ACS Medicinal Chemistry Letters
Page 4 of 9
µM. Therefore, we continued our structure-activity studies and
prepared several zone 2 and zone 3 modifications of RL-81.
and the ortho-aniline nitrogen. We briefly also explored the pos-
sibility that a hindered rotation at the zone 1 benzylamine moi-
ety could be responsible for the lack of activity of the o,o’-di-
substituted aniline RL-50. However, a potential energy analysis
(HF-6-31G*) suggested a barrier of only 1.5-2.5 kcal/mol for
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
3
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
6
4
5
Moving the fluorine atom from R to R in RL-72 had a det-
rimental effect on the EC2x for K 7.2/K 7.3, reducing it 5-fold
vs RL-81 to 1.26 µM. However, the selectivity was now superb,
with EC2x’s of >10, 4.65, and >10 µM for K 7.3/K 7.5, K 7.4,
and K 7.4/7.5, respectively, accounting for an SI>7. In contrast,
installing a CF
v
v
2
the C-NH-CH -C dihedral angle for both RL-50 and the o-
v
v
v
monosubstituted reference compound RL-46, and geometri-
v
21
5
cally similar energy minima. Accordingly, we hypothesize
that K 7.2-5 channel potency is largely due to the electro-
3
-group at the R position in RL-073 completely
abrogated activity at all channel types. This position appears to
be very sensitive to steric bulk.
Surprisingly, changing the ethyl carbamate in zone 3 to an
iso-propyl carbamate slightly increased the potency of the re-
v
static/H-bonding interactions at the carbamate oxygen and the
ortho-aniline, with decreased electron density being detri-
mental. In contrast, steric and conformational effects at the car-
bamate and the benzylamine moieties appear to influence chan-
nel selectivity. This rationalization is also supported by litera-
ture evidence. Based on mutation and modeling studies, the
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
v v
sulting RL-32 at K 7.2/K 7.3, but vastly decreased the
K
v
7.4/7.5 EC2x to 4.98 µM, leading to an SI=31 – 100x better
than the SI=0.3 of RL-81. The SI=2.5 of the corresponding cy-
clo-propyl carbamate analog, RL-56, fits this trend, since the
steric dimensions of a cyclo-propane are roughly in between
those of the iso-propane and the ethane groups. RL-56 proved
tryptophan residue W236 in K
tively, W265, W242, W235 in K
v
7.2 (or, analogously and respec-
7.3, K 7.4, K 7.5) is thought
v
v
v
to be critical for binding, and participates in hydrogen bonding
interactions with carbamate or amide groups of small molecule
to be the most active analog on K
with an EC2x of 0.11±0.02 µM. However, both RL-32 and RL-
6 also still showed <0.4 µM EC2x potencies at K 7.3/K 7.5 and
7.4 channels.
For the next SAR iteration, we introduced a 2-fluoro-4-tri-
v v
7.2/K 7.3 prepared to date,
2
3,24
agonists.
v
In contrast, K 7.1, which lacks a corresponding W
residue, is not activated by retigabine-type molecules.
5
v
v
K
v
fluoromethylbenzylamine moiety in zone 1, and systematically
varied fluorinations in zone 2. The parent compound in this se-
ries, RL-18, was both potent, EC2x=0.18±0.11 µM, and moder-
ately selective, SI=1.7 (Table 1). Changing the ethyl to the cy-
clo-propyl carbamate decreased potency and SI (i.e. RL-35),
5
6
but, as previously found, adding fluorine at R or R , recovered
a high selectivity, generating an SI>10 and >7, respectively, for
NHCO
2
Et
RL-81
EC2x 0.26 µM
RL-36 and RL-46. In agreement with the data found for RL-
N
H
NH
2
5
F
7
2, the R -fluorinated RL-36 also lacked agonist activity at
3
F C
K
v
7.3/K
v
7.5, K
v
7.4, and K
v
7.4/7.5, and, due to its remaining
7.2/K 7.3, RL-36 therefore
sub-micromolar EC2x=0.93 at K
v
v
represents an overall significant improvement over RL-81. In
contrast, the hepta-fluorinated RL-50 lost all activity at these
channels.
In a final round of SAR investigations, we replaced the tri-
fluorobenzene in zone 1 with trifluoromethylated pyridines. In-
F
F
NHCO
2
c-Pr
RL-50
EC2x >10 µM
itially, we focused on the 2-pyridyl analogs RL-31, RL-68, RL-
N
H
NH
2
3
9
6, RL-01, RL-12 and RL-23. With the exception of the R -
F
F
3
C
F
fluorinated RL-96 and RL-12, these analogs demonstrated ei-
3
4
6
ther low selectivity or low potency. The R ,R ,R -trifluorinated
RL-12, in particular, maintained a respectable 1.00 µM EC2x at
K 7.2/K 7.3, with an SI>10 and no detectable agonist activity
v v
at other channels. Compared to their 2-pyridyl isomers RL-31
and RL-68, the 3-pyridyl analogs RL-24 and RL-67 showed
slightly increased selectivity, but essentially equivalent potency,
demonstrating that among the studied chemotypes, the fluorina-
tion pattern was the most significant determinant of selectivity
and activity.
F
NHCO
2
c-Pr
RL-46
EC2x 1.47 µM
N
H
NH
2
F
F
3
C
F
Since substitution with fluorine has profound effects on the
electron distribution in conjugated p-systems, we examined the
electrostatically encoded electron-density surfaces of RL-81 vs
RL-50, which has additional fluorinations at the benzylamine
Figure 3. Maps of electron-density surface encoded with elec-
trostatic potential for RL-81 (top) and RL-50 (middle), and
RL-46 (bottom). Colors reflects a property range of +170
2
5
5
6
kJ/mol (blue) to -310 kJ/mol (red).
moiety and, especially, at R and R of the triaminobenzene,
rendering it inactive at all K 7 channel types (Figure 3). Most
v
significantly, the electron density at the carbamate oxygen and
the ortho-aniline nitrogen is significantly decreased as a result
of the two additional fluorinations at the triaminobenzene moi-
ety in RL-50. In comparison, RL-46, which only has one addi-
An alternative, but possibly complementary, interpretation of
the differential selectivities observed for fluorinated and heter-
ocyclic analogs of retigabine and RL-81 could be their prefer-
ence for different binding sites on the channels, and hence dif-
ferent mechanisms of action. While retigabine binds to the pore
6
tional fluorine atom at R vs RL-81 and is still quite active,
shows an intermediate electron density at the carbamate oxygen
v v
domain on K 7.2-K 7.5, other compounds have been suggested
ACS Paragon Plus Environment