506 A. Lundahl et al.
Xenobiotica, 2014; 44(6): 498–510
corresponding to that of the M1 reference standard was
observed in both materials (Table 1B). However, the major two
peaks at m/z 389 matched the MX and MY isomers described in
human liver microsomes in terms of retention times and
accurate mass spectra (Table 2A and B). The carboxylated
metabolite M3 was identified in both pig urine and bile based
on retention time and the accurate masses of its deprotonated
molecule and three of its product ions (m/z 357, 341 and 102;
Table 2C).
were found to be CYP2A, 2D, 2C and 3A (Achour et al.,
2011). Enterocytes, hepatocytes, liver and intestinal micro-
somes from pigs have been used to study drug metabolism
and similar activity and a corresponding rate of metabolism
have been observed for typical CYP3A substrates such as
testosterone and tacrolimus (Bader et al., 2000; Olsen et al.,
¨
1997; Skaanild & Friis, 1997; Thorn et al., 2011). Differences
in metabolism between humans and pigs have also been
observed for a few compounds, e.g. diclofenac and dextro-
¨
In the unhydrolyzed samples, two intact glucuronides, MX
glucuronide and MY glucuronide, were identified in both bile
and urine from pigs (Figure 2A–F and Table 3A and B). The
initial formation of m/z 389 represented the characteristic loss
of monodehydrogenated glucuronic acid (ꢂ176 Da) and the
further products of m/z 389 were in agreement with those of
MX and MY, respectively, m/z 321 being selective for MX
and m/z 333 for MY (c.f. Table 2A and B). The mass
accuracies were generally good, but for a few product ions
with a very low ion count the mass error exceeded 5 ppm.
metorphan (Thorn et al., 2011). Furthermore, in vivo pig
experiments clearly demonstrated that raloxifene was meta-
bolized to a high extent by intestinal glucuronidation in pigs
and the metabolite formed was the same as that formed in
¨
humans (Thorn et al., 2012).
In the study presented in this article, we qualitatively
identified phase I and phase II metabolites of finasteride in
pig plasma, urine, and bile and compared the results with
those obtained from an in vitro experiment using human liver
microsomes. An important aim of this study was to examine
the validity of the pig model in terms of the metabolite profile
of finasteride as well as to confirm or reject previously
published structural data based on results from low resolution
MS. This is, to the best of the authors’ knowledge, the first
study on the metabolism of finasteride in pigs. We used state-
of-the-art high resolution mass spectrometry [UPLC-Q-TOF-
MS(/MS)] to obtain refined information on the structures of
the metabolites found.
CYP enzymes involved in the formation of the
hydroxylated metabolites MX and MY
A qualitative approach was applied to achieve more know-
ledge about the CYP enzymes involved in the formation of
MX and MY. Finasteride incubations with human recombin-
ant enzymes CYP3A4, CYP2D6, CYP3A5, CYP2C8,
CYP2C9, CYP2C18 and CYP2C19 were performed and the
samples were analyzed. The CYP3A4 enzymes resulted in the
production of MX and MY (Figure 3A–C), while incubations
with human recombinant CYP2D6 enzymes resulted only in
the production of a metabolite with similar retention time and
product ion spectrum as MY (Figure 3D, E). None of the
other enzymes tested produced hydroxylated finasteride
metabolites in detectable concentrations.
In our study from 2009, the structures of MX and MY were
elucidated with a combination of the low resolution tech-
niques tandem quadrupole MS/MS and ion trap MSn. From
the MS analyses, it was suggested that MX was a ring-closed
lactol form of M1 and that MY could be identical to the
previously described 6a-OH finasteride, M4 (Lundahl et al.,
2009b). In this study, we had the possibility to use a more
advanced Q-TOF mass spectrometer giving accurate mass
data which can be used for calculation of elemental compos-
itions of the intact compounds and their fragments.
Interestingly, the metabolite profile of the pigs were in good
agreement with that of the latest in vivo human study
(Lundahl et al., 2009b) as well as with that of human liver
microsomes. MX, MY and their intact glucuronides as well
as M3 were identified in pig urine and bile (Figure 2 and
Tables 1B, 2A and B, 3A and B). In this study, traces of M1
were found in the pig urine and bile samples. However, this
apparent discrepancy with the previous human study
was probably owing to the fact that a more sensitive mass
spectrometer was used in this study. It might not have been
possible to separate MX from M1 with the techniques used in
the earlier studies and therefore M1 was described as the
major metabolite in plasma (Carlin et al., 1992). The
later quantitative investigations using more selective LC-
MS/MS techniques were only directed towards finasteride,
M1 and M3 (Lundahl et al., 2009a, 2011). A determination of
the concentrations of MX and MY were not possible at the
time as no reference standards of these compounds were
available.
Discussion
Two metabolites of finasteride, M1 (!-OH) and M3
(!-COOH), were in an early study described as the major
human plasma and urine biotransformation products (Carlin
et al., 1992). However, in a later study by our group,
contradictory results were found as M1 was not present in
quantifiable concentrations in any of the examined human
plasma, urine or bile samples whereas M3 was confirmed to be
the major metabolite (Lundahl et al., 2009a,b). Instead of M1,
two other hydroxylated metabolites, denoted MX and MY and
the MY glucuronide were identified in human bile and urine
(Lundahl et al., 2009b). Traces of M3 glucuronide could
also be identified in human bile. Recently, we performed a
drug–drug interaction investigation in pigs utilizing an
advanced pig model that enabled bile sampling directly from
the biliary duct (Lundahl et al., 2011). In that study, we aimed
to follow the finasteride, M1, and M3 concentrations over time.
However, the previously described main human metabolite M1
was not present in quantifiable concentrations in pig bile,
plasma or urine which was in agreement with the latter human
study (Lundahl et al., 2009a).
The high-resolution data obtained in this study corrobo-
rated most of the structural suggestions of the fragments that
were previously obtained by our group with low resolution
MS (Lundahl et al., 2009b). One important exception, though,
Previous knowledge from pigs suggests that the metabol-
ism in this species has similarities to that of humans. In a
recent report, the most abundant CYP subfamilies in pigs