC. In contrast, the mutants oxidized
substrate DNA with varied degrees of specificity (Figures 2C,
S5). T1372A, T1393A, and T1883A mutants showed
remarkable specificity for generating primarily 5hmC. It has
been shown that a H-bonding network involving T1372 is
critical for rotating 5hmC to switch from product to substrate
orientation for further oxidation; lack of such interaction in
T1372A locks 5hmC in the product conformation.20 We
suspect a similar mechanism is operating for T1393A and
T1883A mutants as well to impart the degree specificity in C−
H oxidation. Among the hydrophobic residues screened, the
We next compared the activity of V1395A with that of wild-
type TET2 on three individual substrates (Figures 4A−C, S7−
S12). With respect to the wild-type enzyme, V1395A led to a
significantly higher production of 5hmC from 5mC, while both
enzymes showed comparable activity on 5hmC DNA. The
mutant displayed further improved activity on 5fC leading to
higher 5caC formation, demonstrating that it is indeed acting
as a superior dioxygenase in two discrete cycles involving
conversions of 5mC to 5hmC and 5fC to 5caC in a three-step
catalytic process. To further gauge the relative activity, we
measured catalytic efficiencies of V1395A and wild-type TET2
on 5mC with varying concentrations of 2KG (Figure S13).
B
J. Am. Chem. Soc. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX