ACS Medicinal Chemistry Letters
Letter
Compound 18 showed the preeminent affinity to the σ1
receptor. On this compound, a molecular dynamics (MD)
elongation of the aliphatic portion of the ligands leads to a
better affinity for σ2 receptor.
Once the affinity profiles of the synthesized compounds at σ
receptors were evaluated, we determined the ability of these
compounds to release NO. Nitrite content was measured by
the Griess method incubating the compounds (100 μM), at 37
°C, in Tris-HCl buffer for 30 min (Figure 2).
μM for compound 9 and 26 μM for compound 15. None of
the synthesized compounds, nor compound 21, were
demonstrated to be toxic for the human fibroblasts HFF-1 at
the maximal tested concentration. Compounds 18 and 19 have
been shown to be nontoxic for the three evaluated cell lines
(IC50 > 100 μM), probably due to the lower rate of NO release
and to an unsuitable functional profile at σ receptors.
In order to determinate the precise mechanism for the
reduction of cellular viability, compound 15 (IC50 concen-
tration) was evaluated in combination with the σ1 receptor
agonist (+)-PTZ (1 μM) and the σ2 receptor antagonist 1-
phenethylpiperidine (AC927, 1 μM) by MTT.30
Incubation of compound 15 with (+)-PTZ or AC927 wholly
restored the loss of cell viability induced by 15 alone (Figure
3). This outlines a σ1 and σ2 receptors involvement in the
observed cellular events and a σ1 receptor antagonist/σ2
receptor agonist functional profile for compound 15.
Figure 2. Total nitrite content measured using Griess reagent.
For this assay, we selected the compounds based on their
affinity profile against σ receptors. In particular, we evaluated
compounds 9, 11, 15, and 17−19, having shown good affinity
at both receptors or prevalence for one receptor subtype.
Compounds 9 and 15 were able to release a significant amount
of NO in the μM range (9, 13.0 0.5 μM; 15, 13.0 0.4
μM). The amount of NO released by compound 18 was 1.3
0.2 μM, while compound 19 produced 6.3
0.3 μM NO.
Negligible NO amounts were detected for compounds 11 and
17 (data not shown).
Figure 3. Effects of compound 15 in combination with the selective
σ1 receptor agonist (+)-PTZ and σ2 receptor antagonist AC927 on
MCF-7 and Caco-2 viability by MTT test.
After having obtained the desired chemical tools, we
evaluated their activity in the appropriate cell lines. We
evaluated those compounds that, in previous experiments, have
been demonstrated to possess the desired profile (compounds
9, 15, 18, and 19). Two cancer cell lines were selected, Caco-2
and MCF-7 cells, for their expression of both σ receptors.
Although MCF-7 cells are reported to exclusively express the
σ2 subtypes, a Western blot analysis has shown the presence of
the σ1 isoform in our in-house cell line (Figure S4).29 The
toxicity against human fibroblast HFF-1 cells was also
evaluated. Doxorubicin (21) was used as the standard
cytotoxic compound. Results showed a reduction of cellular
viability on both Caco-2 and MCF-7 cell lines for compounds
9 and 15 (Table 2). These compounds were those with a
higher rate of NO release. Measured IC50 values were better
with respect to compound 21 for MCF-7 cells, with IC50 of 36
To dig into the dual mechanism of the prepared compounds,
we tested fragments 5 and 22a,b and synthesized two
derivatives of compound 15 lacking the nitrate function,
compounds 23a and 23b, as negative control (Table 3 and
The fragments 5 and 22a,b have shown no significant
viability reduction on MCF-7 and no affinity for both σ
receptors. Compound 23a showed a loss of affinity at both σ
receptors, while compound 23b retained a similar affinity
profile at both σ receptors with respect to compound 9 or 15.
When evaluated on the MCF-7 cell line, compound 23a
induced lower than 50% viability reduction at 100 μM, while
compound 23b had an IC50 of 87 μM. Overall compound 23b,
while maintaining a similar profile against σ receptors, showed
a lower ability in reducing MCF-7 viability, thus sustaining a
possible synergistic effect between σ receptors and the NO-
mediated events.
In conclusion, this contribution reports the development of
novel hybrid compounds able to release NO and to bind σ
receptors as candidates for double-targeted cancer therapy.
The compounds have been evaluated for their affinity at σ
receptors and ability to release NO. Four compounds showed
the desired profile with compounds 9 and 15 also able to
induce a marked loss of viability in MCF-7 and Caco-2 cell
lines while not being toxic for healthy human fibroblast HFF-1.
Table 2. MTT Test on MCF-7, Caco-2, and HFF-1 for
Compounds 21, 9, 15, 18, and 19
a
IC50 SD (μM)
compd
MCF-7
Caco-2
HFF-1
b
21
9
15
18
19
44 0.3
36 0.2
26 0.4
21 0.3
59 0.5
28 0.2
>100
>100
>100
>100
b
b
b
b
b
>100
>100
b
b
b
>100
>100
>100
a
Each value is the mean SD of at least two experiments performed
b
in quadruplicate. Cell viability reduction lower than 50% at 100 μM.
D
ACS Med. Chem. Lett. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX