2
Tetrahedron Letters
2. Results and Discussion
Carboxylic acid synthon 4 was prepared by basic hydrolysis of
the commercially available ethyl ester 5.6,7 However, the
literature did not provide a method for isolating this water-
soluble compound. After some optimization we found that
treatment of ester 5 with KOH in water, followed by addition of
concentrated HCl and saturation of the aqueous layer with solid
NaCl allowed for extraction of the desired acid 4 with a solvent
mixture of chloroform and isopropanol (Scheme 1).8
Scheme 1. Preparation and isolation of 2-oxo-3-piperidinecarboxylic acid (4)
We initially attempted to couple the carboxylic acid 4 with
serotonin-HCl (1) by activating the acid using carbodiimide
reagents9 as well as through mixed anhydride formation.10 In the
case of the carbodiimide reagents, a small amount of HIOC was
detected via LC-MS, but could not be isolated. Attempts to
activate 4 with methyl chloroformate furnished the methyl ester
of 4 as the only identifiable product. Efforts using pivaloyl
chloride were also unsuccessful, resulting only in pivaloylation
of the primary amine of serotonin. After screening additional
methods we found that the carboxylic acid could be activated
with carbonyl diimidazole (CDI).11 Addition of CDI to an
opaque suspension of carboxylic acid 4 in dichloromethane
provided complete conversion to the soluble N-acyl imidazole
derivative 6 (Scheme 2). Addition of serotonin-HCl (1) to
intermediate 6 gave some conversion to the desired amide 3.
This acylation procedure was plagued by the poor solubility of
serotonin-HCl in CH2Cl2, and N,O-bisacylated product 7 was
often observed from these heterogeneous reaction conditions,
along with some recovered unacylated serotonin. However,
dimethylformamide (DMF) solubilized all reaction components,
giving 66% conversion to HIOC (3) after 3 hours, along with
only 6% of the bisacylated product 7 (Table 1, entry 1). The
product 3 was very difficult to extract from an aqueous acidic
workup of the reaction mixture, so we sought an alternative to
DMF as the solvent.
Scheme 2. Acylation of serotonin with carboxylic acid 4
Table 1. Optimization of Reaction Conditions
entry
solvents
conversion by 1H NMR
serotonin-HCl
(1)
HIOC
(3)
7
1
2
3
DMFa
25%
68%
33%
66%
29%
66%
6%
3%
<1%
1 : 1 CH2Cl2 : Et3Nb
1 : 1 CH2Cl2 : pyridineb
a CDI was added to a 0.3 M solution of 4 in DMF. After 30 min, another
volume of DMF was added followed by 1 equiv of 1.
b CDI was added to a 0.3 M suspension of 4 in CH2Cl2. After aging 30
min, an equal volume of base (triethylamine or pyridine) was added,
followed by 1 equiv of 1.
Adding an equal volume of triethylamine to the reaction
mixture in CH2Cl2 prior to the addition of serotonin-HCl (1) gave
some conversion to product, however the serotonin-HCl was not
completely solubilized, leading to a small amount of bisacylated
product 7 (entry 2). On the other hand, addition of an equal
volume of pyridine (~40 equivalents prior to addition of
serotonin-HCl 1) resulted in a completely homogeneous reaction
mixture (entry 3). After 3 hours, the reaction had proceeded to
66% conversion and high chemoselectivity favoring HIOC (3),
with only a trace amount of N,O-bisacylated product detected by
NMR.12 The addition of 2 equivalents of triethylamine helped to
push the reaction to completion over the course of 3 hours,
bringing the conversion up to ~85% (Scheme 3). Isolation of the
product from the reaction mixture was non-trivial. Concentration
of the reaction mixture followed by dry loading of the unwieldy
crude onto a silica gel column allowed for chromatographic
separation with ethyl acetate / methanol (9 : 1) as eluent. The
resulting solid was washed with hot diethyl ether to remove
remaining imidazole impurities to furnish HIOC (3) in 71% yield
(Scheme 3).
Scheme 3. Optimized acylation for the synthesis of HIOC (3)
In summary, we have developed a short, scalable, and highly
reproducible synthesis of HIOC without the need for protective
groups. The key discovery was the utility of the additional
volume of pyridine to the acyl-imidazole species, which helped
to solubilize the serotonin hydrochloride and also may have
behaved as a nucleophilic catalyst.