Angewandte
Communications
Chemie
illumination, the J–V curve of 2.8 mm Si NWs exhibited an
onset potential (defined as the potential to reach 1 mAcmꢀ2
reductive transformation at substantially more positive
potentials (ca. 700 mV based on Vj=10), thereby reducing the
)
of 0.18 V versus RHE, beyond which the cathodic photo-
current density quickly took off and reached a saturation
value of approximately 37 mAcmꢀ2 at about ꢀ0.6 V. The
observed cathodic photocurrent density quantitatively corre-
sponds to the reduction of maleic acid to succinic acid (see
proceeding text). The large saturation photocurrent density of
the Si NW electrode agreed well with the ideal value for Si
photoelectrodes, suggesting that there was no optical loss and
required external bias.
Subsequently, we analyzed the potential-dependent
reduction product and its Faradaic efficiency on the Si NW
photoelectrode. To do so, bulk photoelectrolysis was per-
formed at a few selected potentials between ꢀ0.9 and 0.1 V.
All the recorded chronopotentiometric curves (j ~ t) remained
highly stable for at least 1 h (Figure 2d). At the conclusion of
each photoelectrolysis experiment, the liquid product in the
catholyte (ca. 125 mL) was collected and characterized by
nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). Succinic acid was
determined to be the only liquid product (Supporting
Information, Figure S4). Based on its concentration in the
catholyte, we calculated the Faradaic efficiency for succinic
acid (Figure 2e). Faradaic efficiency was close to 100% within
the entire potential range, suggesting that HER was largely
overwhelmed by maleic acid reduction on the Si NW photo-
cathode. In stark contrast, electrochemical reduction of
maleic acid on both Ti/TiO2 and lead was accompanied by
significant cogeneration of H2. The Faradaic efficiency for
succinic acid on Ti/TiO2 was around 90% between ꢀ0.9 and
ꢀ0.4 V, and within the range of 70–90% on lead, which is
consistent with previous studies.[12,22] The very high Faradaic
efficiency for the quantitative transformation of maleic acid
to succinic acid on the Si NW photocathode therefore
presents another advantage over conventional electrosyn-
thesis.
Furthermore, we assessed the operation durability of the
Si NW photocathode. Its photocurrent density at 0 V was
monitored continuously for about 17 h, and there was no sign
of activity loss (Figure 2 f inset). The slight initial photo-
current decline was probably caused by the decreasing local
concentration of maleic acid, and a gradual rise in photo-
current thereafter was probably due to increasing wetting of
the Si NW photocathode. Postmortem SEM and TEM
examinations showed that there was no obvious change in
the electrode morphology after prolonged photoelectrolysis
(Supporting Information, Figure S5). Additionally, we
extracted the catholyte every 30 min for the first 6 h during
photoelectrolysis and analyzed the concentration of succinic
acid. The measured concentrations were in perfect accord-
ance with what was predicted by assuming all the cathodic
photocurrent resulted from the two-electron reduction of
that all the photogenerated electrons were fully utilized.[21]
A
control experiment with a planar Si electrode revealed a more
negative onset potential (0.06 V) and a smaller saturation
photocurrent density (ca. 34 mAcmꢀ2). We also compared the
PEC maleic acid reduction performance of Si NW electrodes
with different NW lengths (Supporting Information, Fig-
ure S2). Moreover, electrochemical reaction of maleic acid on
degenerately doped planar Si wafer (p++-Si, not p++-Si NWs
because their NWs could not be prepared by the same metal-
assisted chemical etching process) showed that the reaction
did not initiate until a very negative potential of ꢀ0.60 V was
reached on the Si surface. To a certain degree, the approx-
imately 770 mV difference in the onset potential between Si
NWs and p++-Si reflected the considerable photovoltage
generated from the Si NW/electrolyte junction under 1 sun
illumination.
To shed light on and contrast the different interfacial
charge transfer rates between maleic acid reduction and
HER, PEC experiments in the absence of maleic acid were
also carried out. The electrolyte was 0.3m Na2SO4 with its pH
adjusted to 2.0 with H2SO4. Under these circumstances, only
HER could possibly occur in the cathodic potential regime.
Mott–Schottky analysis indicated a similar flat band (ca.
0.17 V; Supporting Information, Figure S3). However, the
onset potential of the Si NW electrode was displaced to
ꢀ0.07 V, and its saturation photocurrent density was not
reached until about ꢀ1.2 V (Figure 2b). In the presence or
absence of maleic acid, the required potential to sustain
a photocurrent density of 10 mAcmꢀ2 (Vj=10) differed by
approximately 460 mV. Such a drastic difference emphasizes
the much facilitated reduction rate of maleic acid over the
competing HER process. As a result, we can reasonably
deduce that HER was fully suppressed in the presence of
maleic acid (see proceeding discussion).
&
To highlight the advantage of PEC photosynthesis relative
to conventional electrosynthesis, we subsequently investi-
gated the electrochemical reduction of maleic acid on heat-
treated titanium (Ti/TiO2)[22] and lead—two common elec-
trode materials used widely in previous studies with reported
Faradaic efficiencies typically in the range of 70–90%.[12,20] As
depicted in Figure 2c, the polarization curves on Ti/TiO2 and
lead exhibited more negative onset potentials of ꢀ0.21 V and
ꢀ0.30 V, respectively; and their potentials required to reach
a cathodic current density of 10 mAcmꢀ2 were ꢀ0.68 V and
ꢀ0.48 V, respectively. The Si NW photocathode displayed
markedly improved performance in solar-assisted maleic acid
reduction relative to Ti/TiO2 and lead. By capitalizing on the
large photovoltage generated at the semiconductor/electro-
lyte junction, the Si NW photocathode was able to drive this
maleic acid (Figure 2 f, ). These results suggest that the
Faradaic efficiency for succinic acid is retained at about 100%
during prolonged photoelectrolysis.
The aforementioned results corroborate that the conver-
sion of maleic acid to succinic acid was efficiently achieved on
Si NW photocathode under light illumination. Furthermore,
we demonstrated that the idea of PEC reductive transforma-
tion was not specific to succinic acid, but also applicable to
other industrial building-block chemicals. In the proceeding
text, we describe a second example in which glyoxylic acid
was photoelectrosynthesized on a Si NW electrode.
The electrochemical reduction of oxalic acid is a well-
established approach to synthesize glyoxylic acid in indus-
try.[13,23] The process has a standard reduction potential of
ꢀ0.08 V, which is very close to that of HER. As a result,
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2017, 56, 1 – 6
ꢀ 2017 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
3
These are not the final page numbers!