206
A.M. Abu-Dief et al. / Polyhedron 64 (2013) 203–208
O atoms from each half side of the ligand. Then, the angle formed
by both planes was calculated. If the ligands will be disposed in a
single plane the final angle would it be 0° or nearby. The highest
the angle, the most distorted the ligand. This way, measuring the
peripheral ligands, Br5O4N2 and Br6O7N1 provided an angle of
38.24° being the most distorted; it was followed by the 34.03°
formed with the Br2O2N4 and Br1O1N3 planes. The central ligand
displayed an angle of 11.04°, corresponding to the less distorted
one, using the planes described by the following atoms: Br4O3N5
and Br3O6N6 (Fig. 2 right).
some transition metals proved [33–34], the reactivity of such or-
ganic unit with LnIII remained unexplored until now [35]. In this
paper, systems 1 was characterized in the solid state by Infrared,
elemental analysis and X-ray diffraction. The infrared spectrum
agrees with the pattern of other analogous systems. This way,
the m
(C@N) stretching moiety (1636 cmꢁ1 (1)) shifts to higher wave-
numbers compared with the free H2bsph (1612 cmꢁ1) [36]. Other
sharp bands were found around 1611, 1519 and 1164 cmꢁ1 which
intensities decreased progressively, assignable to the m(C@C)
stretching vibrations from the ligand upon coordination. Below
825 cmꢁ1 only weak bands were observed, none of them assign-
Comparison of the distances and angles of compound 1 with
previous systems in the literature provides primary information.
There are only three other structures of LnIII displaying ‘‘real’’ sand-
wich triple-decker dinuclear complexes, [Ln2(L2ꢁ)3(X)](where
L = Salen-type Schiff bases and X = solvent molecule) [25,29–30].
Two of them having NdIII [25,30] as it is the case of complex 1 with
different Salen-type Schiff base ligands (L) and also different mol-
ecules of solvents attached (X = MeOH). The third system differs on
the organic unit as well as on the metal center (YbIII) [29]. Taking
into account the work presented here (1) and the other two [Nd2(-
L2ꢁ)3(X)] species [25,30], a list of comparative values has been
made showing some of their similarities and differences. Table 3
shows some of the most remarkable parameters of the three sys-
tems. From the point of view of the crystal data and refinement
parameters, complex 1 displays the same number of molecules
per unit cell as the other two systems but its volume is higher
and has also a different space group. Complexes from Refs.
[25,30] contain two different dinuclear clusters in the unit cell
comparing with 1. Regarding distances and angles, Ndx–Oy–Ndz
angles are similar in the three systems, although complex 1 shows
the shortest Nd–Nd distance compared with Ref. [25] and an inter-
mediate value compared with Ref. [30]. Interestingly, 1 contains
the shortest intermolecular Ndꢀ ꢀ ꢀNd distance comparing with the
other two (Table 3).
able to m(M–O/N). The elemental analysis corroborated the 2 M:3L
coordination (where M and L stand for metal and ligand) and final-
ly the crystal structures provided precise description of the final
arrangement.
As it has been mentioned in the crystallographic section, three
other sandwich triple-decker dinuclear clusters have been previ-
ously described in the literature containing LnIII centers with sim-
ilar ligands to H2bsph. In addition, few triple-, tetra- and even
penta-decker systems have been also achieved [25–30]. It has been
pointed out that the formation of multidecker multimetallic lan-
thanide-Schiff base assemblies depends on different factors: (i)
the stochiometry, being normally used 1:1 or 1:2 (M:L), (ii) the ini-
tial LnIII-salts (where NO3ꢁ, Clꢁ, OAcꢁ, CF3CO3ꢁ, OTfꢁ have been
proposed in different works), (iii) the bases (sometimes absence
of it, Et3N or NaOH), (iv) additional metallic salts (e.g., Zn(OAc)2)
and (v) the solvents or mixtures of solvents used (MeOH,
MeOH:CH2Cl2, MeCN, MeCN:MeOH, MeCN:THF).
So far, our studies have shown that comparing with previous
works, deprotonation of the base with NaOH and the use of ace-
tone as solvent favors dinuclear entities with Nd. Further studies
with additional Ln-salts are in progress to analyze if this could
be extended to the rest of LnIII ions. As it has been said above,
we have made comparisons of the synthetic ways for achieving
the three existing [Nd2L3X] systems. Initial works, related to the
formation of polynuclear LnIII–Salen-type Schiff base ligands,
claimed that different nuclearity among final systems was depend-
ing on the nature of the anions used [26]. From the point of view of
the [Nd2L3X] species, it is clear that the dinuclear structures have
been made with different Ln salts: triflate [25], acetate [30] and ni-
trate (present work). The three [Nd2L3X] compared here have been
also made using different solvents (or mixture of solvents), stochi-
ometries and bases (none [30], Et3N [25] and NaOH (present
work)). Basically, the present work agrees with the idea that poly-
nuclear decker–LnIII systems depend on several aspects but we
would like to stress that there is not a unique and most relevant
factor among the others, and therefore, each LnIII should be studied
in different conditions to determine which of those affect the most
to the nuclearity and final composition of the structures.
3. Discussion
The present work describes the formation of a homodinuclear
complex, [Nd2(bsph)3(H2O] (1), by reacting Nd(NO3)3ꢀ6H2O with
bsph2ꢁ in a ratio 1:2, using acetone as a solvent. Although the free
ligand, H2bsph, has been studied in the past and its behavior with
Table 3
List of the some of the most important crystal data, structure refinement parameters,
distances (Å) and angles (°).
Parameters
Ref. [25]
Ref. [30]
This work (1)
Empirical
formula
Crystal system
Space group
V (Å3)
C
67H54N6Nd2O7 C61H46N6Nd2O7 C62H34Br6Cl6N6Nd2O7
monoclinic
P21
6090.7
4
triclinic
P1
monoclinic
P21/c
3.1. Magnetism
ꢀ
5424.6
4
6628.7
4
The temperature-dependent magnetic susceptibility data for a
crystalline sample of 1 were measured at applied fields of 0.02
(from 1.8 to 30 K) and 0.3 T (from 30 to 300 K) with superimpos-
able results (Fig. 3 Left). Magnetization measurements were car-
ried out at 2 K and in the field range 0–5 T (Fig. 3 Right).
Z
Distances (Å)
Nd1–Nd2
Nd3–Nd4
Ndꢀ ꢀ ꢀNd
3.9605
3.9629
8.190
3.9608
3.9364
7.677
3.9455
–
5.829
Angles (°)
The experimental
vMT value for 1 at room temperature is
Nd1–Ox–Nd2*
Nd1–Ox0–Nd2*
Nd3–Oy–Nd4*
Nd3–Oy0–Nd4*
108.3
110.5
110.2
110.5
109.5
110.6
108.7
109.0
110.0
108.5
–
3.92 cm3 molꢁ1 K, higher than the expected one for two uncoupled
4
NdIII ions in the I9/2 ground state (S = 3/2, L = 6, J = 15/2, g = 8/11,
v
MT = 3.28 cm3 molꢁ1 K) [37]. The graph shows a slope that gradu-
–
ally decreases by lowering temperature arriving to a value of
*
Numbers of x and x0 are 3 and 4 for Refs. [25,30,3,6] for complex 1. Values of y and
2.13 cm3 molꢁ1 K at 1.8 K. The observed behavior of the
vMT of 1
y0 are 10 and 11 for Refs. [3,4]. The ligand in this work is the N,N0-bis(salicylidene)-
1,2-cyclohexanediamine; The Schiff base used in reference 25 was bis-N,N0-p-
bromo-salicylideneamine-1,2-diaminobenzene and in reference 30 was 2,20-[(4,5-
dimethyl-1,2-phenylene)bis(nitrilomethylidyne)]bis[phenol].
could be attributed to weak antiferromagnetic interactions and
the depopulation of the Stark levels [38,39]. The M versus H plot
shows a faster increase at low magnetic fields and a slow linear