A thiadiazole-based covalent triazine framework nanosheet for highly selective and sensitive primary aromatic amine detection among various amines

Article abstract of DOI:10.1039/c9ta14252e

Primary aromatic amines (PAAs), as a class of persistent and highly toxic organic pollutants, have been posing a great threat to human health and the environment. Therefore, the design and preparation of a highly sensitive and selective luminescent probe

Full text of DOI:10.1039/c9ta14252e

View Article Online
View Journal
Journal of
Materials Chemistry A
Materials for energy and sustainability
Accepted Manuscript
This article can be cited before page numbers have been issued, to do this please use: Y. Tang, H.
Huang, B. Peng, Y. Chang, Y. Li and C. Zhong, J. Mater. Chem. A, 2020, DOI: 10.1039/C9TA14252E.
Volume
Number 12
28 March 2018
Pages 4883-5230
6
This is an Accepted Manuscript, which has been through the
Royal Society of Chemistry peer review process and has been
accepted for publication.
Journal of
Materials Chemistry A
Materials for energy and sustainability
rsc.li/materials-a
Accepted Manuscripts are published online shortly after acceptance,
before technical editing, formatting and proof reading. Using this free
service, authors can make their results available to the community, in
citable form, before we publish the edited article. We will replace this
Accepted Manuscript with the edited and formatted Advance Article as
soon as it is available.
You can find more information about Accepted Manuscripts in the
Information for Authors.
Please note that technical editing may introduce minor changes to the
text and/or graphics, which may alter content. The journal’s standard
Terms & Conditions and the Ethical guidelines still apply. In no event
shall the Royal Society of Chemistry be held responsible for any errors
or omissions in this Accepted Manuscript or any consequences arising
from the use of any information it contains.
ISSN 2050-7488
COMMUNICATION
Zhenhai Wen et al.
An electrochemically neutralized energy-assisted low-cost
acid-alkaline electrolyzer for energy-saving electrolysis
hydrogen generation
rsc.li/materials-a

&'()*( +, -,. )+/0*. 1)234-*
Journal of Materials Chemistry A
Page 1 of 10
View Article Online
DOI: 10.1039/C9TA14252E
A !"#$%
!"#$"#%&'()*#+($ ,&-#'(./ 0"#%".( 10#2(3&04 5#.&+!((/ 6&0
7"8!'9 :('(;/"-( #.$ :(.+"/"-( <0"2#09 A0&2#/"; A2".(+ =(/(;/"&.
#2&.8 >#0"&?+ A2".(+
(6(4=(+ GG.A L)-0)29 MGKKN
A66(8.(+ GG.A L)-0)29 MGKK
O0)-PA( !)-3N)N> Q,-3'4)-3 Q0)-3NR)N> S(- &(-3N)N> O)-/4), #A)-3N)N> O)-3 $4 )N> )-+ #A,-3'4 TA,-3
R)N>N6
DE"? FGCFGHIJKGKKGGGGGK
!A( 8241)29 )2,1).46 )14-(* ;&AA*<N )* ) 6')** ,: 8(2*4*.(-. )-+ A43A'9 .,K46 ,23)-46 8,''0.)-.*N A)=( >((- 8,*4-3 ) 32().
.A2(). ., A01)- A()'.A )-+ .A( (-=42,-1(-.C !A(2(:,2(N +(*43- )-+ 82(8)2).4,- ,: A43A'9 *(-*4.4=( )-+ *('(6.4=(
'014-(*6(-. 82,>( ., +(.(6. &AA* )1,-3 =)24,0* )14-(* )2( 418,2.)-. >0. 6A)''(-34-3C "- .A4* U,2VN >9 4-.2,+064-3
('(6.2,-W+(:464(-. 1,-,1(2 XNXYW;>(-P,@6B@FNMNZB.A4)+4)P,'(WXN[W+49'<+4>(-P)'+(A9+( ;S!DD< U4.A )- )332(3).4,-W6)0*(+
\0(-6A4-3 >(A)=4,2 4-., .A( MD :2)1(U,2VN :'0,2(*6(-. 0'.2).A4- 6,=)'(-. .24)P4-( :2)1(U,2V ;]W#!]< -)-,*A((. U)*
6,-*.206.(+C #,18)2(+ U4.A )332(3).(+ S!DD 1,-,1(2N .A( ,>.)4-(+ ]W#!]WH -)-,*A((. *A,U* 106A A43A :'0,2(*6(-6(
\0)-.01 94('+ +0( ., S!DD :2)31(-. 4* U('' +4*8(2*(+ 4- .A( MD :2)1(U,2VC !A( ]W#!]WH -)-,*A((. (KA4>4.* A43A *.)>4'4.9N
A43A 8,2,*4.9N A43A :'0,2(*6(-6( 8(2:,21)-6( )-+ A)* 246A ('(6.2,-W+(:464(-. 0-4. 4- .A( 8,2( 6A)--('N 1)V4-3 4. 4+()'
8').:,21 :,2 *(-*4-3 ('(6.2,-W246A &AA* 1,'(60'(*C "- :)6.N .A( ]W#!]WH -)-,*A((. *A,U* A43A *(-*4.4=4.9 )-+ *('(6.4=4.9 :,2
&AA* +(.(6.4,- >9 :'0,2(*6(-6( \0(-6A4-3N )1,-3 =)24,0* )14-(*N 6,=(24-3 *,1( 6')**46 )'48A).46 )14-(*N A(.(2,696'46
)14-(*N *(6,-+)29 )2,1).46 )14-(* )-+ .(2.4)29 )2,1).46 )14-(*C !, .A( >(*. ,: ,02 V-,U'(+3(N 4. 4* .A( :42*. 2(8,2.(+
:'0,2(*6(-. *(-*,2 :,2 *('(6.4=( &AA* *(-*4-3 :2,1 =)24,0* )14-(*C ^,2(,=(2N ]W#!]WH (KA4>4.* .A( 0-82(6(+(-.(+ ',U
+(.(6.4,- '414. ,: FFC[ )-+ FCX[ -^ .,U)2+ 8A(-9')14-( ;&A< )-+ ,W8A(-9'(-(+4)14-( ;&DA<N 2(*8(6.4=('9N *028)**4-3 )''
.A( 2(8,2.(+ :'0,2(*6(-. *(-*,2*C !A( 6,1>4-).4,- ,: (K8(241(-.)' )-)'9*4* )-+ +(-*4.9 :0-6.4,-)' .A(,29 ;D]!<
6)'60').4,-* +(1,-*.2).( .A). .A( 0-4\0( &AA* +(.(6.4,- 8(2:,21)-6( ,: .A( ]W#!]WH 6)- >( )..24>0.(+ ., .A( *.).46
\0(-6A4-3 82,6(**N UA46A 4* 6,-:421(+ >9 .A( :,21).4,- ,: .A( 32,0-+W*.).( :'0,2(*6(-6(W\0(-6A(+ 6,18'(K ,- )66,0-.
,: .A( A9+2,3(- >,-+4-3 4-.(2)6.4,-* >(.U((- ]W#!]WH )-+ &AA*C !A4* U,2V -,. ,-'9 82,=4+(* ) .A4)+4)P,'(W>)*(+ MD
:'0,2(*6(-. ,23)-46 :2)1(U,2V -)-,*A((.N >0. )'*, )- (K6(''(-. :'0,2(*6(-. *(-*,2 U4.A 0-(K8(6.(+ *(-*4.4=4.9 )-+
*('(6.4=4.9 :,2 &AA* +(.(6.4,-C
., 2(*0'. 4- .A( +)1)3( ., .A( 2(*842).,29 *9*.(1N 6(-.2)'
-(2=,0* *9*.(1N 6)2+4,=)*60')2 *9*.(1N )-+ 1)9 (=(- 6)0*(
6)264-,3(-464.9CXW` ^()-UA4'(N .A( &AA* 0*0)''9 6,(K4*. U4.A
@./0&$?;/"&.
"- 2(6(-. 9()2*N )14-(* A)=( >((- U4+('9 )88'4(+ ., 1)-9
+,1)4-* 4-6'0+4-3 6A(146)'N 8A)21)6(0.46)'N :,,+ )-+ 14'4.)29
4-+0*.24(*CFWH "- 8)2.460')2N 8241)29 )2,1).46 )14-(* ;&AA*<N
*06A )* 8A(-9')14-( ;&A<N ,W8A(-9'(-(+4)14-( ;&DA< )-+ FW
-)8A.A9')14-( ;_&A< )2( U4+('9 0*(+ 4- 1)-0:)6.024-3 +9(*N
20>>(2 )-+ )32,6A(146)'*N )-+ (K8,*02( ., &AA* 4* 6,-*4+(2(+
,.A(2 )14-(* 4- .A( :4('+* ,: (-=42,-1(-.)' )-+ 4-+0*.24)'
1,-4.,24-3N \0)'4.9 6,-.2,' ,: :,,+N )-+ 1(+46)' +4)3-,*4*N
.A0* .A( A43A *('(6.4=( )-+ *(-*4.4=( +(.(6.4,- ,: &AA*
8,''0.)-.* A)=( 32(). *43-4:46)-6(CIWFH Q,U(=(2N ,U4-3 ., .A(
)14-(* A)=( .A( *414')2 1,'(60'( *.206.02(*N 8A9*46,6A(146)'
82,8(2.4(*N )-+ 4-.(2)6.4,- :,26(N .A( *('(6.4=( +(.(6.4,- ,:
&AA* :2,1 .A( ,.A(2 )14-(* 4* *.4'' ) .,03A .)*VC A. 82(*(-.N
-01(2,0* )-)'9.46)' 82,6(+02(* A)=( >((- +(=(',8(+ :,2 .A(
+(.(6.4,- ,: &AA* )-+ 4.* +(24=).4=(*N 4-6'0+4-3 *8(6.2,1(.29N
!"# #$ %$& ' ()* #)*& )+ "$, * #-). /$0(* .$1 .2 /$0(* .$ 3*)4$11$15
6- .7).7 8.-9$*1-#&5 6- .:-. ;<<;=>5 ?@-. AB0 -CD
@E .7@).7C- .7F#- .7).7!$2E!4.
6A2,1).,32)8A9N
('(6.2,6A(14*.29
)-+
:'0,2(*6(-.
6A(1,*(-*,2 1(.A,+*CXNFXWMG A1,-3 .A(1N :'0,2(*6(-.
6A(1,*(-*,2 A)* 32(). )+=)-.)3(* +0( ., 4.* A43A *(-*4.4=4.9N
()*9 ,8(2).4,- )-+ :)*. 2(*8,-*( .A). 4* 6)8)>'( :,2 2()'W.41(
1,-4.,24-3CMFNMM !A(*( :'0,2(*6(-. 6A(1,*(-*,2* )2( 1,*.'9
>)*(+ ,- :'0,2(*6(-6( \0(-6A4-3 ,2 .A( )6.4=( 1).(24)'* >9
4-.(2)6.4,- U4.A )-)'9.(*CMHNMX A'.A,03A 1)-9 :'0,2(*6(-.
*(-*,2* >)*(+ ,- 8,'91(2* ,2 ,23)-46 *1)'' 1,'(60'(* )*
)6.4=( 1).(24)'* :,2 :'0,2(*6(-6( +(.(6.4,- ,: &AA* A)=( >((-
(!"4@))C )+ ?@$0-1#*& .2 ?@$0-4 C A.7-.$$*-.75 6- .7).7 8.-9$*1-#&5 6- .:-.
;<<;=>5 ?@-. ! AB0 -CD G@).74@).7C-F#- .7).7!$2E!4.!
4! ?)CC$7$ )+ ?@$0-4 C A.7-.$$*-.75 H$-:-.7 8.-9$*1-#& )+ ?@$0-4 C 6$4@.)C)7&5
H$-:-.7 I<<<JK5 ?@-.
5%'(6.2,-46 7088'(1(-.)29 "-:,21).4,- ;%7"< )=)4')>'(? @+(.)4'* ,: )-9
*088'(1(-.)29 4-:,21).4,- )=)4')>'( *A,0'+ >( 4-6'0+(+ A(2(BC 7((
DE"? FGCFGHIJKGKKGGGGGK
&'()*( +, -,. )+/0*. 1)234-*

&'()*( +, -,. )+/0*. 1)234-*
Journal of Materials Chemistry A
Page 2 of 10
View Article Online
DOI: 10.1039/C9TA14252E
AA @,BC
D&?0.#' 5#2(
#
#
#
#
+(=(',8(+N .A( *8(64:46 *(-*,2 1).(24)' 6)- *('(6.4=('9 +(.(6.
&AA* 1,'(60'(* :2,1 =)24,0* )14-(* A)* -,. 9(. >((-
2(8,2.(+C
$
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
$
!"
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
/45 67
$
$
#
#
#
7.2).(346)''9N 4. 4* =(29 .A24''4-3 ., +(*43- )-+ *9-.A(*4P(
:'0,2(*6(-. 1).(24)'* :,2 +4*62414-).4=( 2(6,3-4.4,- ,: )14-(*
.A2,03A 4-.(2)6.4,-* >(.U((- )- ('(6.2,-W+(:464(-. 0-4. )-+
#
#
#
#
#
!#
#!%
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
$
#
#
%)*%+',(-.+,!*+
/*01%2 '3
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
$
$
$
$
#
#
#
#
('(6.2,-W246A
)14-(*N
UA46A
6)-
8(2.02>
.A(
#
!
#
#!
%
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
$
A!"
8A,.,'014-(*6(-6( ;&$< ,: .A( *(-*,2*CMZNMc A* ('(6.2,-W
+(:464(-. :'0,2(*6(-. 1,'(60'(* .A). A)=( >((- U4+('9 0*(+ 4-
=)24,0* ,8.,('(6.2,-46 :4('+*N MNFNHWS(-P,.A4)+4)P,'( ;S!<
>)*(+ 1,'(60'(* )2( 4+()' 6A2,1,8A,2(* ., 6,-*.206.
:'0,2(*6(-. *(-*,2* :,2 )14-(* +(.(6.4,-CM[NM` Q,U(=(2N .A( S!
>)*(+ 1,'(60'(* 0*0)''9 >(',-3 ., ) *(24(* ,: *8(64)'
:'0,2(*6(-. *1)'' 1,'(60'( 82,>(*N 6)''(+ )332(3).4,-W6)0*(+
\0(-6A4-3 '014-,3(-* ;A#d3(-*<N UA46A +4*8')9 '014-(*6(-6(
82,8(2.9 ). .A( *,'0.4,- *.).(CFNMIWHM Q,U(=(2N .A( )332(3).(+
A#d3(-* (KA4>4. .A( (-(239 ',** ,: (K64.(+ *.).(* =4) -,-W
2)+4).4=( 8).AU)9*N .A0* .A(9 6)--,. :'0,2(*6( ). *,'4+ *.).(N
'414.4-3 .A( 82)6.46)' )88'46).4,- ,: .A( A#d3(-*CHFNHHNHX
!A(2(:,2(N >9 6,=)'(-.'9 411,>4'4P(+ ,-., .A( 1).(24)'
*V('(.,-N .A( )332(3).4,- ,: A#d3(-* 6)- >( (::(6.4=('9
*0882(**(+ >9 .A( *9-(239 ,: .A( )-6A,24-3 )-+ +4'0.4-3 (::(6.N
.A0* .A( ,>.)4-(+ 1).(24)'* 6)- 8,**(** *.2,-3 :'0,2(*6(-.
(14**4,-CHZNHc
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
$
!"
#
#
"&((
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
#
$
$
#
#
#
#
#$%&#$'
:;!(2( GC 76A(1).46 ,: .A( *9-.A(*4* 2,0.( ,: ]W#!]WH =4) .A( 6,-+(-*).4,-
2()6.4,- ,: &AQS )-+ S!DDC
*(6,-+)29
)'48A).46
)14-(*
;+41(.A9')14-(N
D^Af
+4(.A9')14-(N D%A<N .(2.4)29 )'48A).46 )14-(* ;.241(.A9')14-(N
!^A<N 8241)29 )2,1).46 )14-(* ;8A(-9')14-(N &Af ,W
8A(-9'(-(+4)14-(N &DAf FW-)8A.A9')14-(N _&A<N *(6,-+)29
)2,1).46 )14-(* ;+48A(-9')14-(N D&A<N .(2.4)29 )2,1).46
)14-(* ;.248A(-9')14-(N !&A<N A(.(2,696'46 )14-(* ;ZW)14-,W
FAW.(.2)P,'N A!Tf A14.2,'(N A!$<N 8924+4-( )14-( ;XW
+41(.A9')14-,8924+4-(N D^A&< )-+ \0).(2-)29 )11,-401
*)'. ;.(.2)1(.A9')11,-401 6A',24+(N !^A#< U(2( *.0+4(+C ".
A)* >((- :,0-+ .A). ]W#!]WH 2(82(*(-.* A43A :'0,2(*6(-6(
\0(-6A4-3 (::464(-69 .,U)2+ &AN &DA )-+ _&AC !A( '414. ,:
+(.(6.4,- ;$ED< ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+ &AN &DA )-+ _&A )2(
(*.41).(+ ., >( FFC[N FCX[ )-+ McCM -^N 2(*8(6.4=('9C
&)2.460')2'9N .A( $ED =)'0(* :,2 &A )-+ &DA *(-*4-3 )2( 106A
',U(2 .A)- .A). ,: )-9 ,.A(2 2(8,2.(+ :'0,2(*6(-6( *(-*,2*N
4-6'0+4-3 ^E]*N #E]*N )-+ &E&*N *06A )* D!&& ;MX -^ :,2 &A<N
$g^E]WF ;ZZ -^ :,2 &A<N S#&W&9W#QE ;[ -^ :,2 &DA< )-+
D!A] ;ZG :,2 &DA<C !, ,02 V-,U'(+3(N .A( ]W#!]WH 4* .A( :42*.
:'0,2(*6(-. *(-*,2 .A). 6)- *('(6.4=('9 +(.(6. &AA* :2,1
=)24,0* )14-( 1,'(60'(*C !A( (K8(241(-.)' 2(*0'.* )-+ +(-*4.9
:0-6.4,-)' .A(,29 ;D]!< 6)'60').4,-* +(1,-*.2).( .A( *.).46
\0(-6A4-3 1(6A)-4*1N .A( 30(*. &AA* 1,'(60'(* )-+ .A( A,*.
]W#!]WH )2( :,21(+ .A( 32,0-+W*.).( -,-W:'0,2(*6(-. 6,18'(K
>9 .A( A9+2,3(- >,-+4-3N UA46A 4* )>'( ., 6,'')>,2).4=('9
(-:,26( :,2 4.* *8(64:46 2(6,3-4.4,- )-+ +(.(6.4,- ,: &AA*
1,'(60'(*C !A(2(:,2(N .A( ]W#!]WH 8,**(**(* A43A :'0,2(*6(-.
*('(6.4=4.9 )-+ *(-*4.4=4.9 .,U)2+* &AA* )1,-3 =)24,0* )14-(*C
#,=)'(-. .24)P4-( :2)1(U,2V* ;#!]*< )2( ) V4-+ ,: -(U 10'.4W
:0-6.4,-)' 1).(24)'* U4.A .A( .24)P4-( 24-3 0-4.N UA46A -,. ,-'9
A)=( *.)>'( )-+ )+/0*.)>'( 8,2,0* *.206.02(N >0. )'*, )2(
6,-=(-4(-. :,2 .A( :0-6.4,-)' 32,08 )-+ 8(2:,21)-6(
+(*43-CH[WXM "- 6,-*(\0(-6(N #!]* U4.A S! 0-4. 1)9 >( )
82,14*4-3 6)-+4+).( :,2 .A( +(.(6.4,- ,: )14-(* 4- U).(2C
#,18)2(+ U4.A .A( *1)'' 1,'(60'( :'0,2(*6(-. 82,>(N .A(
+(*43-(+ :'0,2(*6(-. #!] 1).(24)'* -,. ,-'9 6)- 32().'9
(-A)-6( .A( :'0,2(*6(-6( 8(2:,21)-6( >(6)0*( ,: .A( S!
0-4.* U4.A A#d >(A)=4,2 )2( :0''9 +4*8(2*(+ 4- .A( :2)1(U,2V
,: .A( #!] 1).(24)'N >0. )'*, A)=( *9-(234*.46 (::(6. :,2 .A(
:'0,2(*6(-6( +(.(6.4,- )* ) 2(*0'. ,: .A( 82(6,-6(-.2).4,-
(::(6. ,: .A( )>0-+)-. 8,2,0* *.206.02( ,: ]W#!]CH[NXH
A66,2+4-3 ., .A( )>,=( +4*60**4,-N A(2(4-N U( 82,8,*(+ .A(
*.2).(39 ., 6,-*.206. A#d3(-* 4-., MD :'0,2(*6(-6( #!]
1).(24)'* ., )6A4(=( A43A'9 '014-(*6(-. :'0,2(*6(-. 8,2,0*
1).(24)' :,2 .A( *('(6.4=( +(.(6.4,- ,: &AA* 4- U).(2C A* )
82,,:W,:W6,-6(8. (K8(241(-.N .A( :'0,2(*6(-. 6,=)'(-. .24)P4-(
:2)1(U,2V ;]W#!]< U)* *9-.A(*4P(+ >9 .A( 6,-+(-*).4,-
A(+?'/+ #.$ $"+;?++"&.+
2()6.4,-
>(.U((-
XNXYW;>(-P,@6B@FNMNZB.A4)+4)P,'(WXN[W
+49'<+4>(-P)'+(A9+( ;S!DD< 1,-,1(2 U4.A A#d >(A)=4,2 )-+
8A(-)14+4-( A9+2,6A',24+( ;&AQ#<C #,18)2(+ U4.A .A( S!DD
1,-,1(2N .A( ]W#!]WH (KA4>4.* 106A A43A(2 '014-,0*
(::464(-69 U4.A .A( \0)-.01 94('+ ,: HHCHeN 4-+46).4-3 .A). .A(
+4*8(2*(+ A#d3(-* 4- MD #!] :2)1(U,2V -)-,*A((. 6)-
(::464(-.'9 )-+ *0>*.)-.4)''9 .0-( .A( ('(6.2,-46 .2)-*4.4,-
(-(234(* )-+ 2)4*( .A( '014-,0* (::46)69C S)*(+ ,- .A(42
,0.*.)-+4-3 U).(2 *.)>4'4.9N 8,2,*4.9N )-+ A43A :'0,2(*6(-.N .A(
+(.(6.4,- ,: *('(6.(+ )14-(* U)* (K8',2(+ 4- .A( ]W#!]WHC
],02.((- )14-(* ,: -4-( 6')**(* ;^,'(60')2 *.206.02(* ,: .A(
=)24,0* ,23)-46 )14-(* 4* *A,U- 4- ]43C 7HN %7" 5 <? 8241)29
)'48A).46 )14-(* ;(.A9')14-(N %Af .W82,89')14-(N &&A<N
:9./!(+"+ #.$ ,!#0#;/(0"%#/"&.H
&AQS )-+ S!DD 1,-,1(2* U(2( 0*(+ ., 82(8)2).4,- ,: .A(
MD ]W#!]WH -)-,*A((. U4.A 422(30')2 A(K)3,-)' ;76A(1( F<C
!A( 6,-+(-*).4,- 2()6.4,-* U(2( 6,-+06.(+ 0-+(2
*,'=,.A(21)' 6,-+4.4,-* 4- ) 14K(+ *,'=(-. ,: +41(.A9'
*0':,K4+( )-+ U).(2 U4.A 6(*401 6)2>,-).( 6).)'9*. ). FMG h#
:,2 H +)9*C !A( +(.)4'(+ *9-.A(*4* 1(.A,+* 6)- >( *((- 4- .A(
%7"5C ],024(2 !2)-*:,21 4-:2)2(+ *8(6.2,*6,89 ;]!W" <N -06'()2
1)3-(.46 2(*,-)-6( ;_^ <N )-+ iW2)9 8A,.,('(6.2,-
*8(6.2,*6,89 ;i&7< *8(6.2) ,: .A( )6\042(+ *,'4+ U(2(
1()*02(+ ., 6,-:421 .A( *.206.02( ,: .A( ]W#!]WHC !A( ]!W"
*8(6.2) ,: .A( ]W#!]WH *A,U .A( )88()2)-6( ,: .A(
E a L! M 0$CN MGFMN FFN FWH
!A4* /,02-)' 4* b !A( ,9)' 7,64(.9 ,: #A(14*.29 MGKK
&'()*( +, -,. )+/0*. 1)234-*

Page 3 of 10
Journal of Materials Chemistry A
View Article Online
DOI: 10.1039/C9TA14252E

Journal of Materials Chemistry A
Page 4 of 10
View Article Online
DOI: 10.1039/C9TA14252E

Page 5 of 10
Journal of Materials Chemistry A
View Article Online
DOI: 10.1039/C9TA14252E

Journal of Materials Chemistry A
Page 6 of 10
View Article Online
DOI: 10.1039/C9TA14252E

&'()*( +, -,. )+/0*. 1)234-*
Journal of Materials Chemistry A
Page 7 of 10
View Article Online
DOI: 10.1039/C9TA14252E
D&?0.#' 5#2(
AA @,BC
#!]WH ). FXMG 61WF *A4:.(+ ., FXFc 61WFN UA4'( .A( _W7 >,-+*
,: .A( .A4)+4)P,'( 24-3 *A4:.(+ :2,1 `XM 61WF ., `HI 61WFCZF
],2 i&7 *8(6.2) 4- ]43C X(N 4. 6)- >( *((- .A). .A( _F* 8()V* ,:
.A( .A4)+4)P,'( 24-3 )-+ .24)P4-( 24-3 4- ]W#!]WH )-+ &Ay]W
#!]WH )2( *A4:.(+ :2,1 XGGCH )-+ HI`C` (g ., XGGCG )-+ HI`CH
(gN 2(*8(6.4=('9C !A( 7M8 8()V ,: S!DD 4- ]W#!]WH ,>=4,0*'9
*A4:.* :2,1 FccC` )-+ FcZCc (g ., FccCG )-+ FcZCM (g ):.(2 &A
)+*,28.4,-C ;]43C X:< A'' .A,*( *A4:.* *033(*. .A( *.2,-3
4-.(2)6.4,-* >(.U((- W_QM 32,08 4- &A )-+ .A4)+4)P,'( 24-3 4-
]W#!]WHN )* 4''014-).(+ 4- .A( ]43C Z)C
6,-+4.4,-C ". *A,0'+ >( -,.46(+ .A). .A( !AS 1,'(60'( 4*
2(').4=('9 *.)>'( 4- A9+2,6A',24+( *.).(C Q,U(=(2N 4. U4''
411(+4).('9 +(.(24,2).( 4- .A( -(0.2)' ,2 >)*46 *,'0.4,-N .A0*
2(*0'.4-3 4- 8,,2 +(.(6.4,- 8(2:,21)-6(* ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+
!ASC "- :)6.N .A( +4*.4-6. 6,',02 6A)-3( ,: !AS *,'0.4,- U)*
)'*, ,>*(2=(+ 4- .A( -(0.2)'4P).4,- 82,6(**C !, 6,18)2( .A(
2()' \0(-6A4-3 )>4'4.9 ,: !AS )-+ &A :,2 ]W#!]WHN .A(
:'0,2(*6(-6( +(.(6.4,- (K8(241(-.* U(2( 8(2:,21(+ 4-
)\0(,0* *,'0.4,- ,: 8QkFC A* *A,U- 4- ]43C 7XM 5 N .A(
:'0,2(*6(-6( +(.(6.4,- 8(2:,21)-6( ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+ !AS 4*
,>*(2=)>'9 A43A(2 .A)- .A). ,: &A 4- 8QkF )\0(,0* *,'0.4,-N
82,=4-3 .A). 1,2( )14-, 32,08* ,: &AA* )2( 6,-+06.4=( .,
.A( :'0,2(*6(-6( +(.(6.4,- ,: ]W#!]WH 4- .A( *)1( 6,-+4.4,-*C
^,2( *43-4:46)-.'9N )'.A,03A ]W#!]WH *A,U* (K6(''(-.
:'0,2(*6(-6( +(.(6.4,- )>4'4.4(* .,U)2+* &A 0-+(2 .A( -()2'9
-(0.2)' 6,-+4.4,-*N ,-'9 U()V :'0,2(*6(-6(W\0(-6A4-3 (::(6.
U)* ,>*(2=(+ 4- )64+ )\0(,0* *,'0.4,- ,: 8QkFN :02.A(2
6,-:4214-3 .A). .A( A9+2,3(- >,-+ 4-.(2)6.4,-* >(.U((- &A
1,'(60'(* )-+ ]W#!]WH 8')9* ) V(9 2,'( 4- :'0,2(*6(-6(
+(.(6.4,- 82,6(**C EU4-3 ., .A( 82(*(-6( ,: ) ')23( -01>(2
,: Qv +4*208.* .A( A9+2,3(- >,-+ 4-.(2)6.4,-* >(.U((- &A
)-+ ]W#!]WH 4- .A( )64+ *,'0.4,-N .A( :,21).4,- ,: *.)>'(
32,0-+ *.).( -,-W:'0,2(*6(-. 6,18'(K >(.U((- ]W#!]WH )-+
&A U4'' >( 0-:)=,02)>'(N .A0* *43-4:46)-.'9 *0882(**4-3 .A(
:'0,2(*6(-6( +(.(6.4,- ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+ &AC
!, :02.A(2 6,-:421 .A( :,21).4,- ,: -,-W:'0,2(*6(-. 6,18'(K
4-+06(+ >9 .A( A9+2,3(- >,-+4-3 >(.U((- .A( ]W#!]WH )-+
&AN U( 6)'60').(+ .A( 4-.(2)6.4,-* ,: &A )-+ ]W#!]WH 4- .A(
(K64.(+W*.).( 6,18'(K >9 0*4-3 .41(W+(8(-+(-. +(-*4.9
:0-6.4,-)' .A(,29 ;!DD]!< U4.A #A^WSH$O& :0-6.4,-)' )-+ cW
HFq;+N8< >)*4* *(.C A* *A,U- 4- ]43C Z>N .A( +4*.)-6( >(.U((-
Q ).,1* ,: W_QM 4- &A )-+ .A( _ ).,1* ,: .A( .A4)+4)P,' 24-3
4- ]W#!]WH 4* MCF[c mN UA46A 4* U4.A4- .A( 2)-3( ,: 6')**46
A9+2,3(- >,-+ '(-3.AN 4-+46).4-3 .A). ]W#!]WH A)* .A(
A9+2,3(- >,-+ 4-.(2)6.4,- U4.A &A 4- .A( (K64.(+W*.).(
&Ay]W#!]WH 6,18'(KC ^,2(,=(2N ]43C Z> *A,U* .A). .A(
>4-+4-3 (-(239 >(.U((- &A )-+ ]W#!]WH 4- .A( (K64.(+W*.).(
6,18'(K 4* WMFFCXX VLJ1,'N :02.A(2 *033(*.4-3 .A). ]W#!]WH
8,**(**(* .A( *.2,-3 4-.(2)6.4,- U4.A &A 4- .A( -,-W
:'0,2(*6(-. 6,18'(KC !A(2(:,2(N .A( *.2,-3 4-.(2)6.4,-*
>(.U((- &A )-+ ]W#!]WH 6)- >( )..24>0.(+ ., .A( :,21).4,-
,: .A( -,-W:'0,2(*6(-. 6,18'(K 4-+06(+ >9 .A( A9+2,3(-
>,-+ 4-.(2)6.4,-* >(.U((- &A )-+ ]W#!]WHC
!, (K8')4- .A( +4::(2(-6( ,: .A( :'0,2(*6(-6( +(.(6.4,-
.,U)2+ &A )-+ _&AN .A( )+*,28.4,- V4-(.46* ,: &A )-+ _&A
U(2( *.0+4(+C A* *A,U- 4- ]43C 7XH5N .A( )+*,28.4,- ,: ]W#!]W
H .,U)2+ &A 2()6A(* (\04'4>2401 U4.A4- M 14-*N UA4'( .A). ,:
]W#!]WH .,U)2+ _&A *.4'' +,(* -,. 2()6A (\04'4>2401 (=(- 4-
HG 14-*N 4-+46).4-3 .A). ]W#!]WH A)* A43A(2 )+*,28.4,- 2).(
:,2 &A >(6)0*( ,: .A( 1,'(60')2 +41(-*4,- ,: &A 4* *1)''(2
.A)- .A). ,: _&AC !, :02.A(2 =(24:9 .A4* 6,-6'0*4,-N .A(
)+*,28.4,- V4-(.46* +).) U)* :4..(+ U4.A 8*(0+,W:42*.W,2+(2
V4-(.46 1,+(' )-+ 8*(0+,W*(6,-+W,2+(2 V4-(.46 1,+('C
(1)2V)>'9N )* *A,U- 4- ]43C 7XX )-+ !)>'( 7`5N .A( 8*(0+,W
*(6,-+W,2+(2 V4-(.46 1,+(' 4* 1,2( 82(64*(N )-+ .A( +(24=(+
V4-(.46 2).( 6,-*.)-. VM ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+ &A 4* HXCZH 3 1^uF
14-uFN UA46A 4* M ,2+(2* ,: 1)3-4.0+( A43A(2 .A)- .A). ,: ]W
#!]WH .,U)2+ _&AC EU4-3 ., .A( :)*.(2 )+*,28.4,- 2).( )-+
)+*,28.4,- 4-+06(+ 82(6,-6(-.2).4,- (::(6.NH[NXH .A(
:'0,2(*6(-6( +(.(6.4,- )>4'4.9 ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+ &A 4* A43A(2
.A)- .A). ,: _&AC
"- ,2+(2 ., ('064+).( .A( +4::(2(-6( ,: \0(-6A4-3 (::464(-69
>(.U((- &AA* )-+ )'48A).46 )14-(*N D]! 6)'60').4,-* U(2(
8(2:,21(+ ., )66(** ,8.414P(+ 3(,1(.24(* :,2 .A(
4-.(2)6.4,-* ,: ]W#!]WH U4.A &AA* )-+ )'48A).46 )14-(*N
2(*8(6.4=('9C A* *A,U- 4- ]43C 7H[W7XG5N .A( >4-+4-3 (-(234(*
,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+ &AA* 1,'(60'(* ;WcGCMF jLJ1,'N &Af W`HCcM
jLJ1,'N &DAf WIMCZX jLJ1,'N _&A< )2( ')23(2 .A)- .A,*( ,:
)'48A).46 )14-(* 1,'(60'(* ;WXXCX[ jLJ1,'N %Af WX`C`M jLJ1,'N
&&Af WX[CXc jLJ1,'N D^Af WZGCXI jLJ1,'N D%Af WX`CHX jLJ1,'N
!^Af WZcCFc jLJ1,'N !^A#<N *033(*.4-3 106A *.2,-3(2
4-.(2)6.4,-* >(.U((- ]W#!]WH U4.A &AA*C !A( ')23(2 >4-+4-3
(-(234(* 4-+46).( .A). &AA* 6,0'+ 1,2( ()*4'9 :,21 .A(
32,0-+ *.).( -,-W:'0,2(*6(-. 6,18'(K *.206.02( U4.A ]W#!]WHN
UA46A 4* .A( 82(6,-+4.4,- :,2 .A( :'0,2(*6(-6( +(.(6.4,- ,:
&AA* 4- ]W#!]WHC
S(*4+(*N .A( :'0,2(*6(-6( +(.(6.4,- (K8(241(-.* *A,U .A).
.A( :'0,2(*6(-6( \0(-6A4-3 (::464(-69 ,: &DA 1,'(60'(* U4.A
.U, )14-, 32,08* 4* A43A(2 .A)- .A). ,: &A )-+ _&A U4.A ,-'9
*418'( )14-, 32,08N 418'94-3 .A). .A( 10'.48'( )14-, 32,08*
4- &AA* 1,'(60'(* )2( >(-(:464)' ., \0(-6A .A( :'0,2(*6(-6(
,: ]W#!]WHC "- ,2+(2 ., =(24:9 .A( 6,-/(6.02(N U( 4-=(*.43).(+
.A( +(.(6.4,- )>4'4.9 ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+* FNHNZW
!A( >4-+4-3 (-(239 )-+ .A( (\04'4>2401 )>*,28.4,- 6)8)64.9
,: _&A 4- ]W#!]WH )2( A43A(2 .A)- .A). ,: &A *4-6( .A( ')23(2
1,'(60'( 0*0)''9 8,**(**(* A43A(2 )::4-4.9 :,2 4.* *.2,-3(2 =)-
+(2 t))'* 4-.(2)6.4,-* U4.A )+*,2>(-.CZMWZX Q,U(=(2N 4-
6,18)24*,- U4.A &AN .A( ')23(2 1,'(60'( *4P( ,: _&A 2(*0'.*
4-., .A( *',U(2 +4::0*4,- 2).( ,: _&A ., )66(** ., .A( 8,2( ,:
]W#!]WHN )* 6,-:421(+ >9 .A( )>,=( )+*,28.4,- V4-(.46 +).)C
!A(2(:,2(N )'.A,03A ]W#!]WH A)* .A( ')23(2 >4-+4-3 (-(239
)-+ (\04'4>2401 )>*,28.4,- 6)8)64.9 .,U)2+* _&AN .A(
+(.(6.4,- )>4'4.9 ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+ &A 4* A43A(2 .A)- .A). ,:
_&A >(6)0*( ,: .A( *',U(2 )+*,28.4,- 2).( ,: _&AC !, =(24:9
.A4* 6,-6'0*4,-N .A( .41(W+(8(-+(+ :'0,2(*6(-6( +(.(6.4,- ,:
]W#!]WH .,U)2+ &A )-+ _&A U(2( 8(2:,21(+C A* *A,U- 4- ]43C
7XZ5N .A( +(.(6.4,- ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+ &A 2()6A(* \0(-6A4-3
.24)14-,>(-P(-(
;!AS<
1,'(60'(*C
74-6(
FNHNZW
.24)14-,>(-P(-( .24A9+2,6A',24+( U)* 0*(+ 4- .A4* U,2VN !AS
*,'0.4,- U)* -(0.2)'4P(+ >(:,2( .A( :'0,2(*6(-6( \0(-6A4-3
(K8(241(-.C A* *A,U- 4- ]43C 7XF )-+ !)>'( 7[5N .A( j*= )-+
$ED =)'0(* ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+ !AS )2( MCFHsFGX ^uF )-+ XXG
-^N 2(*8(6.4=('9N )-+ .A( :'0,2(*6(-6( +(.(6.4,- )>4'4.9 ,: ]W
#!]WH .,U)2+ !AS 4* ,>*(2=)>'9 ',U(2 .A)- .A). ,: &A 4- .A4*
!A4* /,02-)' 4* b !A( ,9)' 7,64(.9 ,: #A(14*.29 MGKK
L! M 0$CN MGFHN FFN FWH a Q
&'()*( +, -,. )+/0*. 1)234-*

&'()*( +, -,. )+/0*. 1)234-*
Journal of Materials Chemistry A
Page 8 of 10
View Article Online
DOI: 10.1039/C9TA14252E
AA @,BC
D&?0.#' 5#2(
(\04'4>2401 U4.A4- F 14-N UA4'( FG 14- )2( -((+(+ ., 2()6A
\0(-6A4-3 (\04'4>2401 :,2 _&A 4- ]W#!]WHN 4-+46).4-3 .A). ]W
#!]WH A)* :)*.(2 2(*8,-*( :,2 &A +(.(6.4,-C !A(*( 2(*0'.* )2(
4- '4-( U4.A .A( )+*,28.4,- V4-(.46 +).) 4- ]43C 7XHN 7XX )-+
!)>'( 7` 5 C ". *A,0'+ >( -,.46(+ .A). (=(- ). MG 14-* ,:
6,-.)6.4-3 .41( >(.U((- .A( ]W#!]WH )-+ .U, )14-(*N .A(
\0(-6A4-3 )>4'4.9 ,: _&A 4* *.4'' 4-:(24,2 ., .A). ,: &AN )*
*A,U- 4- ]43C 7Xc5C !A4* 4-6,-:,214.9 1)9 >( )..24>0.(+ .,
:'0,2(*6(-6( (14**4,- ,=(2')8 ,: _&A U4.A ]W#!]WHC !,
6,-:421 .A4* 6,-6'0*4,-N .A( (14**4,- *8(6.2) ,: &AN _&A )-+
]W#!]WH U(2( .(*.(+ 4- U).(2 *9*.(1 ). .A( (K64.).4,-
U)=('(-3.A ,: H[M -1C ]43C 7X[5 *A,U* .A). .A( :'0,2(*6(-6(
(14**4,- *8(6.2) ,: _&A )-+ ]W#!]WH A)* ,=(2')884-3 8)2.*N
UA4'( .A). ,: &A )-+ ]W#!]WH +,(* -,.C !A( 2(*0'. 4-+46).(*
.A). _&A A)* .A( :'0,2(*6(-6( 6,18(-*).4,- (::(6. :,2 .A(
\0(-6A(+ ]W#!]WHC S)*(+ ,- .A(*( :4-+4-3*N .A( ',U +(.(6.4,-
2).( )-+ j*= =)'0(* ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+ _&A .A)- .A). ,: &A 6)-
>( )..24>0.(+ ., .A( *',U(2 +4::0*4,- 2).( ,: _&A )-+ 4.*
:'0,2(*6(-6( 6,18(-*).4,- (::(6.C
]W#!]WHNHNMHNMXNZZ *033(*.4-3 .A). )+*,28.4,- 4-+06(+
82(6,-6(-.2).4,- (::(6. 4* )'*, >(-(:464)' ., .A( &AA*
+(.(6.4,-C
,&.;'?+"&.+
"- *011)29N >9 6,-*.206.4-3 .A( S!DD 1,-,1(2 U4.A A#d
(::(6. 4-., .A( :2)1(U,2V ,: MD 0'.2).A4- 6,=)'(-. .24)P4-(
:2)1(U,2V -)-,*A((.N .A( .A4)+4)P,'(W>)*(+ ]W#!]WH U4.A
422(30')2 A(K)3,-)' 8,2( *.206.02( U)* *9-.A(*4P(+C EU4-3 .,
.A( *9-(239 ,: .A( )-6A,24-3 )-+ +4'0.4-3 (::(6.N ]W#!]WH
8,**(**(* .A( 106A A43A(2 :'0,2(*6(-6( \0)-.01 94('+ )-+
2)+4).4=( 2).( 6,-*.)-. .A)- .A,*( ,: .A( S!DD 1,-,1(2C
"-.(2(*.4-3'9N .A( ]W#!]WH 4* .A( :42*. :'0,2(*6(-. 82,>( .A).
(KA4>4.* (K6(''(-. *('(6.4=4.9 )-+ *(-*4.4=4.9 :,2 &AA* *(-*4-3
)1,-3 =)24,0* )14-( 1,'(60'(* 4- U).(2 *9*.(1C ^,2(,=(2N
.A( $ED =)'0(* ,: ]W#!]WH :,2 &A )-+ &DA )2( (*.41).(+ ., >(
FFC[ )-+ FCX[ -^N 2(*8(6.4=('9N UA46A )2( 106A ',U(2 .A)-
)-9 2(8,2.(+ *(-*4-3 1).(24)'*C %K8(241(-.)' )-)'9*4* )-+
D]! 6)'60').4,-* +(1,-*.2).(+ .A). .A( A43A'9 *('(6.4=( )-+
*(-*4.4=( &AA* +(.(6.4,- 4- ]W#!]WH 6)- >( )*624>(+ ., .A(
*.).46 \0(-6A4-3 82,6(**N UA46A +(24=(+ :2,1 .A( :,21).4,-
,: .A( 32,0-+ *.).( -,-W:'0,2(*6(-. 6,18'(K 4-+06(+ >9 .A(
A9+2,3(- >,-+* 4-.(2)6.4,-* >(.U((- &AA* )-+ ]W#!]WHC
q4=(- 4.* ,0.*.)-+4-3 *(-*4.4=( )-+ *('(6.4=( :,2 &AA*
+(.(6.4,- )* U('' )* .A( A43A .A(21)' )-+ 6A(146)' *.)>4'4.9N
]W#!]WH A)* 32(). 82,*8(6.* )* ) :'0,2(*6(-. *(-*,2 :,2
82)6.46)' )88'46).4,-*C
"- )++4.4,-N ., :02.A(2 (=)'0).( .A( 1,'(60')2 *4P( *62((-4-3
(::(6. ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+ &AA*N :,02 &AA* U4.A 4-62(1(-.)'
1,'(60')2 *4P(* ;&AN _&AN A14-, )-.A2)6(-( ;AA!< )-+ XW
)14-,W&W.248A(-9' ;A&!<< U(2( *('(6.(+C 74-6( A&! )-+ AA!
)2( 4-*,'0>'( 4- U).(2N .A( *('(6.(+ )14-(* :,2 :'0,2(*6(-6(
\0(-6A4-3 (K8(241(-.* U(2( 1()*02(+ 4- D^] *9*.(1C A*
*A,U- 4- ]43C 7X` 5 N 4. 6)- >( 82('414-)24'9 :,0-+ .A). .A(
+(.(6.4,- 8(2:,21)-6(* ,: .A( &AA* )-)'9.(* U4.A +4::(2(-.
1,'(60'( *4P( 4- ]W#!]WH +(62()*( 4- .A( :,'',U4-3 ,2+(2?
&A{_&A{AA!{A&!C ]02.A(21,2(N .A( 7g (\0).4,- )-+ j*=
=)'0( U(2( 0.4'4P(+ ., :02.A(2 \0)-.4:9 .A( \0(-6A4-3 )>4'4.9C
A* 4''0*.2).(+ 4- ]43C 7XI )-+ !)>'( 7I5N .A( j*= =)'0(* ,: ]W
#!]WH .,U)2+ &AN _&AN AA! )-+ A&! )2( MCcIsFGXN FC[XsFGXN
XCMM s FGH )-+ XCFH s FGH ^WFN 2(*8(6.4=('9N 4- UA46A .A( j*=
=)'0( ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+ &A U4.A *1)''(*. 1,'(60'( 4* F ,2+(2
,: 1)3-4.0+( A43A(2 .A)- .A). ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+ A&! U4.A
')23(*. 1,'(60'(C !A(2(:,2(N .A( 2(*0'.* 4-+46).( .A). ]W#!]WH
A)* )- ,>=4,0* *62((-4-3 (::(6. ,- .A( &AA* )-)'9.(* U4.A
+4::(2(-. 1,'(60'( *4P(C
,&.6'";/+ &6 "./(0(+/
!A( )0.A,2* +(6')2( -, 6,18(.4-3 :4-)-64)' 4-.(2(*.C
A;4.&3'($8(2(./+
!A4* U,2V 4* *088,2.(+ >9 .A( _).4,-)' _).02)' 764(-6(
],0-+).4,- ,: #A4-) ;_,CMFZHcGGFN MF`[`MMIN )-+
MFI[`MFM<N _).4,-)' j(9 &2,/(6.* :,2 ]0-+)1(-.)' (*()26A
)-+ D(=(',81(-. ,: #A4-) ;MGFcO]SGcGGIGF< )-+ .A(
764(-6( )-+ !(6A-,',39 &')-* ,: !4)-/4- ;_,C
F`&!7OL#GGF`G<C
". *A,0'+ >( -,.46(+ .A). .A( %++),0+4 32,08 +(=(',8(+ )
'014-(*6(-. T2;"g<W>)*(+ ^E] ;T2WS!DSW6;?W^E]< 4- UA46A
.A( .A4)+4)P,'( 0-4. 6)- :2(('9 2,.).( 4- .A( HD :2)1(U,2VC FF
!A4* ^E] (KA4>4.* (K6(''(-. .02-W,- :'0,2(*6(-. +(.(6.4,- ,:
)'48A).46 )14-(* ,- )66,0-. ,: .A( 2(*.246.(+ 2,.).4,- ,: .A(
.A4)+4)P,'( 6,2( 4- .A( HD :2)1(U,2VN 2(+064-3 -,-2)+4).4=(
2(6,1>4-).4,- 8).AU)9* )-+ *0>*(\0(-.'9 (-A)-64-3
(14**4,- 4-.(-*4.9C "- *.)2V 6,-.2)*.N .A( 2,.).4,- ,: .A(
.A4)+4)P,'( 24-3 4- ]W#!]WH 4* '414.(+ >(6)0*( ,: .A(
.A4)+4)P,'( 0-4.* )2( +(-*( *.)6V4-3 4- .A( MD :2)1(U,2VN
.A0* .A( +(.(6.4,- 1(6A)-4*1 ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+ )14-(* 4*
\04.( +4::(2(-. :2,1 .A). ,: T2WS!DSW6;?W^E]C !A( .02-W,::
1,+(' ,: ]W#!]WH .,U)2+ &AA* +(.(6.4,- 4* )..24>0.(+ ., .A(
*.).46 \0(-6A4-3 82,6(**N UA46A +(24=(+ :2,1 .A( :,21).4,-
,: .A( 32,0-+ *.).( -,-W:'0,2(*6(-. 6,18'(K 4-+06(+ >9 .A(
A9+2,3(- >,-+* 4-.(2)6.4,-* >(.U((- &AA* )-+ .A4)+4)P,'(
24-3 ,: ]W#!]WHC "- )++4.4,-N )'.A,03A *,1( -,-8,2,0*
8,'91(2* 6,-.)4-4-3 .A4)+4)P,'( 0-4.* U(2( )'*, 2(8,2.(+ :,2
&AA* +(.(6.4,-N .A(42 8(2:,21)-6(* )2( 4-:(24,2 .A)- .A). ,:
5&/(+ #.$ 0(6(0(.;(+
F
C C Q0N _C $C #C $(0-3 )-+ SC TC !)-3N ?@$0! ")4! N$9!N
MGFXN LIN XXIXWXZcMC
M
SC dC S),N $C QC O0U(-N iC _C TA(-3N $C iC t(-3N iC C TA0N iC
tC TA)- )-+ $C QC t)-3N L! / #$*! ?@$0!N MGFGN EFN IcM`|
IcHXC
H
$C dC 7A4N #C Q(N DC ]C TA0N dC qC Q(N OC $4N OC #A(-N OC iC 70-N
OC OC ]0N DC t(-N QC ^C #), )-+ LC qC #A(-N L! / #$*! ?@$0!N
MGFMN EEN FFcMI|FFcHZC
X
Z
c
$C ]C q),N iC $4-N iC Q)4N iC tC #A(- )-+ LC QC t)-3N A?"
A,,C! / #$*! O.#$*+ 4$1!N MGF`N GFN XHGXIuXHGZcC
qC OC $4N SC TA)-3N LC O)- )-+ TC qC t)-3N L! / #$*! ?@$0! A!N
MGFXN EN F```F|F````C
OC LC TA),N jC 7C ^4),N TC !C TA0 )-+ $C LC ])-N A?" "$.1)*N
MGF[N EN `XMu`X[C
R a L! M 0$CN MGFMN FFN FWH
!A4* /,02-)' 4* b !A( ,9)' 7,64(.9 ,: #A(14*.29 MGKK
&'()*( +, -,. )+/0*. 1)234-*

&'()*( +, -,. )+/0*. 1)234-*
Journal of Materials Chemistry A
Page 9 of 10
View Article Online
DOI: 10.1039/C9TA14252E
D&?0.#' 5#2(
AA @,BC
[
`
I
qC $4)-3N !C $4N iC QC $4 )-+ iC QC $40N H-)1$.1! H-)$C$4#*).!N
MGFHN LRN MH`|MXHC
jC _3)1+((N 7C ^)2.U4*(.N !C !0-.0')-4 )-+ tC _3(,-.)(N
"$.1)*1 .2 A4#E #)*1 H!N MGFMN GQIN c`M|cIFC
tC &C $0*.43N 7C ^0VA(2/((N _C DC 0++N AC gC D(*)4N LC $4 )-+
7C jC qA,*AN ?@$0! ")4! N$9!N MGF[N LON HMXMWHM`ZC
H` iC L4)-3N &C t)-3 )-+ LC LC TA),N L! / #$*! ?@$0! AN MGFZN IN
[[ZG|[[Z`C
HI jC tC t)-3N $C ^C O)-3N iC t)-3N $C &C q0,N qC #A(-3N #C
TA)-3N 7C SC L4-N SC %C !)- )-+ AC #,,8(2N A-3(UC #A(1C "-.C
%+CN MGF[N PON FXFXIWFXFZHC
XG dC L4)-3N QC $C Q0)-3N OC TC !)-3N OC iC TA)-3 )-+ #C $C TA,-3N
O.2! A.7! ?@$0! N$1!N MGF`N PQN FZFFXuFZFMFC
XF jC jC t)-3N QC $C Q0)-3N DC QC $40N #C t)-3N LC &C $4N )-+ #C $C
TA,-3N A.9-*).! "4-! 6$4@.)C!N MGFcN PFN X`cIuX`[cC
XM ^C OC $40N jC L4)-3N iC D4-3N 7C $C t)-3N #C iC TA)-3N LC $40N TC
TA)-N qC #A(-3N SC OC $4N QC #A(-N 7C SC L4- )-+ SC %C !)-N A29!
/ #$*!N MGFIN IGN F`G[`cZC
FG $C dC 7A4N OC OC ]0N #C Q(N DC ]C TA0N OC iC q),N OC C t)-3N dC
qC Q(N QC ^C #), )-+ LC qC #A(-3N ?@$0! ?)00E.!N MGFXN
PFN `[MW`[XC
FF AC ^)''46VN AC ^C %'WT,A29N EC 7A(VA)AN LC O4-N LC !C L4)N QC
A33)2U)'N AC QC %1U)*N EC ]C ^,A)11(+ )-+ ^C %++),0+4N
L! A0! ?@$0! ")4!N MGFIN GLGN [MXZu[MXIC
FM TC _ L4),N OC TA)-3N tC i0N iC !C TA)-3N QC SC L4)-3N &C #C t0N
OC OC ]0N dC qC Q(N QC ^C #), )-+ LC qC #A(-3N A?" "$.1!N
MGF[N EN c`[ucIXC
XH SC t)-3N iC $C $=N DC tC ](-3N $C QC i4(N LC TA)-3N ^C $4N OC SC
i4(N LC C $4 )-+ QC #C TA,0N L! A0! ?@$0! ")4!N MGFcN GIRN
cMGXucMFcC
FH jC jC tC $,N A44! ?@$0! N$1!N MGFZN LRN MI`ZuMIIZC
FX DC tC A21*.2,-3N $C Q( )-+ OC 7C $40N A. C! ?@$0!N FIIIN QGN
H`[HuH`[cC
XX LC ]C D0N OC #C $40N C j24*A-)N OC O0N OC TC #04N 7C t)-3N OC $C
$40N iC tC 7,-3 )-+ TC dC $4)-3N A?" A,,C! / #$*! O.#$*+ 4$15
MGF`N GFN Mcc[`WMcc`cC
FZ TC q0,N iC 7,-3N QC $(4N QC t)-3N 7C 70N QC i0N qC d4)-N QC
TA)-3 )-+ SC #A(-N ?@$0! ?)00E.!N MGFZN PGN H[c|H[IC
Fc OC j,*)V4N QC "P)U)N 7C "*A4A)2)N jC j)U)V)14N ^C 7014.)N OC
!).(9)1)N dC L4N gC j24*A-)-N 7C Q4*A4.)N OC O)1)06A4N LC&C
Q4''N AC g4-0N 7C 7A42).,24 )-+ jC A243)N A?" A,,C! / #$*!
O.#$*+ 4$1N MGFHN PN MIHG|MIHXC
F[ 7C QC $0N C &A)-3 )-+ LC ^C ])-3N P*7! '$##!N MGFcN GRN F[MX|
F[M[C
F` LC ])-N iC #A)-3N ^C Q(N #C 7A)-3N qC t)-3N 7C O4-N QC &(-3
)-+ OC ])-3N A?" A,,C! / #$*! O.#$*+ 4$1N MGFcN RN F`Z`X|
F`ZIMC
XZ $C &C q0,N OC $C _40N 7C )PP)\0(N SC %C !)- )-+ 7C SC L4-N A?"
? # C!5 MGFIN SN IXH`WIXXZC
Xc !C q,-3N &C $4N dC 704N LC dC #A(-N LC QC i0 )-+ %C dC q),N L!
/ #$*! ?@$0! AN MGF`N ON IMHcWIMXXC
X[ lC S)'4/)8)''4N 7C ^)-46V)1N jC !A4201,,2.A9N jC _C
70-+)2)102.A9 )-+ jC "C 7).A49)-)2)9)-)-N L! P*7! ?@$0!N
MGFIN RLN FFZFHuFFZMHC
X` $C ]C q),N iC $4-N iC Q)4N iC tC #A(- )-+ LC QC t)-3N A?"
A,,C! / #$*! O.#$*+ 4$1N MGF`N GFN XHGXIuXHGZcC
XI QC OC j,N OC QC $4-N #C LC 7A4A )-+ OC $C #A(-N L! Q))2! R*E7!
A. C!N MGFIN EQN `MZW`HFC
FI ^C LC AC 7A4++4V9 )-+ AC AC LC !,224(2,N H-)1$.1! H-)$C$4#*).!N
MGFFN EON F[[ZuF[`[C
MG !C )*A((+N #C $C $4N ]C _)>(('N tC Q0)-3 )-+ OC ]C TA,0N
?@$05 A.75 L!N MGFIN IPRN FGF|FGIC
MF 7C tC !A,1)*N qC DC L,'9 )-+ !C ^C 7U)3(2N ?@$0! N$9!N
MGG[N GFQN FHHIWFH`cC
MM 7C OC D4-3N ^C D,-3N OC tC t)-3N OC !C #A(-N QC TC t)-3N #C
OC 70 )-+ tC t)-3N L! A0! ?@$0! ")4!N MGFcN GIRN
HGHFuHGH[C
ZG iC ^C !4)-N 7C $C O),N #C dC d40N !C ]C TA(-3N OC dC #A(-N QC &C
Q0)-3N LC $C #A(-N 7C LC $40 )-+ QC C t(-N O.)*7! ?@$0!N
MGMGN PSN M`GHWM`FGC
ZF AC jC L)-) )-+ 7C _).)2)/)-N ?@$03CE1?@$0N MGF[N REN FFZHW
FFcHC
ZM 7C LC O0N iC iC t)-3N OC LC A4N iC $C !)-N !C Q)9).N tC &C Q0 )-+
iC jC t)-3N L! / #$*! ?@$0! A5 MGFcN LN ZcZXWZccMC
ZH ^C $C #A(-N 7C OC TA,0N TC i0N $C D4-3 )-+ OC QC #A(-3N
/)C$4EC$15 MGFIN ELN H[F`C
MH iC $C $40N iC ]C TA)-3N C $0N &C #C i0(N DC ]C i0 )-+ QC &C TA,0N
L! / #$*! ?@$0!N MGFFN EGN `[Zc|`[cZC
MX iC ]C TA)-3N iC $C $40N C $0N QC LC TA)-3 )-+ &C q,-3N L!
/ #$*! ?@$0!N MGFMN EEN FFc[|FF[MC
MZ tC tC $4N #C D0N ]C QC $4N OC TA,0N ^C ])A'1)-N TC 7C S, )-+ ]C
$C TA)-3N ?@$0! / #$*!N MGGIN EGN ZHM[WZHHXC
Mc jC OC &0 )-+ SC $40N A29! QE.4#! / #$*!N MGGIN GSN M[[WM`XC
M[ &C A-)-.N _C !C $06)* )-+ LC L)6,>N P*7! '$##!N MGG`N GFN
ZZHHWZZHcC
ZX qC &C Q)-N jC jC t)-3N OC qC &(-3N OC iC TA)-3N QC $C Q0)-3
)-+ #C $C TA,-3N O.2! A.7! ?@$0! N$1!5 MGF[N PON FXcHHW
FXcXFC
ZZ SC dC S),N $C QC O0U(-N iC _C TA(-3N $C iC t(-3N iC C TA0N iC
tC TA)- )-+ $C QC t)-3N L! / #$*! ?@$0!5 MGFGN EFN IcM`W
IcHXC
M` jC ^C E1(2N 7C OC j0N jC !C t,-3 )-+ AC LC S)2+N L! A0! ?@$0!
")4!N MGGIN GIGN FG[HHWFG[XFC
MI LC ^(4N OC _C Q,-3N LC tC OC $)1N AC LC d4-N OC QC !)-3 )-+ SC
TC !)-3N A29! / #$*!N MGFXN EON ZXMI|ZX[IC
HG QC SC #A(-3N OC OC $4N SC TC !)-3N )-+ LC O,,-N ?@$0! ")4! N$9!N
MGMGN LSN MFWHFC
HF OC _C Q,-3N LC tC OC $)1) )-+ SC TC !)-3N ?@$0! ?)00E.!N
MGGIN XHHM|XHZHC
HM QC !C ](-3N OC iC O0)-N LC SC i4,-3N OC 7C TA(-3 )-+ SC TC !)-3N
?@$0! ")4! N$9!N MGF`N LQN [XZMW[X[cC
HH OC _C Q,-3N LC tC OC $)1 )-+ SC TC !)-3N ?@$0! ")4! N$9!N
MGFFN LFN ZHcFWZH``C
HX qC OC L4)-3N qC LC T(-3N tC &C TA0N OC DC $4N iC SC D,-3N qC iC
TA)-3N iC $C ])-N LC qC t)-3N OC dC t0 )-+ SC TC !)-3N ?@$0!
?)00E.!N MGF[N PIN XZGZWXZG`C
HZ tC qC !4)-N LC ^C TA)-3N LC O0N LC t0N QC _)U)PN LC TA)-3N LC 7C
Q( )-+ ]C 7C t)-3N A29! P,#-4 C / #$*!N MGFcN LN MGXXWMGZGC
Hc ^C ^)*W!,22(-. )-+ #C ,=42)N ?@$0! ")4! N$9!N MGG`N IQN
`M[W`H`C
H[ OC TC !)-3N QC $C Q0)-3N tC LC i0(N OC LC #A)-3N OC $4N iC OC q0,
)-+ #C $C TA,-3N ?@$0! A.7! L!N MGMGN IRLN FMHH`MC
!A4* /,02-)' 4* b !A( ,9)' 7,64(.9 ,: #A(14*.29 MGKK
L! M 0$CN MGFHN FFN FWH a S
&'()*( +, -,. )+/0*. 1)234-*

Journal of Materials Chemistry A
Page 10 of 10
View Article Online
DOI: 10.1039/C9TA14252E
!"#$ %& '%()$()*
-B8
-B8
783
63
53
43
3
CD
-B8
-
-
E
-B8
-B8
CD
?
A
+A
B
E
-
B
-
-
-B8
-
-
B-
-B8
-
-
-
B
B-
-
-
-
-
-
-
+
0
1
A
,
A
A
A
A
,
A
A
A
A
.
2
A
+
+
+
+
+
A
A
.
A
/
/
A
+
+
-
,
,
/
/
,
!" #!$%&$%'()"*+%,"& -(.%)"/# #0$%'$/" 10%2"3(04 /%/(,!""# $, #!" 1$0,# 1)5(0",-"/#
,"/,(0 #!%# -%/ ,")"-#$.")6 &"#"-# 7AA, 10(2 .%0$(5, %2$/",8