Q.-D. Ding, et al.
CatalysisCommunications127(2019)69–74
temperature. Mn-MOF was prepared under hydrothermal conditions in
a moderate yield. It should be pointed out that only amorphous powder
was obtained under similar reaction conditions when manganese(II)
salts including Mn(OAc)2∙2H2O and MnSO4∙H2O.
Single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis revealed that Mn-MOF
crystallizes in the monoclinic space group P21/c and the asymmetric
unit contains two Mn(II) ions (Mn1 and Mn2), two 1,4-NDC anions, and
one Fbix ligand. Both Mn1 and Mn2 are five-coordinated by four
oxygen atoms from four 1,4-NDC ligands with the Mn–O distances in
the range of 2.036(2)–2.168(2) Å and one nitrogen atom from Fbix li-
gand with the Mn–N distances of 2.187(2) and 2.236 Å, exhibiting a
distorted square-pyramid geometry (Fig. S1). Each 1,4-NDC ligand is
linked to four Mn(II) ions with two carboxylate groups adopting the μ2-
η1:η1-syn-syn-bridging mode. Adjacent Mn(II) ions are linked in se-
quence by carboxylate groups of 1,4-NDC, forming an 1-D Mn–O–C rod-
shaped chains along the c-axis (Fig. S2). Each chain links four neigh-
boring chains through the 1,4-NDC linkers to generate a 3-D sub fra-
mework (Fig. S3). The Fbix ligand exhibits a trans configuration and
connects the rod-shaped chains together with 1,4-NDC to form the final
3-D framework with the hex net (Figs. 1 and S4) [29].
Fig. 2. Catalyst recycling studies.
catalyst is the reagent molar ratio. A large excess of sodium benzene-
sulfinate should be required for the coupling. Fig. S10 shows the de-
pendence of the yield on the effect of reagent molar ratio. At 3 mol%
Mn-MOF loadings, higher yield was achieved at 110 °C when 3
equivalents of sodium benzenesulfinate were used, while utilization of
lower amounts of sodium benzenesulfinate led to a obvious decrease in
reaction efficiency.
phase purity of the as-synthesized Mn-MOF. The thermal stability was
investigated by the combination of TG analysis and temperature-de-
pendent PXRD patterns (Figs. S6 and S7), suggesting that Mn-MOF can
retain its structure in air up to 300 °C. Moreover, after the bulk samples
were suspended in refluxing water, ethanol, dichloroethane or hot or-
ganic solvents including DMF, NMP and DMSO at 120 °C for 24 h, Mn-
MOF could remain intact without loss of crystallinity (Fig. S8).
Subsequently, the substrate scope of the Mn-MOF-catalyzed dec-
arboxylative sulfonylation reaction was also explored with diverse
substituted cinnamic acids and sodium benzenesulfinates under the
above-mentioned optimal conditions (see Table 2). The Mn-MOF cata-
lyst was found to efficiently catalyze a range of cinnamic acids and
several sodium benzenesulfinates, and the products were isolated in
yields ranging from 42% to 98%. Cinnamic acid derivatives bearing
electron-donating functional groups afforded better yields than the
substrates with electron-withdrawing substituents. Moreover, sodium
benzenesulfinates with 4-H, 4-Me, 4-F and 4-Cl groups substituted on
phenyl rings proceeded smoothly to give the desired vinyl sulfone
products. Between ortho- and meta-methyl or chloride substituents, no
obvious negative steric effect was found. In addition, aliphatic sub-
strates such as 3-methyl-2-butenoic acid and trans-2-hexenoic acid as
well as sodium methane sulfinate have also been examined for the
catalytic system. However, no desired products were obtained.
3.2. Catalytic performance
The decarboxylative sulfonylation of cinnamic acid with sodium
benzene sulfinate was selected as a model reaction using Mn-MOF as
heterogeneous catalyst to study the reaction conditions. First,
a
screening of different solvents revealed that aprotic polar solvents gave
higher yields, where DMSO was found to be the best (Table 1, entries
nylation reported by Deng et al. [15,30–32], the iodine additive is
crucial for this reaction. Then, influence of various reagents on the
reaction was investigated. In the absence of the iodine reagent, the
reaction gave a low yield (entry 8). Significantly enhanced yield was
observed in the presence of KI, and addition of other additives including
I2 and K2CO3 failed to give any positive effect (entries 11 and 12).
Furthermore, when KCl and KBr were employed instead of KI, the re-
actions could proceed smoothly to afford the corresponding product in
moderate to good yields (entries 13 and 14). The results suggested that
iodide anion might act as soft Lewis base to capture soft Lewis acid
carbon cation in this transformation, giving the corresponding vinyl
sulfone products with high yields, which is similar to that observed in
the heterogeneous catalytic process reported by Guo et al. [8]. It was
also found that the reaction in the absence of Mn-MOF catalyst gave
only trace product (entry 15), while the yield was dramatically im-
proved to 93% when 3 mol% Mn-MOF was added to the reaction
mixture. In our previous work, Cu-doped zeolites have been developed
for decarboxylative coupling reactions [33]. For comparison, Mn-con-
Sil-1-10-2 in the reaction system were far less efficient (entries 16–18).
Similar to the homogenous Mn(II)-catalyzed system [15], the presence
action was conducted under N2 atmosphere, yield was significantly
diminished (entry 19).
3.3. Catalyst heterogeneity and reusability
To verify the heterogeneous nature of the Mn-MOF-catalyzed reac-
tion process, the leaching experiments were carried out (Fig. S9). After
removing the solid catalyst, it was found that no further conversion of
cinnamic acid was detected even after 8 h. Moreover, examination by
ICP analysis of the filtrate indicated a negligible amounts (< 1 ppm) of
the manganese. In recycling tests, before the catalyst was reused, the
Mn-MOF catalyst was collected by centrifugation, washed with DMSO
and ethanol, and dried at 60 °C under vacuum in 12 h. The results re-
vealed that the recovered Mn-MOF catalyst could almost maintain its
high activity with no decrease after six consecutive cycles (Fig. 2).
Furthermore, the PXRD pattern of 6th used catalyst indicated that the
Mn-MOF could retain its crystallinity (Fig. S10).
3.4. Proposed mechanism
To understand the reaction pathway better, some control experi-
ments were carried out (Scheme 1). The reaction of 1a with 2a was
radical scavengers, including 2,6-di-tert-butyl-4-methylphenol (BHT)
and 2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-1-piperidinyloxy (TEMPO) (Scheme 1a and b).
BHT was found to suppress the reaction while TEMPO totally stopped
the reaction, which implied that a radical pathway should be involved.
Next, when styrene was employed as a substrate in place of 1a (Scheme
1c), no 3a was observed. The result suggested that styrene is not an
intermediate in the present reaction. Furthermore, it was also found
Fig. S9 shows the dependence of the yield on the effect of reaction
temperature. Indeed, the yield markedly increased at higher tempera-
ture and 110 °C was found to be a relatively optimized temperature,
where the reaction could afford 93% yield after 9 h. Another factor that
should be considered for the cross-coupling reaction over the Mn-MOF
72