Angewandte
Chemie
[
8]
screened for activity on a propane surrogate, dimethyl ether.
Positives were confirmed in a re-screen, purified, and
challenged with propane in sealed vials in the presence of a
cofactor regeneration system. As a cumulative measure of
both catalytic and coupling efficiency, improvement in total
turnover (moles of propanol produced per mole of enzyme)
was used as the sole selection criterion.
Measurement of the half-denaturation temperature of
3
5E11 heme domain demonstrated a considerable reduction
in its stability as a consequence of the 15 accumulated
mutations (T = 43.48C vs. 55.08C for wild type). We there-
5
0
fore subjected 35E11 to an initial thermostabilization step
HL1), in which stabilizing mutations from a thermostable
(
[
16]
P450BM3 peroxygenase were tested singly and in combina-
tion in the 35E11 background (see the Supporting
Information). Variant ETS8 (DT = + 5.18C, DTTN =
propane
5
0
À1250) showed the best combination of increased stability
with little decrease in TTN and was selected for further
directed evolution. Using ETS8 as parent, heme-domain
random mutagenesis libraries were generated by error-prone
PCR (HL2). Variant 19A12, with about twofold increase in
TTN (Table 1), was then used to create a pool of active-site
libraries (HL3) in which 17 positions along the substrate
channel (Figure 2a) and near the active site (Figure 2b) were
subjected individually to saturation mutagenesis. Further
improvements in propane-hydroxylating activity were ach-
ieved in multiple variants, including 11-3. Recombination of
the beneficial mutations from the active-site libraries (HL4)
led to variant 1-3. Further fine-tuning of the active site was
pursued with a series of recombination/site-saturation libra-
ries (HL5, see Supporting Information). From these libraries,
Figure 2. a) Substrate channel and b) active-site residues targeted for
saturation mutagenesis mapped on the palmitate-bound structure of
[
26]
P450BM3 heme domain (PDB 1FAG ). Heme (white) and fatty acid
orange) are shown in space-filling mode.
(
heme domain. Improved 11-3-derived variants were found to
contain G443A, V445R, P654K, T664G, D698G, and E1037G
mutations and showed TTN between 16000 and 20000. In the
final step, a library containing the beneficial reductase
domain mutations was fused to the heme domain of variant
7-7 (L9). The most active variant isolated from this library,
P450PMOR2, supported more than 45000 turnovers and
produced 2- and 1-propanol in a 9:1 ratio. As we expected,
the increase in productivity strongly correlates with the
increase in coupling efficiency, which in the best variant
(P450PMOR2, 98.2%) reaches levels comparable to those
measured for wild-type in the hydroxylation of myristate
7
-7 emerged as the most active variant, supporting 20500
turnovers with propane.
Meanwhile, two libraries were constructed in which
random mutations were targeted to the FMN- and FAD-
binding domains of 35E11 (RL1 and RL2, respectively).
Screening of more than 5000 members from each library led
to the identification of eight beneficial mutations (G443D,
V445M, T480M, T515M, P654Q, T664M, D698G, and
[
11]
(88%), palmitate (93%), or laurate (96%).
The sequence of mutational events leading to P450PMO
generation reveals a continuous rearrangement of substrate-
channel and active-site residues (Table 1), presumably in
search of an optimal configuration for accommodating
propane. Additional beneficial mutations in the hydroxylase
domain include L188P and G443A. Leucine 188 is located
along helix F, which together with helix G forms a lid covering
[
17]
E1037G).
These positions were further optimized by
saturation mutagenesis in a holoenzyme construct having
the 11-3 heme domain (RL3, RL4). Swapping the heme
domains this way serves to remove mutations whose benefi-
cial effect is solely dependent on the presence of the 35E11
[
a]
Table 1: In vitro propane oxidation activities of most representative P450BM3 variants.
[
b]
[c]
À1
[d]
Variant
Library
Mutations versus 35E11
Rate [equivmin
]
Coupling [%] Total turnovers
heme domain
reductase domain
3
1
1
6
1
7
5E11
9A12
1-3
98E5
-3
–
–
–
–
–
210
420
390
295
320
150
455
370
17.45650
HL2
HL3
RL3
HL4
HL5
L52I, L188P, I366V
L52I, A74S, L188P, I366V
L52I, A74S, L188P, I366V
L52I, A74S, V184A, L188P, I366V
L52I, A74E, S82G, A184V, L188P, I366V
44.2
55.3
65.3
72.1
90.9
94.4
98.2
10550
13200
17300
19200
20500
35600
45800
D698G
–
–
-7
P450PMOR1 L9
P450PMOR2 L9
L52I, A74E, S82G, A184V, L188P, I366V, G443A P654K, E1037G
L52I, A74E, S82G, A184V, L188P, I366V, G443A D698G
[
a] Mean values from at least three replicates Æ10% error. [b] Mutations in 35E11 are R47C, V78F, A82S, K94I, P142S, T175I, A184V, F205C, S226R,
H236Q, E252G, R255S, A290V, A328F, L353V, E464G, I710T. [c] Over the first 20 s. [d] Ratio between propanol formation rate and NADPH oxidation
rate in propane-saturated buffer.
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2007, 46, 8414 –8418
ꢀ 2007 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
8415