1054
C. Storkey et al. / Free Radical Biology and Medicine 89 (2015) 1049–1056
modulates the environment and reactivity of the selenol. This
conclusion is supported by the variation in k2 between the various
selenols (Table 1), with the data being consistent with the
neighboring groups modulating selenol reactivity. Of the selenols
examined, the lowest k2 values were for 3-selenopropionic acid
and Sec (both approximately 5 ꢁ 105 Mꢀ1 sꢀ1) with higher values
determined for Sec methyl ester (k2 1.2 ꢁ 106 Mꢀ1 sꢀ1) and re-
reactions. These reactions also generate nitroso, nitro, nitroso-thiol
and nitro-thiol products, in addition to the disulfides [68–72]. The
identities of the materials formed from the seleno species remain
to be determined, though it is probable that the major route is a
2-electron (molecular) reaction to give a selenenic (RSeOH) spe-
cies before reaction with another selenol, to give the diselenide.
The data reported in Table 1 allow conclusions to be drawn as
to the potential importance of peroxynitrite reactions with sulfur-
versus seleno-species within cells and extracellular fluids. Within
cells, the high concentration of low-molecular-mass thiols (e.g.
GSH; 2–5 mM [73]) compared to sub micromolar levels of en-
dogenous low-molecular-mass selenols/selenides/diselenides,
suggests that there will be a marked selectivity for thiol oxidation,
despite the higher reactivity of selenols/selenides/diselenides. In
duced selenocystamine (k2 7.1–19.0 ꢁ 105 Mꢀ1 sꢀ1).
A similar
trend is apparent for the corresponding thiols, though these values
were much lower than for the selenium analogs, with the highest
values determined for the methyl ester of cysteine
(3.9 ꢁ 103 Mꢀ1 sꢀ1). These data suggest that the presence of a
suitably positioned ionized carboxyl group decreases the rate of
reaction, and a protonated amine group enhances the rate of re-
action, though the exact reason for this observation remains to be
established.
Previous studies have reported k2 for reaction of peroxynitrite
with Cys to be 4.5 ꢁ 103 Mꢀ1 sꢀ1 [7] and 1.36 ꢁ 103 Mꢀ1 sꢀ1 at
37 °C for GSH [63]. These values are between 1.7 and 1.9-fold faster
than determined here at 22 °C. The similarity of the ratio of the k2
values at these two different temperatures for Cys and GSH, sug-
gests that realistic estimates can be made for other species at
37 °C, if required.
All the selenides examined had similar k2 values, with both the
novel 6-membered ring seleno-sugar SeGul, and the 5-membered
ring species SeTal, being 2.5 ꢁ 103 Mꢀ1 sꢀ1. Interestingly 3-(sele-
nomethyl)cysteine (1.9 ꢁ 103 Mꢀ1 sꢀ1) displayed a slightly lower
rate constant than SeMet (2.4 ꢁ 103 Mꢀ1 sꢀ1), suggesting that an
increased distance between the seleno center and the other
functional groups enhances reactivity; this may reflect a diminu-
tion of through bond electron withdrawing effects. Comparison of
these data with those of the corresponding sulfur-analogs (e.g.
thiogulose, SGul, k2 2.1 ꢁ 102 Mꢀ1 sꢀ1) indicates an approximate
12-fold decrease in reactivity, consistent with the difference be-
tween SeMet and Met (Table 1).
the case of exogenously added species (supplementation), high M
μ
levels of added seleno compounds would be needed before direct
seleno oxidation becomes significant.
With Sec residues on proteins, the situation is more favorable.
As thioredoxin reductase is only present at nM levels in cells [74]
this is unlikely to be a major target when compared to GSH or
protein thiols. In contrast, cellular concentrations of GPx are high
(ꢃ2
μM [74,75]) and may compete with GSH for peroxynitrite in
the light of the values presented in Table 2. These data are con-
sistent with a report that GPx can act as a peroxynitrite reductase,
thereby preventing peroxynitrite-induced damage [76]. A similar
argument applies to intracellular protein-bound Cys residues,
which are present at millimolar concentrations (cf. protein thiol
concentrations in mitochondria of 60–90 mM [77,78]), though the
higher k2 values for some protein-Cys residues compared to GSH
(cf. Table 2), may mitigate against this. In particular, proteins with
low pKa Cys residues (e.g. cytosolic peroxiredoxins, Prx1 and Prx2,
which are present in Jurkat cells at ꢃ65
μ
M, and mitochondrial
M [79]) would be expected to out-
Prx3 which is present at ꢃ125
μ
compete reaction with GPx.
In extracellular fluids, the situation is very different, as the
For the diselenides the highest values of k2 were determined for
3,3′-diselenodipropionoic acid (1.3 ꢁ 103 Mꢀ1 sꢀ1) with lower values
determined for the 3,3′-diselenide form of the Sec methyl ester
(7.3 ꢁ 102 Mꢀ1 sꢀ1) and 3,3′-diselenocystamine (7.2 ꢁ 102 Mꢀ1 sꢀ1).
These values indicate that diselenides per se offer limited scavenging
activity against peroxynitrite in biological systems when compared to
their reduced (selenol) forms. However as diselenides are likely to be
reduced in vivo (cf. the ready reduction of disulfides to thiols), these
species may act as potential pro-forms of the more reactive selenols.
Data for the analogous disulfide reaction could not be obtained due to
the (relatively) rapid intrinsic decay of peroxynitrite under these
conditions, consistent with a previous report for glutathione disulfide
where no increased rate of peroxynitrite decay was observed [63]. The
cyclic disulfide lipoic acid does however enhance the rate of perox-
ynitrite decay (k2 1.4 ꢁ 103 Mꢀ1 sꢀ1 at 37 °C), with this resulting in
disulfide S-oxide (thiosulfinate) formation [63].
concentration of the low-molecular-mass thiol pool in plasma is
low (cf. 12–19
incorporated Cys (primarily Cys-34 of human serum albumin;
nominally 400–600 M, although a significant fraction of this is
μ
M) [80], compared to the concentration of protein-
μ
present in modified forms [80]). At these thiol concentrations, and
with a 250–830 greater reactivity of selenols over thiols with
peroxynitrite (Table 1), reaction of peroxynitrite with low-mole-
cular-mass plasma selenols, selenides and diselenides would be
competitive if these were present at low
μM levels. For extra-
cellular selenoproteins, the (up to) 10 Sec residues of selenoprotein
P (the most abundant seleno species in plasma [81]) would be
expected to be competitive for peroxynitrite (relative to both free-
and protein Cys residues) on the basis of the determined k2 value
for free Sec (Tables 1 and 2), and the reported plasma concentra-
tions of this seleno protein, which range from 0.8 to 2
μ
M, and
hence a total Sec concentration of up to 20 M [81]. This conclu-
μ
Although the present study has provided absolute kinetic data
for the reactivity of peroxynitrite with selenols and other seleno-
species, the mechanisms and products of these reactions remain to
be fully defined. The major pathway for the analogous thiol reac-
tions has been reported to be a (2-electron) molecular process
involving nucleophilic attack of the thiolate anion on one of the
peroxidic oxygens of peroxynitrite resulting in the formation of an
intermediate sulfenic acid (RSOH), which then reacts rapidly with
another thiol to give the disulfide [7]. The RSOH intermediate has
been detected in some cases (e.g. on peroxiredoxins [43] and al-
bumin [67]). However radicals that may be generated as a result of
peroxynitrite homolysis (either in the absence or presence of CO2)
sion is consistent with experimental data [29]. Plasma con-
centrations of extracellular GPx (GPx3) and thioredoxin reductase
are lower: 0.24–0.6
μ
M (and hence 0.96–2.4 M Sec given its
μ
tetrameric structure) and 0.3 nM respectively [74, 82]. On the basis
of these data, reaction of peroxynitrite with the Sec residues of
GPx3 may be significant (given a concentration ratio of protein Sec
to Cys of 0.96–2.4
Table 2), but scavenging of peroxynitrite by extracellular thior-
edoxin reductase would not.
μ
M : 400–600
μM, and a k2 ratio of ꢃ800; cf.
Overall, these data indicate that selenols and other seleno-
species are targets for peroxynitrite, with rate constants for sele-
nols being significantly faster than for thiols, and selenides being
faster than sulfides/thioethers. Diselenides also exhibit consider-
able reactivity towards peroxynitrite, though their k2 values are
lower than for both selenols and selenides. The diselenides are
ꢂ
may also mediate thiol oxidation via formation of thiyl (RS ),
disulfide radical-anion (RSSR ꢀ) and sulfinyl (RSO ) radicals, with
ꢂ
ꢂ
these and other species participating in dioxygen-dependent chain