DOI: 10.1002/chem.201602390
Communication
&
Catalysis
One-Step Production of 1,3-Butadiene from 2,3-Butanediol
Dehydration
Xi Liu,[a, c] Viktoria Fabos,[a] Stuart Taylor,[a] David W. Knight,[a] Keith Whiston,[b] and
Graham J. Hutchings*[a]
Recent work has revealed the potential of 2,3-butandiol
Abstract: We report the direct production of 1,3-buta-
diene from the dehydration of 2,3-butandiol by using alu-
mina as catalyst. Under optimized kinetic reaction condi-
tions, the production of methyl ethyl ketone and isobutyr-
aldehyde, formed via the pinacol–pinacolone rearrange-
ment, was markedly reduced and almost 80% selectivity
to 1,3-butadiene and 1,3-butadiene could be achieved.
The presence of water plays a critical role in the inhibition
of oligomerization. The amphoteric nature of g-Al2O3 was
identified as important and this contributed to the im-
proved catalytic selectivity when compared with other
acidic catalysts.
(BDO) as a promising C4 platform chemical for use in a variety
of industrial applications.[4,5] BDO had been used as the precur-
sor to produce deacetyl, butenes, or 1,3 butadiene before the
availability of processes based on the ready availability of inex-
pensive fossil hydrocarbons were introduced in the 1950s. At
present, BDO has only limited industrial applications as a food
flavor additive.[6] However, the development of the biomass in-
dustry and the abundance of BDO as a by-product have reig-
nited interest in the catalytic conversion of BDO, in particular
its dehydration to 1,3-butadiene (BDE). At present, attempts to
directly produce BDE with a high yield have failed and the re-
action to methyl ethyl ketone, the thermodynamically pre-
ferred product, always predominates.[7–9] The mechanism is
well understood since the consecutive dehydration of the adja-
cent two hydroxyl groups leads to an enol which readily forms
methyl ethyl ketone (MEK). To achieve high yields of the re-
quired product, a two-step process has been designed to con-
vert the diol into the diene by using an acid as an esterifying
agent, or catalytic reductive deoxygenation in the presence of
H2 has been used.[10–12] Both processes are not environmentally
benign and make industrial production less attractive due to
usage of either a stoichiometric acid or a reductant. In addi-
tion, biomass-derived polyols are formed at low concentrations
in aqueous solution. Refining these crude aqueous solutions,
using distillation or membrane separation, is an endothermic
reaction requiring a high-energy input, which also hinders the
overall potential catalytic conversion process.[13,14]
The use of renewable biomass as a resource for chemical and
fuel production has been gaining increasing attention during
the last two decades. This is in response to the present global
challenge related to the use of fossil fuels and the environmen-
tal problems to which their use may contribute. However, in-
stalled production capacity based on renewable resources has
not reached the levels anticipated for economic reasons and it
has increased at a slower rate than originally forecast.[1] One of
the key problems is the production of vast amounts of lower
value by-products which have limited applications, for in-
stance, glycerol generated from biodiesel production and buta-
nediols generated from biomass fermentation or wood hydrol-
ysis. These by-products potentially make the overall process
less efficient and non-profitable.[2] Therefore, the development
of value-added uses for the crude biomass-derived by-products
or the so-called ‘biomass waste’ will contribute to the viability
of the nascent biomass industry.[3] Besides the reduction of
waste with a reduced impact on the environment, the recovery
of energy and useful feedstocks could make these processes
economically practical and competitive against present indus-
trial processes based on readily available fossil fuels.
Here we report a facile method to produce BDE with almost
100% selectivity via the direct dehydration of aqueous BDO
using a commercial alumina catalyst. High selectivity to buta-
diene is achieved by using high flow rates and a smaller
amount of catalysts. Our work suggests that under these opti-
mized kinetic reaction conditions the consecutive dehydroxyla-
tion via 1,2-elimination to BDE by an E2 mechanism is favored.
The activities for the dehydration of BDO (10 wt%) using
a range of catalysts were investigated (Table 1). In most cases,
by using a relatively large amount of catalyst (0.5 g), the major
product was always MEK, which was produced via partial dehy-
dration followed by the pinacol–pinacolone rearrangement
(Equations 1–5).[15] The major by-product was isobutyraldehyde
(IBA), which also generated via the pinacol–pinacolone rear-
rangement (Equations 1, 2, 6–8). BDE was only observed as
a minor product for almost all catalysts, except g-Al2O3, where
BDE selectivity was 21% at 3508C (Table 1, entry 13). This was
almost double the selectivity observed using bentonite and
[a] Dr. X. Liu, Dr. V. Fabos, S. Taylor, Prof. D. W. Knight, Prof. G. J. Hutchings
Cardiff Catalysis Institute, School of Chemistry
Cardiff University, Cardiff CF10 3AT (UK)
[b] Dr. K. Whiston
INVISTA Textiles (UK) Limited, P.O. Box 2002,
Wilton Redcar TS10 4XX (UK)
[c] Dr. X. Liu
Syncat@Beijing, Synfuels China Technology Co.,Ltd,
Beijing 101407 (China)
Chem. Eur. J. 2016, 22, 1 – 6
1
ꢀ 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
&
&
These are not the final page numbers! ÞÞ