6
B.L. Venables et al. / Bioorganic & Medicinal Chemistry Letters xxx (2018) xxx–xxx
excess amine to provide the desired ureas 7–19 in good overall
yield. A series of P4-P5 amides was prepared via hydrolysis of
the tert-butyl ester in 19 followed by subsequent HATU-mediated
coupling of the resultant acid 20 with various amines to give the
series of amides 21–23.
All compounds were testedfor enzymeinhibitory activitytoward
a homogeneous full-length HCV GT 1a NS3/4A protease complex
with the more active molecules additionally tested against NS3/4A
complexes representing GT 2b and 3a proteases.9b,13 Activity was
assessed using a fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET)
assay and the 50% inhibitory concentration (IC50) values were
determined as previously described.14,15 The concentration required
for half maximal inhibition of virus replication in a GT 1b (Con1)
replicon was determined and the data reported as EC50 values. Con-
struction of the replicon cell line has been described previously.16
Aqueous solubility was determined in phosphate buffer solution at
pH = 6.5. These data are compiled in Tables 1 and 2.
pounds 18–23 in Table 1. It should be noted that the P4 tert-butyl
group present in 14 was a fixed structural element in this series
since the SAR suggested optimal complementarity between this
lipophilic substituent and the complementary pocket of the
enzyme. In the event, esters 19 and 20 and amides 21–23 were
found to exert similar anti-NS3 protease activity in the biochemical
assay although they did not provide a significant improvement in
potency compared to 14. This observation suggested that the
immediate P4 caps were not interfacing with the enzyme surface
but were instead solvent-exposed. The PK profile of compounds
19 and 20 provided no significant improvement over the simpler
congener 14. Interestingly, compound 20, which bears a carboxylic
acid as a P4 cap, demonstrated a significant improvement in
potency in the biochemical assays across NS3 proteases represent-
ing GTs 1–3. Most notable was the IC50 value toward the GT 1a
enzyme which, at 50 pM, was 6-fold more potent than compound
14. Docking studies suggested that the enhanced potency of 20
could be attributed to hydrogen-bonding interactions between
the terminal carboxylate of 20 and both Arg-123 as well as the
backbone NH of Cys-159 (Fig. 4). While this level of activity in
the biochemical assay was significant, the PK profile of 20 was less
than optimal and hence this compound was not progressed.
As noted above, a model of 4, bound to the NS3/4a protease
enzyme complex suggested that the P4 urea moiety could poten-
tially bind to the carbonyl moiety of Ala-157 in a bidentate fashion
(Fig. 2), while P4 carbamates such as 1 interface with the enzyme
through a single H-bond interaction.12,8 Given the potency of car-
bamate 1, we sought to examine the idea that acceptable inhibition
of the NS3 protease may be achievable with substrates possessing
a single H-bond donor projected distal rather than proximal to the
P3 moiety. To this end, both N-methylated urea derivatives as well
as reverse carbamates were prepared in effort to explore this con-
cept and the results are summarized in Table 2. Synthetic schema
for the preparations of these compounds can be found in the Sup-
plemental Material.
In the course of preparing a series of P3-P4 urea analogs, it was
discovered that urea 7b, which contains
the P4 endcap (Table 1), offered an ꢀ8-fold potency advantage over
the corresponding -valine methyl ester 7a. This observed stereo-
chemical preference at P4 was recapitulated with the diastere-
omeric pair of ureas 8a/8b and 9a/9b where the -isomer showed
a several-fold increase in potency relative to the -isomer. Compu-
tational modeling suggested that the enhancement in activity
observed for compounds in the -stereochemical series was due
L-valine methyl ester as
D
L
D
L
to a beneficial hydrophobic surface interaction between enzyme
and inhibitor at the lipophilic P4 pocket of the protease, as previ-
ously reported.11b,17
In an attempt to further optimize interactions in the lipophilic
P4 pocket, we next prepared compounds 10–17 (Table 1) which
possessed the preferred stereochemistry at P4, but with R-groups
of varying size and shape. In addition to providing important struc-
tural information for maximizing potency, these compounds were
engineered with the goal of improving PK. We reasoned that the
terminal methyl ether oxygen of 10–17 might form an intramolec-
ular hydrogen-bond with the urea moiety, effectively presenting
the end of the molecule as a pseudo 5-membered ring, and thereby
masking a portion of the urea polarity and potentially improving
permeability.18,19 Compound 14 proved to be the most active in
this series, with anti-NS3 protease activity in the GT 1a and GT
3a biochemical assays ꢀ3-fold more potent than that observed
for compound 4. SAR trends in this series were sensitive to steric
bulk, with in vitro anti-NS3 protease activities generally deteriorat-
ing as R became either smaller (compounds 10–13) or larger (com-
pounds 15–17) than the tert-butyl moiety of compound 14. With
respect to PK properties, a 6-fold increase in plasma AUC was
observed for compound 14 compared to urea 4 while liver concen-
trations were found to be similar for these analogues. Interestingly,
this PK improvement was coincidental with a ꢀ50-fold increase in
aqueous solubility of 14 when compared to 4. Given these data, we
speculated that the terminal P4 ether moiety in 14 may be driving
solubility by providing a more polar terminus compared to 4. This
enhanced solubility may also explain the increase in absorption for
14 compared to 4. However, the potential for the terminal methyl
ether in 14 to facilitate the desolvation of the P4 urea through the
formation of an intramolecular hydrogen-bond that obscures the
polarity of the urea should also be considered as a source of
improved absorption of 14. Although the PK result for 14 marked
progress within the urea series, the exposure observed for this
compound was inferior to that of carbamate 1 and, hence, atten-
tion was focused on replacement of the P4 methyl ether end cap
in an effort to further modulate anti-NS3 protease activity and
improve PK.
A series of P3-P4 ureas were explored first and their anti-NS3
protease activity, antiviral properties in a HCV replicon cell-based
assay and PK profiles examined. Installation of a methyl group on
the P4 side nitrogen atom of the urea yielded 27, a molecule which
retained intrinsic potency against the GT 1a NS3 protease but
exhibited reduced potency in the GT 1b replicon cell-based assay
when compared to the parent urea analogue 25. Transposition of
the methyl group to the P3 side of the urea provided 28, a com-
pound with poor potency in the biochemical assay. While this
result appeared discouraging with respect to the hypothesis under
examination, a model of 28 bound to the NS3/4a protease complex
The P4 cap functionality explored in this part of the survey
included esters, amides and acidic groups, as exemplified by com-
Fig. 4. Compound 19 modeled into the GT 1a HCV NS3/4A protease complex
binding site.