J. Nguyen et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 26 (2016) 4753–4756
4755
activation of autophagy, the microtubule-associated form of LC3,
LC3-I, is converted to the autophagy-associated form, LC3-II.1 After
24 h of treatment with DMSO or DK-1-49, changes in LC3 levels
were evaluated (Fig. 1E). DK-1-49-treated cells exhibited an accu-
mulation of LC3-II while DMSO-treated cells exhibited no signifi-
cant conversion of LC3-I to LC3-II. Note that the increase of MDC
fluorescence and LC3-II accumulation of cancer cells by DK-1-49
was consistent with the previous Letter.24
cells. As mentioned previously, DK-1-71 stimulates weaker autop-
hagy compared to DK-1-49 in HeLa cells. Similar results were
observed in both wild-type and DKO MEFs. Minimal MDC and
Cyto-ID fluorescence were seen (Fig. 3A) and low conversion of
LC3-I to LC3-II was detected (Fig. 3B). Additionally, cytotoxic
effects of DK-1-71 were weaker than those of DK-1-49 by approx-
imately 10-fold in both wild-type cells and apoptosis-defective
cells. The EC50 was determined to be 28.6 lM and 24.2 lM respec-
The autophagonizer was originally reported to induce autopha-
gic cell death. To validate that our autophagonizer exerts similar
cytotoxic effects, 3-(4,5-dimethylthiazol-2-yl)-2-5-diphenyltetra-
zolium bromide (MTT) assay was employed. MTT results showed
that cell death occurred in cells after 24 h treatment with DK-1-
49 (Fig. 1F). The percentage of viable cells dramatically declined
tively (Fig. 3C). These results on apoptosis-defective MEFs further
accentuate that the modification of the pyrrolidine nitrogen to a
carbon markedly reduced autophagic cell death, suggesting that
this nitrogen may be vital for autophagonizer activity. According
to a previous study, autophagonizer promotes cell death in cancer
cells even under the presence of Z-VAD-FMK, a pan-caspase
inhibitor.24 This finding implicates that the extrinsic pathway of
apoptosis is not involved in the mechanism towards autophago-
nizer-induced cell death. Based on our results regarding Bax/Bak
DKO cells, the intrinsic pathway of apoptosis is also not involved
because cell death still occurred after treatment with the
autophagonizer.
by 5-fold after compound treatment at a dosage of 8
l
M. From
the dose–response curve, EC50 was estimated to be 3.5
lM, which
is similar to the previously reported value.24 Taken together from
these results of autophagic activity and cell viability, the DK-1-49
synthesized using the scheme described above was validated to
induce autophagic cell death in cancer cell line.
Autophagonizer was previously reported to undergo a mecha-
nism that is unique from the traditional pathways towards the
onset of autophagy. In order to gain additional insight, we are cur-
rently performing structure–activity relationship (SAR) analysis.
Derivatives of autophagonizer were generated, each bearing a
modification in various regions of the structure. Additional
detailed studies on SAR are necessary and will be reported in due
course. However, we have identified a less-active derivative of
the autophagonizer, DK-1-71 (Fig. 2A). The nitrogen of pyrrolidine
moiety of DK-1-49 was replaced with a carbon in DK-1-71. This
modification resulted in a marked reduction in autophagic cell
death activity in HeLa cells. No sufficient increase in MDC fluores-
cence was observed in cells treated with DK-1-71 compared to
cells treated with DK-1-49 (Fig. 2B), suggesting that DK-1-71
induces weaker autophagy. This was also reflected by DK-1-71’s
autophagic cell death activity as the EC50 of the compound was cal-
In summary, in order to gain a further understanding of
autophagonizer-induced autophagic cell death, we have success-
fully developed the first synthetic procedure of the autophago-
nizer. The synthesized autophagonizer (DK-1-49) was validated
to induce autophagic cell death in cancer cells as similarly
described in the previous study. We have also shown that DK-1-
49 can induce cell death in Bax/Bak DKO MEFs in which the intrin-
sic apoptosis was disabled. This result, combined with the result in
A
B
culated to be approximately 25
lM, about 7-folds higher than DK-
1-49’s EC50 of 3.5 M (Fig. 2C). Because DK-1-71 proves to be less
l
DMSO
DMSO
1.0 µM
3.0 µM
6.0 µM
active in inducing autophagic cell death than DK-1-49 after the
replacement of the nitrogen of pyrrolidine moiety, DK-1-71 was
assessed alongside DK-1-49 in the following studies.
An obstacle to chemotherapy is some cancer cells’ resistance
against apoptosis, rendering them unresponsive to anti-cancer
drugs that target the apoptosis pathway. In order to determine
whether DK-1-49 holds suppressive effects against apoptosis-
defective cells through autophagic cell death, Bax/Bak double-
knockout (DKO) mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) were used.27
Bax and Bak are pro-apoptotic Bcl-2 family members that perme-
abilize mitochondria to induce apoptosis.28 Therefore, Bax/Bak
DKO MEFs are defective in activating mitochondrial intrinsic apop-
tosis. We have expected that, if DK-1-49 induces cell death through
the intrinsic apoptosis pathway, DK-1-49 may induce less cell
death in Bax/Bak DKO MEFs compared to wild type MEFs. After
15 h of treatment, wild-type and DKO MEFs were stained with
MDC and Cyto-ID reagent (Fig. 3A). Upon treatment with DK-1-
49, an accumulation of acidic vacuoles and autophagosomes was
observed in both wild-type and DKO MEFs. Furthermore, LC3-I to
LC3-II conversion was detected by Western blot, confirming that
autophagy was induced in DK-1-49-treated cells (Fig. 3B). The
wild-type and DKO MEFs were subsequently assessed with MTT
assay for effects on cell viability (Fig. 3C). DK-1-49 was shown to
have potent cytotoxicity in both wild-type and DKO MEFs. The
apparent EC50 calculated from the dose-response curve for the
25.0 µM
C
EC50 = ~ 25 µM
Figure 2. Identification of the less active form of autophagonizer, DK-1-71.
(A) Structure of DK-1-71. The arrow indicates the site of modification of DK-1-49
in DK-1-71. (B) After 24 h treatment, cells were stained with MDC for acidic
vacuoles. Images were taken under the DAPI filter. (C) Cytotoxicity of DK-1-71 in
HeLa cells was measured by MTT assay. Viable DK-1-71-treated cells were
normalized against DMSO-treated cells to obtain the percentage of viable cells.
wild-type and DKO MEFs were essentially identical, 2.1
2.2 respectively. These results further suggest DK-1-49’s
potentiality as an anti-cancer drug against apoptosis-defective
lM and
lM