L.E. Rusali, M.P. Schramm / Tetrahedron Letters 61 (2020) 152333
3
Table 1
Cycloisomerization of 12 under a variety of conditions.
Entry
1
Conditionsa
Time
Conversionb
1, 24 °C
1 h
0%
1, 70 °C
1 h
0%
1, 70 °C
16 h
1 h
16 h
1 h
1 h
16 h
1 h
0%
0%
0%
0%
48%
99%
0%
2
3
AgOTf, 70 °C
AgOTf, 70 °C
1, + AgOTf, 24 °C
1, + AgOTf, 70 °C
1, + AgOTf, 70 °C
2, 70 °C
happened.
Scheme 8. Catalytic screening of substrates 18–20, resulting in 26.
4
5
2, 70 °C
16 h
1 h
1 h
16 h
16 h
16 h
0%
0%
7%
99%
11%
8%c
Table 2
Cycloisomerization of 18–20: variation of R under a variety of conditions.
2 + AgOTf, 24 °C
2 + AgOTf, 70 °C
2 + AgOTf, 70 °C
AuCl, 70 °C
Entry
1
Substrate
Conditionsa
Time
Conversionb
6
7
18
1, + AgOTf, 70 °C
1, + AgOTf, 70 °C
2 + AgOTf, 70 °C
2 + AgOTf, 70 °C
1, + AgOTf, 70 °C
1, + AgOTf, 70 °C
2 + AgOTf, 70 °C
2 + AgOTf, 70 °C
1, + AgOTf, 70 °C
1 h
15%
99%
7%
AuCl, + AgOTf, 70 °C
16 h
1 h
16 h
1 h
16 h
1 h
16 h
16 h
a
[12] = 0.04 mM, [Au] = 0.002 mM (5 mol%), [additive] = 0.004 mM (10 mol%),
reaction volume 0.60 mL.
As determined by NMR integration, all species were cleanly resolved and except
for entry 7, the only observable compounds were starting 12 or product 24.
2
3
4
5
18
19
19
20
99%
0%
50%
0%
37%
0%
b
c
6% of fluorene 5 was detected.
by NMR. The same unresponsiveness resulted with AgOTf alone
(Entry 2). The combination of the two gave appreciable turnover
after 1 h with heating (48% conversion, entry 3). After 16 h, clean,
quantitative conversion was achieved. Using a non-cavitand AuCl
surrogate, namely (di-t-butylphenylO)3PAuCl 2, which is nearly
isoelectronic at P and thus at Au compared to 1, we see similar
results; no conversion on its own (Entry 4) and complete conver-
sion after 16 h heating in the presence of AgOTf (Entry 5). Interest-
ingly, AuCl was mildly reactive without an additive (Entry 6) and
with AgOTf, produced trace amounts of 5 (Entry 7). We assume
for now that Au/Ag synergistic/dependent effects are not at work
[36,37], and that Ag is simply playing the role of Au activation
through ligand replacement. We will explore this matter in a
future report, and for the time being, the effect of substrate shape
with cavitand will be our point of focus.
Knowing that 12 is compatible with 1 and that this reaction is
comparable with chloro[tris(2,4-di-tert-butylphenyl)phosphite] 2,
we continued our inquiry looking for differences in reactivity.
We continued with chloro (15), bromo (16) and iodo (17) termi-
nated alkynes that gave 25 (Scheme 7). The cycloisomerization of
16 and 17 involving 1,2-migration of the halogen has been
reported using AuCl [24]. Chloro alkyne (15) was resistant to
cyclization in our hands with AuCl, AgOTf, or a combination, but
cyclized readily when treated with 1 and AgOTf, giving 74% conver-
sion after 16 h at 70 °C. Bromo alkyne (16), was completely con-
verted to product 25 after 16 h, again with 1 + AgOTf, and iodo
alkyne (17) was completely converted after only 1 h.
a
[Substrate] = 0.04 mM, [Au] = 0.002 mM (0.05 mol%) [additive] = 0.004 mM
(0.1 mol%), reaction volume 0.60 mL.
b
As determined by NMR integration, all species were cleanly resolved, the only
observable compounds were starting [Substrate] or product 26.
with 1 vs. 2, resulting in 50% and 37% conversion, respectively.
The ester-functionalized alkyne 20 was unreactive, whereas it
was previously cyclized with PtCl2 to give fluorene 5 as the major
product [24]. This sequence of experiments aimed to probe the
effect of short vs. long alkyl groups on the alkyne in the reaction
with 1; the hope was to find a permutation of cavitand volume
and guest size that would alter reactivity. This was not found in
experiments where the alkyne was modified, but when the aro-
matic scaffold was changed, something different happened.
We prepared modified scaffold 21 where the xylyl group of 12
was replaced with tolyl (Scheme 9). Resorcinarene cavitands admit
phenyl, benzyl, tolyl, and cyclohexyl sized groups with ease, but
larger o-, m- xylyl or mesityl (1,3,5-trisubstituted) become too
wide to access the interior. Alkynes 22 and 23 are further
variations.
Immediately,
a reactivity difference was noted between
dimethyl substituted 12 and tolyl 21. Cavitand 1 was ineffective
at producing measurable amounts of 29 (Table 3, Entry 1), even
after multiple replicates. Using AuCl 2, 29 was produced with
We then explored substrates 18–20 (Scheme 8, Table 2) with
terminal methyl, propyl, and ester groups. Methyl-terminated
alkyne 18 readily converted to cycloadduct 26 under Au catalysis
in the presence of AgOTf, with either 1 (Entry 1) or gold 2 (Entry
2), with complete conversion achieved after 16 h. The elongated
propyl-terminated alkyne 19, had marginally higher reactivity
Scheme 7. Catalytic screening of substrates 15–17. 1,2-Migration of
observed in the product 25 (as previously reported).
X
was
Scheme 9. Catalytic screening of substrates 21–23: variation in the aromatic
scaffold.