CHEMBIOCHEM
FULL PAPERS
tionate with the sustained antimicrobial activity. Ala1, Ala4,
and Ala6, in which d-Val1, d-Ser4, and l-Ser6 have been re-
placed, have a similar spectrum to the natural peptide and
also have similar antimicrobial activity. The next group of ana-
logues, Ala3, Ala11, and Ala7, have similar spectra with a greatly
reduced negative band, which correlates to a roughly two- to
fourfold reduction in activity against sensitive Gram-negative
organisms. The CD spectra of the remaining analogues were
more revealing. Substituting d-Dab8 with d-Ala abolished both
the antimicrobial activity and the secondary structure, whereas
d-Trp5-d-Ala and d-allo-Ile12-d-Ala substitutions both led to
an average eightfold decrease in antimicrobial activity. The re-
maining analogues, Ala2 and Ala9, also showed a substantial
decrease in activity against some Gram-negative bacteria. The
overall trend in these results is that the magnitude of the neg-
ative band at 194 nm in the CD spectra of the tridecaptin A1
analogues correlates directly to their antimicrobial activity. Res-
idues d-Trp5, d-Dab8, and d-allo-Ile12 are required for effective
folding of octyl-tridecaptin A1 in a phospholipid bilayer, likely
directly affecting the ability of the peptides to kill Gram-nega-
tive bacteria.
proportional. The least active analogues did not adopt a secon-
dary structure in the presence of the phospholipid LUVs.
This study shows that a combination of alanine scanning
and CD spectroscopy are an effective tool for analyzing the
structures of peptides as they pertain to antimicrobial activity.
The results suggest tridecaptin A1 exerts its bactericidal effect
through an interaction with or in the bacterial membrane, pos-
sibly involving a chiral receptor. Further studies are underway
to probe the nature of this interaction.
Experimental Section
General information: NMR spectra were recorded on a Varian
1
Inova 500 or 600 spectrometer. For H NMR spectra, d values were
referenced to D2O (4.79 ppm) or [D6]DMSO (2.50 ppm). HRMS spec-
tra were recorded on an Agilent Technologies 6220 oaTOF by elec-
trospray ionization (ESI). Matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization
(MALDI) MS/MS analysis was performed on a Bruker Ultraflextreme
MALDI TOF/TOF. 4-Hydroxy-a-cyanocinnamic acid was used as
a matrix. Peptides were purified on a a Gilson Preparative HPLC
system equipped with a model 322 HPLC pump, a GX-271 liquid
handler, a 156 UV/Vis detector, and a 10 mL sample loop. A Phe-
nomenex C18 column (5 mm, 21.2ꢁ250 mm) was used for prepara-
tive scale purification. HPLC solvents were filtered with a Millipore
filtration system under vacuum before use.
To account for the selectivity of octyl-tridecaptin A1 for bac-
teria over human cells, we also measured the CD spectrum in
the presence of neutral LUVs, which mimic the mammalian
membrane.[9,10] The peptide adopted the same secondary
structure (see the Supporting Information), which suggests the
bactericidal effect might be due to more than membrane dis-
ruption. To further corroborate this theory, the enantiomer of
octyl-tridecaptin A1, Ent-Oct-TriA1, was synthesized and tested
against the organisms in Table 1. Although activity against the
Gram-positive organisms was mostly unaffected, there was a
marked decrease in activity against the Gram-negative organ-
isms; this suggests there could also be a chiral receptor in-
volved in the mode of action. Studies are currently underway
to undercover the full mode of action of tridecaptin A1.
Peptide synthesis: Solid-phase peptide synthesis was performed
on a 100 or 50 mmol scale by using Fmoc chemistry on preloaded
Fmoc-Ala-Wang resin (100–200 mesh, Novabiochem, #856001).
Reactions were performed in 12 mL polypropylene solid-phase
extraction tubes, fitted with a 20 mm polyethylene frit (Aldrich,
#57176). The resin was gently stirred with a magnetic stirrer. The
resin was preswollen by addition of DMF (5 mL, 10 min) while stir-
ring. Between deprotections and couplings, the vessel was drained
and washed with DMF (3ꢁ5 mL). The Fmoc group was removed
by stirring with 20% piperidine in DMF (2ꢁ5 mLꢁ2 min; 1ꢁ5 mLꢁ
10 min). The deprotection steps were monitored by spotting each
filtrate on a silica gel TLC plate and visualizing the benzofulvene
piperidine adduct with a 254 nm UV lamp. The appropriate amino
acid (5 equiv) was preactivated by shaking with HATU (5 equiv)
and DIPEA (10 equiv) in DMF (5 mL) for 5 min. The resin was stirred
in the coupling solution for 1 h, drained, and washed with DMF
(3ꢁ5 mL). The deprotection and coupling steps were continued to
complete the peptide synthesis. The resin-bound peptide was
washed with CH2Cl2 (3ꢁ5 mL) and dried under argon for
20 min.The resin was transferred to a screw-top vial containing
TFA/TIPS/H2O (95:2.5:2.5, 5 mL) and was shaken for 2 h. The cleav-
age mixture was filtered and concentrated in vacuo, and the pep-
tide was precipitated with ether. The crude peptide was dissolved
in H2O/MeCN (1:1, 5 mL) and purified by preparative-scale C18-RP-
HPLC: Phenomenex C18 column, flow rate 10 mLminÀ1, detected at
220 nm. Gradient: starting from 20% MeCN (0.1% TFA) and 80%
water (0.1% TFA) for 5 min, increasing to 55% MeCN over 30 min,
then increasing to 95% MeCN over 3 min, remaining at 95% MeCN
for 3 min, decreasing to 20% MeCN over 2 min, then remaining at
20% MeCN for 5 min. Pure product-containing fractions were
pooled, concentrated, frozen, and lyophilized to yield the product
as a white powder. Peptide sequences and structure were con-
firmed by HRMS, NMR, and/or MS/MS analysis.
Conclusions
An alanine scan of the lipopeptide octyl-tridecaptin A1 showed
that the residues d-Trp5, d-Dab8, and d-allo-Ile12 are necessary
for activity against Gram-negative bacteria, whereas substitu-
tion of all other amino acids was well tolerated. Of particular
note is d-Dab8, which was essential for antimicrobial activity.
The short linear sequence of tridecaptin A1 makes it well suited
for chemical synthesis, and the information derived from this
alanine scan could guide the synthesis of more active and/or
less toxic analogues.
Tridecaptin A1 and its octyl analogue are disordered in aque-
ous media and 50% trifluoroethanol, with no discernable sec-
ondary structure. However, the peptides adopt a definite sec-
ondary structure in the presence of 50 nm phospholipid LUVs.
Although trifluoroethanol is often the solvent of choice for in-
ducing structures in membrane-associated peptides and pro-
teins, our results suggest that this is not always an effective
model for membrane-interacting peptides. The activity of the
alanine scan analogues and their ability to adopt a secondary
structure in the model membrane environment are directly
Peptide characterization: See the Supporting Information.
Bacterial growth conditions: All cultures were grown from glycer-
ol stocks. Organisms (excluding C. jejuni) were grown in Mueller
ꢀ 2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ChemBioChem 2014, 15, 1295 – 1299 1298