16
Z. Ma et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 26 (2016) 15–20
of the models tested.14 Encouraged by these results, we initiated a
Phase I clinical trial of AMG 837.
groups to the tail group and/or the head group of the AMG 837 class
of GPR40 agonists.
Herein, we report the discovery of AM-3189 (13k). AM-3189
maintains the in vivo efficacy of AMG 837 while displaying a supe-
rior pharmacokinetic profile and minimal CNS exposure.
O
As we reported previously, activity on the GPR40 receptor var-
ies significantly with substitution at the b-carbon relative to the
carboxylate.13 We hoped to modify the beta-substitution of AMG
837 in order to improve potency and desired physiochemical prop-
erties. The racemate of AMG 837 (8a in the Table 1) displayed the
expected twofold decrease in potency on GPR40 compared to the
active enantiomer AMG 837 and its activity crossed over to the
rat and mouse forms of GPR40.13 Due to the lack of an efficient
method for the asymmetric synthesis of b-substituted 2-phenyl-
propanoates at the time, racemic compounds were assayed for
structure–activity relationship (SAR) studies and early screening
purposes. Using the tail group from AMG 837 as a probe, the syn-
thetic route for modification of the beta-substitutions of the car-
boxylic acids is shown in Scheme 1. Treatment of aldehydes 1
with (4-((tetrahydro-2H-pyran-2-yl)oxy)phenyl) magnesium bro-
mide afforded secondary alcohols 2, which were oxidized by pyri-
dinium chlorochromate (PCC) to yield ketones 3. The ketones 3
F3C
OH
O
tail group
head group
AMG 837
While the clinical evaluation of AMG 837 was ongoing, we turned
our attention to the development of a structurally distinct GPR40
agonist. Although AMG 837 is a carboxylic acid, its physicochemical
properties, including low polar surface area (tPSA 47, Table 1),
suggest a reasonable possibility of achieving CNS exposure. Addi-
tional support comes from a structurally close analog of AMG 837
(with 40-chloro-20-ethoxy-(1,10-biphenyl)-4-yl replacing 40-(trifluo-
romethyl)-(1,10-biphenyl)-3-yl of AMG 837) which showed a brain
to plasma ratio of 0.6 3 h after an oral dose of 5 mg/kg in rats. Given
that the efficacy of GPR40 agonists is derived peripherally and that
they are likely to be dosed chronically, we sought molecules with
minimal brain penetration.15 In general, increasing the polar surface
area (PSA) of a molecule tends to decrease its blood–brain barrier
permeability.16 In keeping with this principle, we focused on
increasing the PSA of AMG 837, while maintaining its potency
and metabolic stability. The approach taken was to introduce polar
were converted to a,b-unsaturated esters 4 through Peterson-ole-
fination17 followed by hydrogenation to afford beta-substituted 3-
arylpropanoates 5. After removing the THP protecting group with
TFA, the resulting para-substituted phenols 6 were alkylated with
3-(bromomethyl)-40-(trifluoromethyl)-1,10-biphenyl in the pres-
ence of cesium carbonate to afford the esters 7, which were hydro-
lyzed under basic conditions to yield the desired carboxylic acids 8.
Since GPR40 is a G q-coupled GPCR, compounds were assayed
a
for GPR40 activity in a chemiluminescent system (aequorin) mon-
itoring calcium flux in CHO cells transiently transfected with
GPR40 as reported previously (Table 1).13,14 In the later stage of
the project, a CHO cell line stably transfected with human GPR40
was developed. GPR40 aequorin assay was then run in buffer con-
taining 0.01% human serum albumin or in 100% human serum to
test activity of compounds in the absence or presence of plasma
proteins (Table 2). AMG 837 was included with all assays as a pos-
itive control and as a reference compound for benchmarking SAR.
The SAR of the b-substituted 3-phenylpropanoate lead series
with AMG 837 tail group is shown in Table 1. Activity on the
GPR40 receptor varied significantly with substitution at the b-car-
bon of the carboxylate. Simple phenyl (8b) reduces GPR40 potency
10-fold relative to the methyl acetylene compound (8a, racemate
of AMG 837). Introducing a nitrogen to the phenyl ring in various
positions does not restore the lost potency, thus pyridin-2-yl and
pyridin-3-yl compounds (8c, 8d) are equally potent to the simple
phenyl analog (8b), while the pyridin-4-yl compound (8e) is
slightly more potent. Five-membered ring heterocycles retain
potency slightly more than the phenyl analogs, as evidenced by
2-thiophenyl (8f) compared to the simple phenyl (8b). Replacing
the thiophene ring with a thiazole ring or 2-methylimidazole ring
also showed slightly improved potency (8f vs. 8g and 8h).
In an attempt to quantify the likely improvement in the balance
between physiochemical properties and potency, the lipophilic
efficiency (LipE)18 of this set of compounds was calculated and
shown in Table 1. 8h was revealed to be the best of replacements
in terms of lipophilic efficiency among the set shown in Table 1
and it was comparable to that of 8a (racemate of AMG 837). By
incorporating both acidic and basic functional groups, analogs
derived from 8h should be less likely to penetrate the BBB. There-
fore, the imidazole arylpropionate was used as the scaffold for the
next set of compounds. In designing our analogs, emphasis was
placed on increasing polarity and conformational rigidity. We
had established in previous work13 that meta-biaryls yielded the
Table 1
SAR of the b-substituted 2-phenylpropanoate lead series with AMG 837 tail group
R1
b
O
F3C
OH
a
O
C ring
A ring
B ring
Head Group
AMG 837 Tail Group
Compounda
R1
hGPR40b
EC50 (lM)
LogD (pH 7.4)
LipEc
tPSA (Å2)
AMG 837
0.013
0.025
3.66
3.66
4.23
3.94
47
47
8a
8b
8c
0.33
0.33
4.84
3.12
1.64
3.36
47
59
N
S
8d
0.40
3.17
3.23
59
N
N
8e
8f
0.19
0.19
3.13
4.42
3.59
3.30
59
47
S
N
8g
8h
0.12
0.13
3.79
3.01
3.13
3.89
59
62
N
N
a
All compounds reported in this table are racemates except AMG 837.
GPR40 activity was assayed in a chemiluminescent system (aequorin) moni-
b
toring calcium flux in CHO cells transiently transfected with GPR40 as reported
previously13,14
.
c
Lipophilic efficiency, LipE = pEC50 – LogD.