W. Zhang et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 24 (2014) 2188–2192
2191
S
O
SMe
N
O
a
b
N
H
Et
Et
N
N
H
O
N
O
Cl
N
Cl
O
N
Cl
N
N
28
30
29
O
O
=
Y
NH NH
NH
MeN NH
MeN
X
N
O
c
Y
X
N
S
N
N
O
Cl
Cl
N
N
O
31
32
Scheme 5. Reagents and conditions: (a) SCNCO2Et, chloroform, 23 °C, 97%; (b) NaH, MeI, THF, 23 °C, 92%; (c) hydroxylamines or hydrazines, 2-propanol, 82 °C, 33–35%.
outlined in Scheme 5. Reaction of secondary amine 28 with eth-
oxycarbonyl isothiocyanate provided intermediate thiourea 29 in
quantitative yield. Alkylation of 29 with iodomethane in the pres-
ence of sodium hydride generated methylthiocarbamate 30 in
excellent yield. This carbamate is a suitable substrate for the de-
sired tandem double displacement and ring formation reactions.
Therefore, treatment of carbamate 30 with hydrazine or hydroxyl-
amine provided the expected cyclization product triazolinones or
oxadiazolinones 31 in moderate yields.12 The corresponding tied-
back analogs, such as oxadiazolinones 32, can be prepared in a sim-
ilar way when the hydroxylamine group is tethered to the amine
moiety in advance.
Insecticidal activity of amino-2(5H)-oxazolones and other het-
erocyclic analogs is summarized in Tables 1–3. Test compounds
were formulated using a solution containing 10% acetone, 90%
water and 300 ppm of a non-ionic surfactant. The formulated com-
pounds were sprayed on the foliage of plants at 2–5 rates and rep-
licated three times. Efficacy was evaluated on the following test
units: 12–15 day-old radish plant for green peach aphid (Myzus
persicae (Sulzer) GPA), 6–7 day-old cotton plant for cotton melon
aphid (Aphis gossypii (Glover), CMA), 3–4 day-old corn for corn
planthopper (Peregrinus maidis (Ashmead) CPH), 5–6 day-old bean
for potato leafhopper (Empoasca fabae (Harris) PLH), and 12–
14 day-old cotton for sweetpotato whitefly (Bemisia tabaci (Genna-
dius) WF). Mortality was evaluated 6 days after application for all
insects except for WF, which was evaluated 12 days after applica-
tion. Insecticidal activity is reported as an LC50 (the lethal concen-
tration required for 50% mortality) in ppm. In general, all
compounds showed better control against aphid species and hop-
per species than whitefly.
Table 1 shows compounds initially prepared in comparison to
Nippon Soda’s enaminolactone compounds 8 and 33. Both 8 and
33 are potent insecticides against all four hemipteran insect spe-
cies tested (GPA, CMA, CPH, and PLH). Novel 2-aminopyrrolin-5-
ones 13a and 13b displayed only weak levels of activity.
4-Amino-2(5H)-oxazolones 18a and 18b, on the other hand,
showed potent insecticidal activity against all four hemipteran in-
sect species tested (GPA, CMA, CPH, and PLH). This result illustrates
that it is critical to maintain the ring oxygen atom so as to form an
ester moiety, which may mimic the nitro group in imidacloprid (1).
Although N-cyclopropyl enaminolactone 8 demonstrated overall
higher levels of insecticidal activity than the corresponding N-
methyl enaminolactone 33 when tested against CMA, CPH, PLH,
and WF, this trend is not as clear for the 4-amino-2(5H)-oxazol-
ones 18a and 18b.
bromo-3-pyridylmethyl compound 39, which provided insecticidal
activity close to the corresponding 6-chloro analog (18a).
Compounds containing N-2-chloro-5-thiazolylmethyl groups
(40) showed anticipated insecticidal activity similar to that of the
N-6-chloro-3-pyridylmethyl analog (18a). Compounds containing
other heterocycles, 2-pyridazinyl 41, 4-pyrazolyl 42, and pyrimid-
inyl 43 showed a significant reduction in activity.
The R2 group attached to the amino nitrogen also played an
important role on the insecticidal activity. Compounds containing
a small alkyl group, methyl 18b, ethyl 44, cyclopropyl 18a, showed
highest activity. The 2,2-difluoroethyl compound 49, showed less
activity on GPA and PLH, while compounds containing larger alkyl
groups, n-propyl 45, cyclopropylmethyl 46, as well as cyclobutyl
47, showed a drastic loss of activity. However, the size of the sub-
stituent is not the only factor responsible for the insecticidal po-
tency because the N-methoxy compound 48, displayed only
marginal activity on CMA with no activity on other species tested.
Finally, we explored a series of analogs which maintained the
carbonyl amidine feature, while containing various heteroatoms
or moieties to make up the five-membered heterocycle rings (Ta-
ble 3). Most variations resulted in loss of activity, while com-
pounds 52, 53, and 57 containing the lactone (or thio-lactone)
function showed reasonably good activity on GPA and CMA.
The most potent analogs approached or were comparable to the
activity of imidacloprid (Table 1). For GPA and CPH, 18a was ꢀ18-
fold and 3-fold less potent than imidacloprid, respectively. For
CMA, 18b was 1.6-fold more potent than imidacloprid. Precise
LC50 values were not obtained for 18b and 40 on PLH, however
both were <2 ppm whereas imidacloprid was determined to be
0.8 ppm. For WF, 49 was ꢀ2.5-fold less potent than imidacloprid.
The assays described in this study were all based on contact
sprays. The neonicotinoid class of chemistry is also known for pos-
sessing physical properties that allow uptake into plants via sys-
temic delivery, either through soil treatment or seed treatment.13
As such, a preliminary study using a soil application of either 18a
or 18b resulted in activity against GPA that was comparable to
the foliar application of these compounds.
Table 4
Comparative potency of nAChR agents at displacing 3H-imidacloprid in GPA
membrane preparations
Compounds
IC50 (nM)
95% Confidence interval
Lower
Upper
18a
40
Imidacloprid
Thiacloprid
Dinotefuran
Sulfoxaflora
310
1115
3
244
811
2
392
1532
4
Based on the activity of amino-2(5H)-oxazolones 18a and 18b, a
series of analogs A containing different substitutions on the amino
group was investigated (Table 2). Compounds 34 through 39 are
analogs containing a N-3-pyridylmethyl group, unsubstituted, or
substituted by one or two halogen atoms at different ring posi-
tions. All these analogs showed a reduction in activity, except 6-
3
2
4
13,300
473
11,655
374
15,162
598
a
For the structure of sulfoxaflor, see Ref. 2c.