1202
S. Mostert et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 26 (2016) 1200–1204
H
N
O
100
75
50
25
0
N H
O
O
O
O
16
15
Br
MAO-A: IC50 = 0.233 µM
MAO-B: IC50 = 0.009 µM
MAO-A: IC50 = 0.22 µM
MAO-B: IC50 = 0.0069 µM
MAO-B
-3
MAO-A
Figure 5. The structures of isatin (15) and phthalimide (16) analogues, both
reported MAO inhibitors.19,20
were combined with the irreversible inhibitors, pargyline (MAO-A)
and (R)-deprenyl (MAO-B), and dialysed. For reversible inhibitors,
enzyme activity is expected to recover to 100% of the negative con-
trol value following dialysis. For irreversible inhibition, enzyme
activity is not recovered by dialysis. The results are given in
Figure 6, and show that, upon inhibition by 7c, both MAO-A and
MAO-B activities are recovered by dialysis to 93% and 78%, respec-
tively. The MAO activities in undialysed mixtures of the MAOs and
7c, in contrast are 73% and 39%, respectively. This result show that
7c is a reversible inhibitor of both MAO isoforms. As expected, after
dialysis of mixtures of the MAOs and the irreversible inhibitors,
pargyline and (R)-deprenyl, enzyme activity is not recovered with
MAO-A and MAO-B at 0.9% and 4.8%, respectively, of the negative
control.
-4
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
Log[I], µM
Figure 3. The sigmoidal plots for the inhibition of MAO-A (filled circles) and MAO-B
(open circles) by 7c.
studies employing identical experimental conditions to the current
study. Although weaker as MAO-A inhibitors, two compounds dis-
play good MAO-A inhibition. These are 7b and 7c with IC50 values
of 0.424
ically used reversible MAO-A inhibitor, toloxatone (14), inhibits
MAO-A with an IC50 value of 3.92
M.27 These compounds as well
as 7d (IC50 = 2.55 M) are thus more potent MAO-A inhibitors than
toloxatone. This study also finds that 6-hydroxy-1,3-benzoxathiol-
2-one (11) is a weak MAO-B inhibitor with an IC50 of 9.57 M. This
lM and 0.189 lM, respectively. For comparison, the clin-
l
l
To investigate the mode (e.g., competitive) of MAO-A and MAO-
B inhibition by 7c, Lineweaver–Burk plots were constructed. For
each MAO isoform a set consisting of six Lineweaver–Burk plots
was constructed by measuring the enzyme activities in the pres-
l
shows that the C6 substituent is indeed a requirement for potent
MAO-B inhibition by the benzoxathiolone analogues, and is in
agreement with similar findings with other heterocycles, such as
isatins (e.g., 8) and phthalimides (e.g., 9), for which an appropriate
side chain also is a requirement for MAO-B inhibition.19,20 Based on
the inhibition potencies it may thus be concluded that, similar to
the isatins and phthalimides reported previously, benzoxathi-
olones represent a class of highly potent MAO-B inhibitors. When
comparing 7a with the corresponding isatin and phthalimide
homologues, it is evident that 7a is a more potent MAO-B inhibitor
than 5-benzyloxyisatin (8; IC50 = 0.103
5-benzyloxyphthalimide (9; IC50 = 0.043
show that with the appropriate substitution good MAO-A inhibi-
tion may be obtained with the benzoxathiolones. Good MAO-A
inhibitors also exist among the reported isatins and phthalimides
ence of the following inhibitor concentrations: 0
l
M, ¼ Â IC50
,
½ Â IC50, ¾ Â IC50, 1 Â IC50 and 1¼ Â IC50. For each plot, eight dif-
ferent substrate (kynuramine) concentrations were used, ranging
from 15 to 250 lM. The results are given in Figure 7 and show that,
for both MAO-A and MAO-B inhibition, the lines are linear and
intersect on the y-axis. This is in agreement with a competitive
mode of inhibition of both MAO-A and MAO-B by 7c. By plotting
the slopes of the Lineweaver–Burk plots versus the inhibitor con-
centration, Ki values of 0.36 lM and 0.0035 lM for the inhibition
l
l
M) and equipotent to
of MAO-A and MAO-B, respectively, are estimated. The Ki values
can also be determined by global (shared) fitting of the inhibition
data directly to the Michaelis–Menten equation. This yielded sim-
ilar results with Ki values of 0.56 0.07
M (R2 = 0.98)
0.0039 0.0005 M for the inhibition of MAO-A
and MAO-B, respectively.
M).19,20 The results also
lM
(R2 = 0.99) and
l
l
as exemplified by 15 (IC50 = 0.233 lM) and 16 (IC50 = 0.22 lM)
(Fig. 5).19,20
Since benzoxathiolone analogues show good promise as MAO
inhibitors, selected properties were measured for the series as part
of a preliminary investigation of the suitability of these compounds
as drugs. For this purpose, the lipophilicity (logP) and aqueous sol-
ubility of the compounds were experimentally determined and are
listed in Table 2. Log P was determined with the shake-flask
method and represents the partitioning of the test compounds
between n-octanol and water. The logP value, in general, provides
an estimation of how readily a compound may diffuse passively
across the lipid bilayer, an important process for absorption from
the gastrointestinal tract and permeation across the blood–brain
barrier. It is generally accepted that, for a compound to display
good oral bioavailability and blood–brain barrier permeation, the
logP value should be in a range of 0–3.28 The logP values of the
benzoxathiolone analogues are 3.80–5.61, indicating that a high
degree of lipophilicity may be a concern, particularly from a solu-
As mentioned, reversibility of MAO inhibition is an important
consideration in inhibitor design. This study thus investigates the
reversibility of MAO-A and MAO-B inhibition by a selected ben-
zoxathiolone analogue, compound 7c. To examine the reversibility
of inhibition, the MAO enzymes and test inhibitor (at a concentra-
tion of 4 Â IC50) were combined for 15 min and subsequently dial-
ysed for 24 h. As negative control, similar dialysis of the MAOs in
absence of inhibitor was carried out. As positive controls, the MAOs
O
O
O
N
NH2
N
H
N
OH
Cl
12
Lazabemide (
)
Toloxatone (14)
bility point of view. Indeed, the aqueous solubilities are <0.081 lM
NH2
N
H
and may be considered to be in the very weak solubility range. To
improve the properties of the benzoxathiolone analogues, this
study recommends that in future studies polar, and possibly ionis-
able groups should by incorporated in the C6 side chain to reduce
lipophilicity and improve solubility. This would yield compounds
F
O
O
13
Safinamide(
)
Figure 4. The structures of reference MAO inhibitors.