RESEARCH
fluorinations (21), arylations (22), and other
C–C bond formations (23). However, because
of the gaseous nature and the low solubility of
light alkanes in organic solvents, we reasoned
that the use of flow technology is indispens-
able to facilitate the gas-liquid decatungstate-
mediated processes (Fig. 1C) (24). The short
length scales in microflow reactors (typically
<1-mm optical path) provide a homogeneous
irradiation of the entire reaction medium,
allowing for the efficient generation of alkyl
radicals (25). Furthermore, by increasing the
pressure in the reactor through use of opera-
tionally simple back-pressure regulators, the
gaseous alkanes can be forced into the liquid
phase, increasing the odds of C(sp3)–H bond
activation through decatungstate photocatalysis
(26). Finally, flow processing of these combusti-
ble gases can be done safely in microreactors,
and the conditions can be readily scaled (27, 28).
Among all volatile alkanes, methane is the
hardest one to activate because of high BDE
of these C–H bonds (BDE = 105 kcal/mol)
(Fig. 1B) (29). However, if we can successfully
split methane bonds with decatungstate HAT
photocatalysis, cleaving the C–H bond in ethane
(BDE = 101 kcal/mol) and other volatile aliphatic
feedstock materials, such as propane (BDE =
99 kcal/mol) and isobutane (BDE = 96.5 kcal/
mol), should be within reach. Indeed, we car-
ried out trapping experiments with TEMPO
(tetramethylpiperidine-1-oxyl), a stable aminoxyl
radical, and the trapped adducts of methane,
ethane, propane, and isobutane gave credence
to the feasibility of our approach (Fig. 1D). No-
tably, because of the stability of the generated
radical and the lower BDE of the C–H bond,
high selectivity was observed for the formation
of secondary and tertiary C(sp3)–O bonds from
propane and isobutane, which is in contrast to
a recently reported HAT approach using alkoxy
radicals (14).
We began our investigation into the proposed
C(sp3)–H functionalization of light hydrocarbons
by exposing isobutane and benzylidenemalononi-
trile in the presence of tetrabutylammonium
decatungstate (TBADT) in acetonitrile:H2O
(7:1), which provides both good solubility and
good reactivity of the photocatalyst, to UV-A
light [365-nm light-emitting diodes (LEDs),
60 W]. For a number of substrates, limited
solubility was observed upon addition of water.
However, this could be circumvented by car-
rying out the reactions in neat acetonitrile.
Furthermore, acetonitrile, despite the relatively
low BDE (96 to 97 kcal/mol) of its C–H bonds
(30), is also inert under the given HAT reaction
conditions. This can be attributed to a polarity
mismatch between decatungstate and the
C(sp3)–H bonds in acetonitrile. All the experi-
ments were carried out in a standardized,
commercially available Vapourtec UV-150 pho-
tochemical flow reactor, which should enable
reproducibility of the results. After careful
ORGANIC CHEMISTRY
C(sp3)–H functionalizations of light hydrocarbons
using decatungstate photocatalysis in flow
Gabriele Laudadio1*, Yuchao Deng1,2,3*, Klaas van der Wal1, Davide Ravelli4, Manuel Nuño5,
Maurizio Fagnoni4, Duncan Guthrie5, Yuhan Sun2,3, Timothy Noël1†
Direct activation of gaseous hydrocarbons remains a major challenge for the chemistry community.
Because of the intrinsic inertness of these compounds, harsh reaction conditions are typically
required to enable C(sp3)–H bond cleavage, barring potential applications in synthetic organic chemistry.
Here, we report a general and mild strategy to activate C(sp3)–H bonds in methane, ethane, propane,
and isobutane through hydrogen atom transfer using inexpensive decatungstate as photocatalyst
at room temperature. The corresponding carbon-centered radicals can be effectively trapped by a
variety of Michael acceptors, leading to the corresponding hydroalkylated adducts in good isolated
yields and high selectivity (38 examples).
ne of the most challenging reactions in
organic synthesis is the selective func-
tionalization of C(sp3)–H bonds that
lack activation by proximal functional
groups (1). The conversion of light
can be easily converted into organometallic
reagents, which can be engaged as nucleophiles
in a variety of transition metal–catalyzed C–C
bond forming reactions (9).
O
A general synthetic strategy that enables the
selective and direct activation of a diverse set
of light hydrocarbons under mild reaction
conditions remains a challenge, suffering from
at least one drawback with regard to substrate
scope (10–13), practicality, and selectivity (14).
The development of such a transformation
would be particularly useful, given the broad
availability and the inexpensive nature of these
starting materials. Furthermore, the reduction
in synthetic steps would allow for streamlined
reaction sequences and decreased waste gener-
ation. However, we reasoned that two funda-
mental problems needed to be addressed to
succeed: First, a suitable transformation would
require the selective cleavage of very strong
aliphatic C–H bonds [bond dissociation energy
(BDE) = 96.5 to 105 kcal/mol] (Fig. 1B), and
second, the handling of these gaseous alkanes
presents several technological challenges to
bring them into close proximity with a suitable
catalyst and reaction partner.
alkanes to high–value added chemicals has
especially been a key objective for the synthetic
community in the past decades, yet with limited
success so far (2–4). Up to now, strategies to
introduce such alkyl fragments into organic
scaffolds necessitate prefunctionalization of
the hydrocarbons to increase their reactivity
(Fig. 1A). Volatile alkanes are typically con-
verted into alkyl electrophiles through halo-
genation by using chlorine or bromine gas at
elevated temperatures (>500°C) or by using
light activation (5, 6). These radical chain pro-
cesses result in low-yielding and unselective
transformations, with demands for subsequent
energy-intensive and elaborate purification and
recycling processes [for the effluent guidelines
in the chlorine and chlorinated hydrocarbon
manufacturing industry, see (7)]. Despite the
apparent drawbacks, these classical halo-
genation strategies are being carried out on a
multi–metric ton scale to prepare a variety of
halogenated compounds that are key for the
production of most pharmaceuticals, agrochem-
icals, materials, and other industrial chemicals
(8). In synthetic organic chemistry, alkyl halides
are widely used as electrophiles in nucleophilic
substitution reactions or serve as substrates for
elimination reactions to install double bonds
regioselectively. Furthermore, alkyl halides
Seeking to address these challenges, we
wondered if a photoexcited decatungstate
anion (*[W10O32]
4−) could sunder effectively
the strong and nonactivated C–H bonds of
light alkanes (Fig. 1A). W10O324− is a versatile
and inexpensive polyoxometalate-based hydro-
gen atom transfer (HAT) photocatalyst that can
abstract hydrogen atoms from C(sp3)–H frag-
ments upon activation by near–ultraviolet
(UV) light irradiation (~365 nm) (15–18). The
resulting carbon-centered radicals are nucleo-
philic and might be readily engaged in C–C
bond forming reactions, thereby effectively
bypassing the requirement for more-elaborate
reaction strategies while expanding the syn-
thetic toolbox of available alkyl reagents. To
1Micro Flow Chemistry and Synthetic Methodology,
Department of Chemical Engineering and Chemistry,
Eindhoven University of Technology, Eindhoven, Netherlands.
2School of Physical Science and Technology, ShanghaiTech
University, Shanghai 201210, P. R. China. 3Shanghai
Advanced Research Institute, Chinese Academy of Sciences,
Shanghai 201210, P. R. China. 4PhotoGreen Lab, Department
of Chemistry, University of Pavia, Pavia 27100, Italy.
5Vapourtec, Fornham St Genevieve, Bury St Edmunds,
Suffolk IP28 6TS, UK.
4−
date, W10O32 photocatalysis has enabled a
number of synthetically useful C(sp3)–H func-
tionalizations, including oxidations (19, 20),
*These authors contributed equally to this work.
†Corresponding author. Email: t.noel@tue.nl
Laudadio et al., Science 369, 92–96 (2020)
3 July 2020
1 of 5