S.S. Bhagade, B.M. Bhanage
CatalysisCommunications112(2018)21–25
It has been observed that change in reaction temperature significantly
affects the net conversion and selectivity of the desired product. When
the reaction was carried out at 120 °C it gave 100% conversion with
91% selectivity for compound (1d) (Table 1, entry 4). Further increase
in temperature up to 130 °C had no significant impact (Table 1, entry
5). However at 140 °C, the conversion remains same but the rate of
substrate hydrogenation was increased and gives (1e) (Table 1, entry
6). The effect of reaction temperature and pressure on the conversion
and selectivity of products under hydroformylation condition for (R)-
carvone was not studied in earlier reports [12]. In the catalyst
screening, the performance of different rhodium metal sources for
better selectivity with conversion towards desired product was tested. It
is been found that the use of [RhCl3] and [Rh(COD)Cl]2 (Table 1, en-
tries 7, 8) are not ideal for the given set of reaction sequences and gives
low i.e. 40% and 70% conversion respectively. With [RhCl3] and [Rh
(COD)Cl]2 complexes, an inhibition period always observed before
hydroformylation began. Such inhibition period in [RhCl3] and [Rh
(COD)Cl]2 complexes may be responsible for a slow formation of cat-
alytically active Rh-hydride species by hydrogenolysis and less re-
activity in the developed catalytic system. Desire results for compound
(1d) were obtained only by using [Rh(CO)2(acac)] as a rhodium metal
precursor and gives the highest selectivity up to 91% with 100% con-
version (Table 1, entry 4). The appropriate choice of ligand ancillary
was found to be a crucial step as it plays an important role in conversion
and selectivity towards formation of (1d) (Table 1, entries 9–14). The
phosphine containing aryl (PPh3 (triphenylphosphine); Table 1, entry
10), alkyl (PBu3 (tributylphosphine); PCy3 (tricyclohexylphosphine);
Table 1, entries 11, 12) backbone gave acceptable conversion but high
reactivity towards the hydrogenation leads to the generation of (1e) in
the final product and hence it eliminates their applicability for the
synthesis of (1d). Whereas the use of dppp ligand gives 97% selectivity
for (1d) shows similar conversion as of dppe (Table 1, entries 9). Use of
wide bite angle containing bulky bidentate phosphine ligand like
xantphos (4,5-bis(diphenylphosphino)-9,9-dimethylxanthene) is well-
known ligand reported for the hydroformylation chemistry and known
for its excellent selectivity towards normal aldehyde product. And
hence use of xantphos as phosphine ancillary displays very high se-
lectivity for the hydroformylation reaction and gives (1a) in the highest
ratio (Table 1, entry 13) but retards next consecutive hydrogenation
reaction of (1a) to form intermediate product (1b). The low conversion
and highest percent composition of side product (1e) in reaction mix-
ture disclose the importance of phosphine ancillary in the developed in
the present catalytic system (Table 1, entry 14). The diphosphine li-
gands are reported in the literature for hydroformylation of various
olefins and their performance in terms of conversion and selectivity is
correlated with their bite angle. We also observed results which are in
line with the reported results for other olefins. i.e. increase in conver-
sion and selectivity ratio with respect bite angle [13,14].
Scheme 1. Synthesis of tamariscol.
Scheme 2. Hydroformylation of (R)-carvone and dihydrocarvone.
(C) intramolecular keto-aldol condensation of (1b) catalyzed by PPTS;
(D) hydrogenation of α,β-unsaturated C]C bond of newly formed
enone (1c); (E) hydrogenation of both C]C bonds of carvone gives by-
product (1e); (F) hydroformylation of dihydrocarvone gives keto-al-
dehyde (1b) and (G) hydrogenation of C]C bond of dihydrocarvone
gives by-product (1e) as shown in (Scheme 2).
2. Experimental
2.1. Materials and instruments
All the materials i.e. (R)-carvone, dihydrocarvone, PPTS, rhodium
metal precursor, phosphine ligand etc. were procured from the reputed
chemical supplier and used without further purification. The quanti-
tative analysis and qualitative product formation were confirmed by
using GC–MS-QP 2010 instrument (Rtx-17, 30 m × 25 mm ID, the film
thickness(df) = 0.25 μm) (column flow 2 mL min−1, 65 °C to 240 °C at
10 °C min−1 rise). The FT-IR (Fourier Transform Infrared) spectra were
recorded on Brucker Perkin Elmer-100 spectrometer in the wavelength
range from 400 to 4000 cm−1. 1H NMR spectra of the final product (1d)
were obtained with a Bruker Avance 400 MHz NMR spectrometer with
CDCl3 as the solvent [15].
3. Results and discussion
In the next set of experiments, the effect of metal to ligand ratio was
studied (Table 1, entries 15, 16). It was observed that the decrease in
Rh/dppp ratio from 1:4 to 1:2 considerably brings down the net con-
version up to 91% and selectivity (Table 1, entry 15). However when
metal to ligand ratio increased from 1:4 to 1:6, hydrogenation reactions
get decelerate and gives intermediate (1a) and (1c) in notable con-
centration (Table 1, entry 16). From above observations, it can be
concluded that metal to ligand ratio of 1:4 is necessary for the optimal
conversion and selectivity.
The pyridinium-based organic salts like pyridinium chloride
(Py.HCl), pyridinium sulfate (Py.H2SO4) and pyridinium nitrate
(Py.HNO3) were also examined. But the promising result was obtained
with PPTS as co-catalyst (Table 2, entries 1–4). When the reaction was
carried out in the absence of co-catalyst considerable amount of inter-
mediate aldehyde (1b) was detected in the final product, this indicates
that co-catalyst is necessary to accelerate intramolecular keto-aldol
reaction to give intermediate (1c) (Table 2, entry 5). Further, it has
been observed that ligand to co-catalyst ratio in reaction medium
In the initial stage, we have optimized the reaction parameters for
the hydroformylation reaction. The hydroformylation reaction was
performed by taking (R)-carvone (600 mg, 4 mmol), Rh(CO)2(acac)
(2.58 mg, 0.01 mmol), dppe (1,2-bis(diphenylphosphino)ethane,
15.92 mg, 0.04 mmol; M/L 1:4), PPTS (5.00 mg, 0.02 mmol), synthesis
gas (CO/H2, 1:1) pressure ranging from 550 psi to 750 psi in toluene
(10 mL) at 110 °C for 24 h at 700 rpm stirring speed (Table 1, entries
1–3). At 550 psi of synthesis gas pressure, only 60% of conversion and
selectivity was observed with considerable amount intermediates (1a)
and (1c) (Table 1, entry 1). With the increase in synthesis gas pressure
from 550 psi to 650 psi, the conversion was enhanced up to 96% with
90% selectivity for 1d (Table 1, entry 2). With further increase in the
synthesis gas pressure to 750 psi leads to double hydrogenation of
starting material and gives tetrahydrocarvone (1e) (Table 1, entry 3) as
a side product. Next, the effect of temperature towards conversion of
(R)-carvone and selectivity for (1d) was studied (Table 1, entries 4–6).
22