ꢀ
NajmehꢀNowrouziꢀetꢀal.ꢀ/ꢀChineseꢀJournalꢀofꢀCatalysisꢀ34ꢀ(2013)ꢀ1787–1790ꢀ
&&#ꢁꢂ!#27*ꢂ2#"ꢁ.0-"3!21ꢁ5#0#ꢁ!&ꢂ0ꢂ!2#0'8#"ꢁ 7ꢁ2&#ꢁ!-+.ꢂ0'1-,ꢁ
O
S
SU
-$ꢁ 2&#'0ꢁ 1.#!20ꢂ*ꢁ ꢃ'%ꢁ ꢂ,"ꢁ Kꢁ ꢂ,"ꢁ ꢀꢁ )2%ꢄꢁ ꢂ,"ꢁ .&71'! ꢂ*ꢁ "ꢂ2ꢂꢁ
H3C
N
NH CH3COO
(8.0 mol%)
5'2&ꢁ2&-1#ꢁ-$ꢁ2&#ꢁꢂ32&#,2'!ꢁ1ꢂ+.*#1Tꢁ
X
CH3
R
RXH
',ꢁꢂꢁ27.'!ꢂ*ꢁ.0-!#"30#ꢁ$-0ꢁ2&#ꢁ!-,4#01'-,ꢁ-$ꢁꢂ,'*',#ꢁ',2-ꢁꢂ!V
(CH3CO)2O, r.t.
O
#2ꢂ,'*'"#Qꢁꢂ,'*',#ꢁꢃSTRꢁ++-*QꢁRTR[ꢁ+ꢆꢄꢁ5ꢂ1ꢁꢂ""#"ꢁ2-ꢁꢂꢁ12'00#"ꢁ
+'6230#ꢁ-$ꢁꢂ!#2'!ꢁꢂ,&7"0'"#ꢁꢃTTRꢁ++-*QꢁRTSZZꢁ+ꢆꢄꢁꢂ,"ꢁ'+'"ꢂ8V
-*#ꢁ ꢃRTRZꢁ ++-*Qꢁ RTRRWꢁ %ꢄꢁ ꢂ2ꢁ 0--+ꢁ 2#+.#0ꢂ230#Qꢁ ꢂ,"ꢁ 2&#ꢁ .0-V
%0#11ꢁ-$ꢁ2&#ꢁ0#ꢂ!2'-,ꢁ5ꢂ1ꢁ+-,'2-0#"ꢁ 7ꢁ&ꢆꢀTꢁQ.-,ꢁ!-+.*#2'-,ꢁ
X = O, NH
R = alkyl, phenyl
ꢀ
Schemeꢀ 1.ꢀ $!7*'+'"ꢂ8-*'3+ꢁ ꢂ!#2ꢂ2#ꢁ !ꢂ2ꢂ*78#"ꢁ ꢂ!#27*ꢂ2'-,ꢁ -$ꢁ ꢂ*!-&-*1Qꢁ
.&#,-*1Qꢁꢂ,"ꢁꢂ+',#1ꢁ5'2&ꢁꢂ!#2'!ꢁꢂ,&7"0'"#Tꢁ
-$ꢁ2&#ꢁ0#ꢂ!2'-,ꢁꢃSꢁ+',ꢄQꢁ5ꢂ2#0ꢁꢃUꢁ+ꢆꢄꢁ5ꢂ1ꢁꢂ""#"ꢁ2-ꢁ2&#ꢁ+'6230#Qꢁ
0#13*2',%ꢁ',ꢁ2&#ꢁ.0#!'.'2ꢂ2'-,ꢁ-$ꢁ2&#ꢁꢂ!#2ꢂ,'*'"#Qꢁ5&'!&ꢁ5ꢂ1ꢁ!-*V
*#!2#"ꢁ 7ꢁ$'*20ꢂ2'-,ꢁꢂ,"ꢁ5ꢂ1&#"ꢁ5'2&ꢁ5ꢂ2#0ꢁ #$-0#ꢁ #',%ꢁ"0'#"ꢁ
ꢂ,"ꢋ-0ꢁ !ꢂ2ꢂ*7121ꢁ $-0ꢁ -0%ꢂ,'!ꢁ 17,2'1Tꢁ *-0ꢁ 2#ꢁ 0#ꢂ1-,1Qꢁ ꢂꢁ
3,"#0ꢁ4ꢂ!33+ꢁꢂ2ꢁYRꢁ5ꢀꢁ2-ꢁ%'4#ꢁ2&#ꢁ"#1'0#"ꢁ.0-"3!2ꢁ',ꢁ&'%&ꢁ.3V
4ꢂ0'#27ꢁ-$ꢁ"'$$#0#,2ꢁ0#ꢂ!2'-,1ꢁꢈTSꢅTVꢉQꢁ',!*3"',%ꢁ2&#ꢁꢂ!#27*ꢂ2'-,ꢁ
2K8QꢁꢀCꢀ*UꢄSꢁꢁꢀTVTVQꢁSTRTTQꢁSTVTUQꢁSTZT[QꢁSUZTSQꢁSXS[TTTꢁ
0'27ꢁ ꢂ1ꢁ !-*-0*#11ꢁ !0712ꢂ*1ꢁ ꢃRTSTZꢁ %Qꢁ [W$ꢁ 7'#*"ꢄTꢁ Kꢁ )2%ꢁ ꢃVRRꢁ
-$ꢁ &7"0-67*ꢁ %0-3.1Qꢁ &ꢂ4#ꢁ ##,ꢁ ! -,"3! 2#"ꢁ ',ꢁ 'ꢆ1Tꢁ K#0#',Qꢁ 5#ꢁ
0#.-02ꢁ2&ꢂ2ꢁ2&#ꢁ',ꢁ1'23ꢁ%#,#0ꢂ2#"ꢁ'ꢆꢁꢂ!7*'+'"ꢂ8-*'3+ꢁꢂ!#2ꢂ2#ꢁ!ꢂ,ꢁ
#ꢁ31#"ꢁꢂ,ꢁ#6!#**#,2ꢁꢂ!7*ꢂ2',%ꢁꢂ%#,2ꢁꢂ,"ꢁ!ꢂ2ꢂ*712ꢁ$-0ꢁ2&#ꢁꢂ!#27V
*ꢂ2'-,ꢁ-$ꢁꢂ*!-&-*1Qꢁ.&#,-*1Qꢁꢂ,"ꢁꢂ+',#1ꢁꢃ-!&#+#ꢁSꢄTꢁ
2K8QꢁꢀCꢀ*UꢄSꢁꢁꢁTTSYꢁꢃ1QꢁUKꢄQꢁYTSTꢁꢃ2QꢁJꢁ-ꢁYTTꢁK8QꢁSKꢄQꢁYTUSꢁꢃ2QꢁJꢁ-ꢁ
SU
YTXꢁK8QꢁTKꢄQꢁYTWVꢁꢃ"QꢁJꢁ-ꢁYTXꢁK8QꢁTKꢄQꢁZTTSꢁꢃ1QꢁSKꢄTꢁ ꢀꢁ)2%ꢁꢃSRRꢁ
',ꢁꢂꢁ27.'!ꢂ*ꢁ.0-!#"30#ꢁ$-0ꢁ2&#ꢁ!-,4#01'-,ꢁ-$ꢁꢂꢁ #,87*ꢁꢂ*!-&-*ꢁ
&-ꢁ #%',ꢁ5'2&Qꢁ5#ꢁ!-,"3!2#"ꢁꢂꢁ1#0'#1ꢁ-$ꢁ.0#*'+',ꢂ07ꢁ#6.#0V
',2-ꢁ ꢂꢁ #,87*ꢁ ꢂ!#2ꢂ2#Qꢁ #,87*ꢁ ꢂ*!-&-*ꢁ ꢃSTRꢁ ++-*Qꢁ RTSꢁ +ꢆꢄꢁ 5ꢂ1ꢁ
'+#,21ꢁ31',%ꢁ #,87*ꢁꢂ*!-&-*ꢁꢂ1ꢁꢂꢁ+-"#*ꢁ!-+.-3,"Qꢁ5&'!&ꢁ5ꢂ1ꢁ
ꢂ""#"ꢁ2-ꢁꢂꢁ12'00#"ꢁ1-*32'-,ꢁ-$ꢁ'+'"ꢂ8-*#ꢁꢃRTRZꢁ++-*QꢁRTRRWꢁ%ꢄꢁ
0#ꢂ!2#"ꢁ 5'2&ꢁ ꢂ!#2'!ꢁ ꢂ,&7"0'"#ꢁ ꢂ,"ꢁ '+'"ꢂ8-*#ꢁ ꢂ2ꢁ ꢂ+ '#,2ꢁ 2#+V
ꢂ,"ꢁꢂ!#2'!ꢁꢂ,&7"0'"#ꢁꢃTTRꢁ++-*QꢁRTSZZꢁ+ꢆꢄꢁꢂ2ꢁꢂ+ '#,2ꢁ2#+.#0V
.#0ꢂ230#TꢁQ,"#0ꢁ2#ꢁ!-,"'2'-,1QꢁZTRꢁ+-*$ꢁ-$ꢁꢂ!7*'+'"ꢂ8-*'3+ꢁ
ꢂ230#Qꢁꢂ,"ꢁ2&#ꢁ.0-%0#11ꢁ-$ꢁ2&#ꢁ0#ꢂ!2'-,ꢁ5ꢂ1ꢁ+-,'2-0#"ꢁ 7ꢁ&ꢆꢀTꢁ
ꢂ!#2ꢂ2#ꢁ5ꢂ1ꢁ$-3,"ꢁ2-ꢁ #ꢁ13$$'!'#,2ꢁ$-0ꢁ2&#ꢁ!-+.*#2#ꢁ!-,4#01'-,ꢁ
Q.-,ꢁ !-+.*#2'-,ꢁ -$ꢁ 2&#ꢁ 0#ꢂ!2'-,ꢁ ꢃUꢁ &ꢄQꢁ 2&#ꢁ 0#1'"3#ꢁ 5ꢂ1ꢁ 13 V
-$ꢁ STRꢁ ++-*ꢁ -$ꢁ ꢂ*!-&-*ꢁ ',ꢁ 2&#ꢁ .0#1#,!#ꢁ -$ꢁ TTRꢁ ++-*ꢁ -$ꢁ ꢂ!#2'!ꢁ
(#!2#"ꢁ 2-ꢁ .30'$'!ꢂ2'-,ꢁ -,ꢁ ꢂꢁ 1&-02ꢁ !-*3+,ꢁ -$ꢁ 1'*'!ꢂꢁ %#*Qꢁ 31',%ꢁ
ꢂ,&7"0'"#Tꢁ*302�ꢁ',!0#ꢂ1#1ꢁ',ꢁ2&#ꢁꢂ+-3,2ꢁ-$ꢁ2&#ꢁ!ꢂ2ꢂ*712ꢁ*#"ꢁ
2-ꢁꢂꢁ0#"3!2'-,ꢁ',ꢁ2&#ꢁ0#ꢂ!2'-,ꢁ2'+#ꢁ5'2&ꢁ-,*7ꢁ,#%*'%' *#ꢁ',!0#ꢂ1V
nVꢂ,#ꢋ#2&7*ꢁꢂ!#2ꢂ2#ꢁꢃSRSSꢄꢁꢂ1ꢁ2&#ꢁ#*3#,2Qꢁ2-ꢁ%'4#ꢁ2&#ꢁ"#1'0#"ꢁ
S
#,87*ꢁꢂ!#2ꢂ2#ꢁꢂ1ꢁ!-*-0*#11ꢁ*'/3'"ꢁꢃRTSVꢁ%Qꢁ[V$ꢁ7'#*"ꢄTꢁ Kꢁ)2%ꢁ
#1ꢁ',ꢁ2&#ꢁ7'#*"Tꢁ&-ꢁ#6.*-0#ꢁ2&#ꢁ%#,#0ꢂ*'27ꢁꢂ,"ꢁ1!-.#ꢁ-$ꢁ2&'1ꢁ,#5ꢁ
ꢃVRRꢁ 2K8Qꢁ ꢀCꢀ*UꢄSꢁ ꢁꢁ TTSUꢁ ꢃ1Qꢁ UKꢄQꢁ WTSVꢁ ꢃ1Qꢁ TKꢄQꢁ YTT[ꢅYTVUꢁ ꢃ+Qꢁ
+#2&-"Qꢁꢂꢁ4#0'27ꢁ-$ꢁ"'$$#0#,2ꢁꢂ*!-&-*1ꢁ5#0#ꢁꢂ!#27*ꢂ2#"ꢁ3,"#0ꢁ2&#ꢁ
WKꢄTꢁ
-.2'+'8#"ꢁ0#ꢂ!2'-,ꢁ!-,"'2'-,1ꢁꢂ,"ꢁ2&#ꢁ0#13*21ꢁꢂ0#ꢁ*'12#"ꢁ',ꢁ&ꢂV
',ꢁꢂꢁ27.'!ꢂ*ꢁ .0-!#"30#ꢁ$-0ꢁ2&#ꢁ !-,4#01'-,ꢁ-$ꢁVV#2&7*.&#,-*ꢁ
*#ꢁSTꢁ
',2-ꢁ VV#2&7*.&#,7*ꢁ ꢂ! #2ꢂ2#Qꢁ VV#2&7*.&#,-*ꢁ ꢃSꢁ ++-*Qꢁ RTSTTꢁ %ꢄꢁ
$1ꢁ!ꢂ,ꢁ #ꢁ1##,ꢁ',ꢁ&ꢂ *#ꢁSQꢁ2&#ꢁꢂ..*'!ꢂ2'-,ꢁ-$ꢁ2&#ꢁ-.2'+'8#"ꢁ
5ꢂ1ꢁꢂ""#"ꢁ2-ꢁꢂꢁ12'00#"ꢁ1-*32'-,ꢁ-$ꢁ'+'"ꢂ8-*#ꢁꢃRTRZꢁ++-*QꢁRTRRWꢁ
0#ꢂ!2'-,ꢁ !-,"'2'-,1ꢁ 2-ꢁ ꢂꢁ 0ꢂ,%#ꢁ -$ꢁ "'$$#0#,2ꢁ #,87*'!Qꢁ .0'+ꢂ07ꢁ
%ꢄꢁꢂ,"ꢁꢂ!#2'!ꢁꢂ,&7"0'"#ꢁꢃTTRꢁ++-*QꢁRTSZZꢁ+ꢆꢄꢁꢂ2ꢁꢂ+ '#,2ꢁ2#+V
ꢂ,"ꢁ1#!-,"ꢂ07ꢁꢂ*!-&-*1ꢁ%ꢂ4#ꢁ2&#ꢁ!-00#1.-,"',%ꢁ#12#01ꢁ',ꢁ%--"ꢁ
.#0ꢂ230#Qꢁꢂ,"ꢁ2&#ꢁ.0-%0#11ꢁ-$ꢁ2&#ꢁ0#13*2',%ꢁ0#ꢂ!2'-,ꢁ5ꢂ1ꢁ+-,'V
2-ꢁ #6!#**#,2ꢁ 7'#*"1Tꢁ ,#,87*ꢁ ꢂ*!-&-*1ꢁ #ꢂ0',%ꢁ #*#!20-,ꢁ "-,ꢂ2',%ꢁ
2-0#"ꢁ 7ꢁ &ꢆꢀTꢁ Q.-,ꢁ !-+.*#2'-,ꢁ -$ꢁ 2&#ꢁ 0#ꢂ!2'-,ꢁ ꢃTTWꢁ &ꢄQꢁ 2&#ꢁ
%0-3.1Qꢁ 13!&ꢁ ꢂ1ꢁ pV+#2&-67 #,87*ꢁ ꢂ*!-&-*Qꢁ 0#ꢂ!2#"ꢁ $ꢂ12#0ꢁ 2&ꢂ,ꢁ
!03"#ꢁ .0-"3!2ꢁ +'6230#ꢁ 5ꢂ1ꢁ .30'$'#"ꢁ 7ꢁ !-*3+,ꢁ !&0-+ꢂ2-%V
#,87*ꢁ ꢂ*!-&-*ꢁ ꢃ&ꢂ *#ꢁ SQꢁ #,207ꢁ TꢄQꢁ 5�#ꢂ1ꢁ #,87*ꢁ ꢂ*!-&-*1ꢁ
0ꢂ.&7ꢁ-,ꢁ1'*'!ꢂꢁ%#*ꢁ31',%ꢁnVꢂ,#ꢋ#2&7*ꢁꢂ!#2ꢂ20#ꢁꢃSRSSꢄꢁꢂ1ꢁ2&#ꢁ
#ꢂ0',%ꢁ#*#!20-,ꢁ5'2&"0ꢂ5',%ꢁ%0-3.1Qꢁ13!&ꢁoV,'20- #,87*ꢁꢂ*!-V
#*3#,2ꢁ2-ꢁ%'4#ꢁVV#2&7*.&#,7*ꢁꢂ!#2ꢂ2#ꢁꢂ1ꢁ!-*-0*#11ꢁ*'/3'"ꢁꢃRTSVUꢁ%Qꢁ
&-*Qꢁ0#ꢂ!2#"ꢁ1*3%%'1&*7ꢁ5'2&ꢁ2&#ꢁ!-00#1.-,"',%ꢁ#12#0ꢁ #',%ꢁ'1-V
S
ZY$ꢁ7'#*"ꢄTꢁ Kꢁ)2%ꢁꢃVRRꢁ2K8QꢁꢀCꢀ*UꢄSꢁꢁꢀSTUSꢁꢃ2QꢁJꢁ-ꢁYTXꢁK8Q UKꢄQꢁ
*ꢂ2#"ꢁ',ꢁZZ$ꢁ7'#*"ꢁꢂ$2#0ꢁWTWꢁ&ꢁꢃ&ꢂ *#ꢁSQꢁ#,207ꢁWꢄTꢁ30'+ꢂ07ꢁꢂ,"ꢁ
1#! -,"ꢂ07ꢁ ꢂ*! -&-*1ꢁ %#,#0ꢂ**7ꢁ .0-4'"#"ꢁ &'%&ꢁ 7'#*"1ꢁ -$ꢁ 2&#ꢁ "#V
TTUUꢁꢃ1QꢁUKꢄQꢁTTYSꢁꢃ/QꢁJꢁ-ꢁYTXꢁK8QꢁTKꢄQꢁYTRYꢁꢃ"QꢁJꢁ-ꢁZTVꢁK8QꢁTKꢄQꢁYTTYꢁ
SU
ꢃ"QꢁJꢁ-ꢁZTVꢁK8QꢁTKꢄTꢁ ꢀꢁ)2%ꢁꢃSRRꢁ2K8QꢁꢀCꢀ*UꢄSꢁꢁꢀSWTXQꢁTSTSQꢁTZTUQꢁ
1'0#"ꢁ .0-"3! 21ꢁ 3,"#0ꢁ 2&#ꢁ -.2'+'8#"ꢁ ! -,"'2'-,1Qꢁ 5�#ꢂ1ꢁ 2&#ꢁ
STSTUQꢁSTZTZQꢁSVSTYQꢁSVZTYQꢁSX[TYTꢁ
2#02'ꢂ07ꢁ ꢂ*! -&-*ꢁ SVꢂ"ꢂ+ꢂ,2ꢂ,-*ꢁ $ꢂ'*#"ꢁ 2-ꢁ .0-4'"#ꢁ ꢂ,7ꢁ -$ꢁ 2&#ꢁ
',ꢁ ꢂꢁ 27.'! ꢂ*ꢁ .0-! #"30#ꢁ $-0ꢁ 2&#ꢁ 0#31ꢂ '*'27ꢁ -$ꢁ 2&#ꢁ ! ꢂ2ꢂ*712Qꢁ "#1'0#"ꢁ.0-"3!2ꢁꢃ&ꢂ *#ꢁSQꢁ#,207ꢁSSꢄTꢁ'2ꢁ'1ꢁ,-2#5-02&7ꢁ2&ꢂ2ꢁ2&#ꢁ
NVꢂ!7*'+'"ꢂ8-*'3+ꢁ ꢂ!#2ꢂ2#ꢁ '1ꢁ 1-*3 *#ꢁ ',ꢁ 5ꢂ2#0Tꢁ $2ꢁ 2&#ꢁ #,"ꢁ -$ꢁ
-.2'!ꢂ**7ꢁ ꢂ!2'4#ꢁ ꢂ*!-&-*Qꢁ ꢃꢅꢄV+#,2&-*Qꢁ %ꢂ4#ꢁ +#,2&7*ꢁ ꢂ!#2ꢂ2#ꢁ ',ꢁ
#ꢂ!&ꢁ0#ꢂ!2'-,QꢁnVꢂ,#ꢁꢃWꢁ+ꢆꢄꢁꢂ,"ꢁ5ꢂ2#0ꢁꢃWꢁ+ꢆꢄꢁ5#0#ꢁꢂ""#"ꢁ
YW$ꢁ'1-*ꢂ2#"ꢁ7'#*"ꢁꢃ&ꢂ *#ꢁSQꢁ#,207ꢁSRꢄTꢁ,ꢂ1#"ꢁ-,ꢁꢂꢁ!-+.ꢂ0'1-,ꢁ
2-ꢁ2&#ꢁ0#ꢂ!2'-,ꢁ+'6230#Qꢁꢂ,"ꢁ2&#ꢁ0#13*2',%ꢁ+'6230#ꢁ5ꢂ1ꢁ12'00#"ꢁ
-$ꢁ2&#ꢁ-.2'!ꢂ*ꢁ0-2ꢂ2'-,ꢁ-$ꢁ2&#ꢁ+#,2&7*ꢁꢂ!#2ꢂ2#ꢁ.0-"3!2ꢁ5'2&ꢁ2&#ꢁ
$-0ꢁUꢁ+',Tꢁ&&#ꢁ-0%ꢂ,'!ꢁ*ꢂ7#0ꢁ5ꢂ1ꢁ2&#,ꢁ!-**#!2#"ꢁꢂ,"ꢁ#4ꢂ.-0ꢂ2#"ꢁ
4ꢂ*3#ꢁ$0-+ꢁ2&#ꢁ*'2#0ꢂ230#ꢁꢈTWꢉQꢁ2&#ꢁ0#ꢂ!2'-,ꢁ5ꢂ1ꢁ$-3,"ꢁ2-ꢁ-!!30ꢁ
2-ꢁ"07,#11ꢁ2-ꢁ%'4#ꢁꢂꢁ!03"#ꢁ0#1'"3#Qꢁ5&'!&ꢁ5ꢂ1ꢁ.30'$'#"ꢁ 7ꢁ!-*V
5'2&ꢁꢂꢁ&'%&ꢁ*#4#*ꢁ-$ꢁ0#2#,2'-,ꢁꢂ,"ꢁ-.2'!ꢂ*ꢁ.30'27ꢁꢃ[Y$ꢁ##ꢄTꢁ&&#ꢁ
3+,ꢁ!&0-+ꢂ2-%0ꢂ.&7ꢁ-4#0ꢁ1'*'!ꢂꢁ%#*ꢁ2-ꢁ%'4#ꢁ2&#ꢁ.30#ꢁ.0-"3!2Qꢁ
ꢂ..*'!ꢂ2'-,ꢁ -$ꢁ 2&#ꢁ -.2'+'8#"ꢁ !-,"'2'-,1ꢁ 2-ꢁ #,-*'8ꢂ *#ꢁ SQUV
ꢁ
ꢂ1ꢁ "#1! 0' #"ꢁ ꢂ -4#Tꢁ &&#ꢁ ꢂ/3#-31ꢁ .&ꢂ1#ꢁ ! -,2ꢂ',',%ꢁ 2&#ꢁ '-,'! ꢁ
"')#2-,#1ꢁ 2&ꢂ2ꢁ !-3*"ꢁ ,-2ꢁ $-0+ꢁ !7!*'!ꢁ &7"0-%#,V -,"#"ꢁ 1203!V
*'/3'"ꢁꢃ'ꢆꢄꢁ5ꢂ1ꢁ#4ꢂ.-0ꢂ2#"ꢁ2-ꢁ"07,#11ꢁ3,"#0ꢁ0#"3!#"ꢁ.0#1130#ꢁ
230#1ꢁ%ꢂ4#ꢁ2&#ꢁ!-00#1.-,"',%ꢁ#,-*Vꢂ!#2ꢂ2#1Tꢁ*-0ꢁ#6ꢂ+.*#QꢁWQWV
ꢁ
2-ꢁ %'4#ꢁ 2&#ꢁ !ꢂ2ꢂ*712Qꢁ 5&'!&ꢁ 5ꢂ1ꢁ 13 1#/3#,2*7ꢁ 0#!-4#0#"ꢁ ꢂ,"ꢁ
"'+#2&7*V
ꢁ
SQUV!7!*-ꢂ,#"'-,#ꢁ 5ꢂ1ꢁ /3ꢂ,2'2ꢂ2'4#*7ꢁ !-,4#02#"ꢁ
0#31#"Tꢁ
2-ꢁ2&#ꢁ!-00#1.-,"',%ꢁ#,-*Vꢂ!#2ꢂ2#ꢁꢃ&ꢂ *#ꢁSQꢁ#,207ꢁTWꢄTꢁ',ꢁ!-,V
20ꢂ12Qꢁ .#,2ꢂ,#VTQVV"'-,#Qꢁ 5&'!&ꢁ '1ꢁ ꢂ,ꢁ #,-*'8ꢂ *#ꢁ SQUV"')#2-,#ꢁ
3.ꢀ ꢀ Resultsꢀandꢀdiscussionꢀ
!ꢂ.ꢂ *#ꢁ-$ꢁ$-0+',%ꢁꢂꢁ!7!*'!ꢁ&7"0-%#,V -,"#"ꢁ1203!230#Qꢁ"'"ꢁ,-2ꢁ
0#ꢂ!2ꢁꢂ2ꢁꢂ**ꢁ3,"#0ꢁ2&#ꢁ-.2'+'8#"ꢁ!-,"'2'-,1ꢁꢂ,"ꢁ5ꢂ1ꢁ0#!-4#0#"ꢁ
H'2&ꢁ0#%ꢂ0"ꢁ2-ꢁꢂ""0#11',%ꢁ1-+#ꢁ-$ꢁ2&#ꢁ.0- *#+1ꢁꢂ11-!'ꢂ2#"ꢁ
/3ꢂ,2'2ꢂ2'4#*7ꢁꢂ$2#0ꢁTVꢁ&ꢁꢃ&ꢂ *#ꢁSQꢁ#,207ꢁTXꢄTꢁ
5'2&ꢁ!&#+'!ꢂ*ꢁ.-**32'-,Qꢁ'ꢆ1ꢁ&ꢂ4#ꢁ ##,ꢁ2&#ꢁ13 (#!2ꢁ-$ꢁ',!0#ꢂ1',%ꢁ
*-**-5',%ꢁ 2&#ꢁ 13!!#11$3*ꢁ !-,4#01'-,ꢁ -$ꢁ ꢂ*!-&-*1ꢁ ',2-ꢁ 2&#ꢁ
*#4#*1ꢁ-$ꢁꢂ22#,2'-,ꢁꢂ1ꢁ#,4'0-,+#,2ꢂ**7ꢁ$0'#,"*7ꢁ0#ꢂ!2'-,ꢁ+#"'ꢂꢁ
!-00#1.-,"',%ꢁꢂ*)7*ꢁꢂ!#2ꢂ2#1Qꢁ5#ꢁꢂ*1-ꢁ',4#12'%ꢂ2#"ꢁ2&#ꢁꢂ..*'!ꢂV