2
S. Bag et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. xxx (2014) xxx–xxx
O
The data indicate that the compounds overall belong to two dif-
R
O
S
O
ferent groups. The commercially available sulfonamides (1–6) and
the rather compact saccharin derivatives (7–12) commonly pro-
mote fibril formation. In contrast, the long linear-shaped com-
pounds (13–28) exhibited moderate to good fibrillogenesis
inhibition. Compounds 14, 18, 19, 21 and 26 showed the most
significant effect (87%, 60%, 43%, 64% and 45%, respectively). To
confirm that inhibition was not due to THT displacement by
compounds during the above assays, complementary Atomic Force
Microscopy (AFM) experiments were performed.34 For example,
AFM images of the solvent treated control and the sample incu-
bated in the presence of compound 14 (Fig. 3), which showed the
best (87%) fibril inhibition are depicted in Figure 5.
The images confirm the interpretation of the THT results.
The control sample showed the expected well-developed mature
fibrils, while the image of the inhibitor-containing sample reflects
the high, although not complete, inhibition. The small amount
of remaining fibril-like assemblies were thinner and shorter in
appearance indicating the profound effect of 14 on the Ab
fibrillogenesis.
1
4-OCH3
2 4-NO2
2-CH3
4 2-Br
3-C4H4
6
saccharin
H2N
NH
S
R
O
3
O
5
Figure 1. Structure of the tested commercial sulfonamides.
(b)
(a)
O
OH
O
O
H
O
O
N
N
Figure 2. Structure of donepezil (a) and galanthamine (b).
We expected that compounds with longer alkyl chains might
The compounds were also tested for their activity in the inhibi-
tion of oligomer formation by the biotinyl-Ab(1–42) single-site
streptavidin-based assay.35 The samples were incubated for
act as better cholinesterase inhibitors, mimicking the structural
features of donepezil (Fig. 2a); a well-known AChE inhibitor with-
out decreasing the efficiency of the compounds in other assays.32
Therefore, several saccharin derivatives (7–12) were synthesized
as illustrated in Scheme 1.
30 min in the assays, using Ab/inhibitor = 0.0002 ratio at 0.01 lM
Ab concentration. The intensity of the inhibited samples was nor-
malized to the control sample containing Ab and the solvent. The
percentile values were calculated similarly to those of fibril inhibi-
tion as shown above. The data are illustrated in Figure 6.
After the preliminary assays further modifications were exe-
cuted on the scaffold. Instead of having the sulfonamide moiety
in a ring, a relatively long, linear chain was introduced to the scaf-
fold, positioning the sulfonamide group in the chain. Aromatic
head and tail groups were added as well. This design aims to pro-
vide more flexibility to the compounds and at the same time to
continue to have large flat end-units. The synthesis of these second
generation compounds (14–26) is summarized in Scheme 2a.
Two additional compounds; 27 and 28 were also prepared
(Scheme 2b) to determine how the activity would be affected if
the sulfonamide moiety was eliminated from the scaffold. Each
product was characterized by 1H and 13C NMR spectroscopy and
by LC–MS. The spectroscopic characterization of the new com-
pounds was in agreement with their structures (see Supporting
information). The complete list of the compounds synthesized in
this work, except 27 and 28 (Scheme 2b), is shown in Figure 3.
To determine the activity profile of the compounds they were
first subjected to Ab fibrillogenesis assays. The quantitative Thio-
flavin-T (THT) fluorescence assay was applied to determine the
antifibrillogenic potency of the compounds.33 All data were nor-
malized to the fluorescence of the inhibitor-free control (Icontrol).
The fibrillogenesis assay data are presented in Figure 4.
Comparing Figure 6 to Figure 4, indicates that compounds
active against oligomers were poorly active against fibrillogenesis
and vice versa. The small commercial sulfonamides and saccharin
derivatives (1–12) showed moderate inhibition (up to 54%, except
11) of oligomers while the long chain linker containing sulfona-
mides (13–26) were generally oligomer formation promoters.
Interestingly, 27 and 28 showed 50–100% inhibition of oligomer
formation. These compounds are similar to the long chain sulfona-
mides (13–26), however, they lack the sulfonamide moiety. Com-
paring the activity of the compounds in the two Ab self-assembly
inhibition assays one cannot fail to notice that the behaviour of
the compounds in the two assays are the opposite; a compound
is either a fibril inhibitor or an oligomer inhibitor. This observation
is in agreement with our earlier findings21–24 and literature data.10
Oxidative stress caused by free radicals also plays an important
role in development of AD. Thus, the potential antioxidant charac-
ter of the compounds was also assessed. The scavenging of the 2,2-
diphenyl-1-picrylhydrazyl (DPPH) free radical was measured by
the decrease of its absorbance The data are compared to those
obtained with reference compounds ascorbic acid36 and
resveratrol,37 both of which are well-known antioxidants. The data
are illustrated in Figure 7.
1.NaH, DMF
RT, 1h
Three of our synthetic sulfonamides (19, 23 and 24) showed
higher free radical scavenging property than ascorbic acid, two
molecules (23 and 24) were even better than resveratrol.
2. X
O
O
Y
MW, 120oC, 5min
Y
With an aim to have multi-target functionality each compound
was assayed for the inhibition of cholinesterases. All of the synthe-
sized molecules were subjected to Ellman assay of the hydrolysis
of acetylthiocholine to determine their potency towards inhibition
of AChE and BuChE (Figs. 8 and 9). For AChE inhibition, the mole-
cules were assayed at 2 M; which is the IC50 of galanthamine
N
NH
S
S
O
O
O
O
6
7 8
-
Y = OH, N(C2H5)2
O
O
O
1. NaH, DMF
RT, 1h
2.
(Fig. 2b).38 Molecule 19 (Fig. 3) produced 88% inhibition at 2
lM,
+ R-NH2
N
NH
O
N
K2CO3, DMF,
S
O
while galanthamine at same concentration showed 54% inhibition.
Molecules 18 and 26 (Fig. 3) showed greater than 40% inhibition at
the same concentration. Due to solubility issues molecule 28
(Scheme 2) could not be tested in either assay. For BuChE inhibi-
Br-(CH2)3-Br
S
O
S
MW, 120oC,
MW, 120oC,
O
O
O
5min
Br
5min
NHR
9-12
6
R= alkyl, substituted alkyl
Scheme 1. Structure of the tested commercial sulfonamides.
tion, the molecules were assayed at 10
lM; which is the IC50 of
galanthamine against that enzyme.39 Nine out of 15 synthesized