Synthesis of an Indinavir Precursor
1147
of indinavir by Dorsey et al., the pentanamide was constructed
via the stereoselective benzylation of tert-butyldimethylsilyl
(TBS)-protected g-lactone 5.[17] This procedure required a five-
step synthesis starting with glutamic acid, a borane reduction to
obtain the alcohol 4,[19] and anhydrous conditions with strong
base for the benzylation reaction. The commercial route to
indinavir now avoids the use of 7a, and instead constructs the
pentanamide using the allylation of a 3-phenylpropanamide
derivative.[20,21] Recent patents describing bioactives synthe-
sised incorporating 7a have used the strategy of Dorsey et al. to
construct 7a, which indicates that this is still the best-known
route to this lactone.[22] Lactone 7a has also been used for the
synthesis of protease inhibitors active against indinavir-resistant
virus,[23] vasoactive intestinal peptide receptor inhibitors,[22]
and allylamides useful for the treatment of Alzheimer’s dis-
ease.[24] The importance of lactone 7a in the medicinal chemistry
literature led us to investigate methods to synthesise it from LGO,
but our previous attempts to insert benzyl groups on the 3-iodide
derivative of LGO using Suzuki–Miyaura chemistry were not
successful.[16] We now report on the efficiency of three different
approaches for the synthesis of lactone 7a using LGO, and
the development of a general strategy for the preparation of
3-(arylmethyl)-6,8-dioxabicyclo[3.2.1]octanones.
Table 1. Alkylation reactions of 2 with benzylbromide
O
O
O
O
Ph
Ph
BnBr
Ph
Ph
O
O
O
O
O
O
THF, Base
O
O
2
9a
10a
11
O
O
O
Ph
O
O
12
BnBr equiv. Base
Temp. [8C] Time [h] YieldA (9a : 10a : 11)
1.1
1.0
2.4
LDAC
tBuOK 25
tBuOK 25
ꢀ78 to 25
48
24
7 (1 : 3 : 26)B
31 (3 : 2 : 95)
88 (0 : 0 : 100)
1.5
AIsolated yield with ratio determined by gas chromatography–mass spec-
trometry (GC-MS).
B16 % of adduct 12 was also isolated.
CLDA ¼ lithium diisopropylamide.
Results and Discussion
We envisaged that the synthesis of lactone 7a could be
approached using direct alkylation of an enolate, aldol chem-
istry to introduce a benzylidene at the a-position of 2, or Baylis–
Hillman chemistry starting with LGO, the key step being the
C–C bond forming reaction at the a-centre. Watson et al.
recently reported that 2 undergoes aldol reactions to form a
dimer in the presence of base, providing support for an aldol
approach to generate 7a.[11] Furthermore, LGO is known to
undergo a stereoselective domino oxa-Michael–aldol reaction
with water and aromatic aldehydes, which would involve similar
reactivity.[25,26]
The conceptually simplest approach to the a-benzylated
derivatives via a-alkylation of ketone 2 consistently failed to
give appreciable amounts of monoalkylated products 9a or 10a
and reactions were dominated by the dibenzylated product 11
(Table 1). Lowering the temperature and using a strong base
afforded mainly dibenzylated adduct 11 as well as compound
12, which presumably resulted from a dimerisation of 2, subse-
quent g-deprotonation, and alkylation. The propensity for dia-
lkylation led us to increase the number of equivalents of halide; a
very good yield of the dialkylated adduct 11 was obtained. Thus,
the a-alkylation reaction was an excellent way to dibenzylate the
carbon adjacent to the carbonyl in 2, but efficient mono-
a-benzylation of the ketone using benzyl bromide and base
was not possible.
Turning our attention to the aldol reaction, an optimisation
study for the reaction of 2 with benzaldehyde was performed and
representative reactions are shown in Table 2. Initial attempts
using K2CO3 and NEt3 as base gave either none or very little
aldol adduct (Table 2, entries 1–3). Switching the base to
1,1,3,3-tetramethylguanidine (TMG), an excellent yield of ben-
zylidene was obtained; however, reactions took 24–48 h to reach
completion. Eliminating the solvent and running the reactions
neat gave a better yield of 13a and reduced the reaction time to
just 1 h. The geometry of the alkene in 13a was assigned as E on
the basis of a cross-peak in the 2D NOESY spectrum between
the aromatic ring protons and the methylene at C2. It should also
be noted that photochemical isomerisation of the E-enone to the
Z-enone was observed over time, requiring the products to be
kept in the dark.
With the success of the aldol reaction of 2 with benzalde-
hyde, we attempted to extend the derivatisation to other types of
aldehydes. Not only could these materials be used to construct
analogues of indinavir or the other bioactives prepared from
lactone 7a, the preparation of new chiral materials from such an
abundant precursor could lead to new chiral ligands or catalysts.
Thus, ketone 2 was reacted with a series of aromatic aldehydes
as shown in Table 2 to give the enones 13b–13i in moderate to
excellent yield. Although successful for the parent aldol reac-
tion, the neat reaction conditions were found to be unsatisfactory
for other aldehydes examined both in yield and product
distribution.
In addition to the aldol adducts, some double-bond migration
was observed, giving endocyclic enones 14b, d, f–h, which were
evident in the 1H NMR spectra of crude reaction mixtures. These
products lacked the H2a and H2b signals normally seen
1
between d 2.5 and 3.5 ppm in the H NMR spectrum, which
were replaced with a benzylic AB quartet at d 3.60–3.70 ppm.
The migration was more pronounced in reactions with aromatic
aldehydes substituted with electron-withdrawing groups
(Table 2, entries 10 and 19). We found that the isomerisation
was virtually eliminated when the reaction was performed in
acetonitrile at 508C and the amount of base was also limited. The
installation of an alkyl group using butyraldehyde was also
attempted; however, the yield of alkylidene 13j was poor,
indicating that an aldol approach was not feasible for alkyl
substituents.
To access these allylic rearrangement products, the isomer-
isation of 13b to endo-alkene 14b was attempted. No isomerisa-
tion was observed when 13b was heated in neat Hunig’s base at
¨
808C; however, isomerisation was observed by heating in TMG
at 1008C, although the reaction was slow and significant
decomposition occurred, makingisolation difficult. Thus, heating
13b at 1008C for 48h with TMG gave 13b/14b with a ratio of