824
P. Bach et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 24 (2014) 821–827
Table 1 (continued)
Compd
No
R1
stereo
a
-C
R1
ACDa pKa
of R1
R2
stereo
a
-C
R2
R3
APC,
IC50
Thrombin,
IC50 M)
APC/
thrombin
ratio
FXa,
IC50
FXIa,
IC50
(lM)
ACDa
logD
pH7.4
logDb,
pH7.4
(lM)
(
l
(lM)
H
N
27
28
S
10.2
10.5
R
CH2-cy-hex
CH2-cy-hex
CH2CO2H
CH2CO2H
3.1
1.3
26
8.4
9.1
—
—
>44
À2.53
À3.07
—
—
*
HN
rac
R
12
—
*
29
30
31
rac
rac
rac
10.6
10.6
10.6
R
R
R
CH2-cy-hex
cy-hex
CH2CO2H
CH2CO2H
H
0.92
>44
3.1
22
23
1
>130
—
>44
—
À2.67
À3.38
À5.78
<0
—
HN
HN
HN
*
*
*
>44
28
CH2-cy-hex
8.9
—
—
—
a
The pKa values of the R1 functionalities in the corresponding protonated forms and the lipophilicity of the compounds, expressed by logD at pH 7.4, were calculated using
the software package from Advanced Chemical Design, Inc.
b
logD at pH 7.4 was determined by a chromatographic method. cy-hex = cyclohexyl.
for binding to the S2 pocket of APC, and all synthesized compounds
with (R)-amino acids in this position were inactive, as exemplified
by the pair of diastereomers 25/26. Further investigations of basic
side-chains with amine functionalities presented compounds 27–
was added to reach approximately 5% FVIII level. Ellagic acid, a
known FXII activator (up-stream to FVIII and FIX), was also added
to amplify the thrombin signal from the internal pathway. The re-
sults from this method are shown in Figure 3 and Table 3. The area
under the curve represents the total thrombin activity (endoge-
nous thrombin potential, ETP) in the sample and was shown to de-
crease when thrombomodulin was added, due to APC-induced
inhibition of thrombin formation. When an APC inhibiting anti-
body was added as positive control, the ETP was restored to the le-
vel when no thrombomodulin was present.
29, of which 29 showed an affinity of 0.91 lM for APC and a
remarkable 23-fold selectivity vs thrombin. Replacement of the
CH2-cyclohexyl R2 substituent of 29 with a cyclohexyl gave 30,
which was inactive both vs APC and thrombin. In the Servier series,
replacement of the cyclohexyl R2 substituent of compound 1
(Fig. 1) with a CH2-cyclohexyl substituent led to an 8-fold increase
in inhibition of APC (from IC50 = 0.82
l
M to 0.10
l
M), but also to a
Both compound 1 and compound 29 showed activity starting at
their IC50 for APC. However, while compound 1 (Fig. 4, Table 3)
showed a decreasing ETP with increasing concentration of 1, com-
pound 29 (Fig. 5, Table 3) showed an increase in ETP towards nor-
malisation with increasing concentration. Compounds 1 and 29
both shifted lagtime and time to peak to the right (Figs. 4 and 5, Ta-
ble 3). The tendency with right shifted time to peak is often seen
when more thrombin is formed in the system due to that the peak
in thrombin formation then occurs later. The delay in lagtime is
probably due to coagulation factor inhibition since it is most pro-
nounced at higher concentrations where the coagulation inhibition
is substantial.
These results are surprising as both 1 and 29 have the same
selectivity for APC towards thrombin (21 and 23-fold, respectively)
and also the selectivity ratios against FXa (immediately up-stream
to thrombin, 28 and >140, respectively) and FXIa (up-stream to FXa
and FIXa in the internal pathway, >26 and >48, respectively) seem
reasonable. Both compounds were also inactive against FIXa at
lowering of selectivity for APC over thrombin from 57-fold to 13-
fold. This shows that the SAR does not translate directly between
the two series. Replacement of the acidic R3 substituent of com-
pound 29 with hydrogen gave 31 which showed a 3.5-fold reduc-
tion in affinity (to 3.1 lM) and a reduced selectivity vs thrombin
compared to 29.
Introduction of aromatic groups as R1 substituents, exemplified
by compounds 33–35 (Table 2), led to inhibitory effects on the le-
vel of 29, however with lower selectivity for APC over thrombin. In
comparison to benzyl compound 33, substitution in the benzyl 4-
position (compounds 36–39), led to an increased selectivity over
thrombin only for the phenolic derivative 36. Interestingly, this
derivative also showed significant selectivity levels over FXa and
FXIa. The anilinic derivative 37 turned out to be the strongest
inhibitor of APC with however a decreased selectivity over throm-
bin compared to 33. Nitrile and methylamino derivatives 38 and 39
both showed decreases in inhibition of APC and in selectivity over
thrombin compared to 33.
The efficiency of compounds 1 and 29, which showed similar
inhibitory constants and selectivity for APC over thrombin, was
evaluated by a modified thrombin generation assay known as the
Calibrated Automated Thrombogram (CAT) method, using citrated
plasma from patients with severe haemophilia A.21 This method
was based on activation of coagulation and APC by addition of tis-
sue factor and thrombomodulin, respectively. To speed up throm-
bin generation, a small fraction of normal human pooled plasma
100
FVIIa on the external pathway show an interesting difference with
1 having an IC50 of 8.9 M (selectivity ratio 5.2) while compound
29 was inactive against FVIIa (IC50 > 133 M, selectivity ratio
lM (see Supplementary material). However, the analysis of
l
l
>140). Thus, most likely the high selectivity against relevant coag-
ulation factors explains the higher therapeutic potential of com-
pound 29 in comparison to compound 1 since inhibition of the
anti-coagulant APC can be achieved while retaining the pro-coagu-
lant effect in plasma.