Angewandte
Communications
Chemie
Electrocatalysis
Morphology-Directed Selective Production of Ethylene or Ethane
from CO2 on a Cu Mesopore Electrode
Ki Dong Yang+, Woo Ri Ko+, Jun Ho Lee, Sung Jae Kim, Hyomin Lee,* Min Hyung Lee,* and
Ki Tae Nam*
Abstract: The electrocatalytic conversion of CO2 to value-
added hydrocarbons is receiving significant attention as
a promising way to close the broken carbon-cycle. While
most metal catalysts produce C1 species, such as carbon
monoxide and formate, the production of various hydro-
carbons and alcohols comprising more than two carbons has
been achieved using copper (Cu)-based catalysts only. Meth-
ods for producing specific C2 reduction outcomes with high
selectivity, however, are not available thus far. Herein, the
morphological effect of a Cu mesopore electrode on the
selective production of C2 products, ethylene or ethane, is
presented. Cu mesopore electrodes with precisely controlled
pore widths and depths were prepared by using a thermal
deposition process on anodized aluminum oxide. With this
simple synthesis method, we demonstrated that C2 chemical
selectivity can be tuned by systematically altering the morphol-
ogy. Supported by computational simulations, we proved that
nanomorphology can change the local pH and, additionally,
retention time of key intermediates by confining the chemicals
inside the pores.
In particular, hydrocarbons with high energy density, like
methane (CH4) and ethane (C2H6), are compatible with
existing infrastructures and can substitute for fossil fuels.[1,2]
Additionally, hydrocarbons with unsaturated bonds are used
as major feedstocks in polymer synthesis.[3,4] For instance,
ethylene (C2H4) has carbon double bond so that it can
participate serial chain propagation reactions. Among cur-
rently available materials, Cu-based catalysts have been
reported as the only electrodes exhibiting the reduction of
CO2 to various hydrocarbons.[5–7] However, the issue of
selectivity for the conversion of CO2 to a desired hydrocarbon
remains a scientific challenge and makes its practical appli-
cation far from certain.
Several factors in product selectivity have been revealed
for CO2 reduction. According to the recent theoretical
calculations, adsorbed intermediates and their relative stabil-
ities determine the final products. Adsorbed CO is trans-
formed to COH or remains in its original form, and each
intermediate is protonated, producing CH4 or inducing CO
dimerization[8,9] In this context, control of the adsorption
energy for specific intermediates and protons involving
kinetics have been attempted by controlling the crystal
facet,[10,11] grain boundary density,[12] and oxide layer thick-
ness.[13,14] In case of C2H4 formation, the highest Faradic
efficiency of 60% is achieved by the Cu2O–Cu biphasic
electrode,[15] whereas one of 9% is observed on polycrystal-
line Cu.[10] Selective production of CH4 or C2H4 also have
been achieved on Cu nanocubes, by controlling the crystal
facet and changing proton affinity.[3]
A
s well as a major contributor of greenhouse gas, CO2 also
can be an abundant C1 feedstock. Electrochemical CO2
conversion, powered by renewable energy, has attracted
considerable attention for achieving both objectives of
reducing the carbon footprint and closing the carbon cycle.
[*] K. D. Yang,[+] J. H. Lee, Prof. K. T. Nam
Department of Materials Science and Engineering
Seoul National University
Recently, the local proton concentration was reported as
another contributor. From previous reports, observations of
length- and density-dependent product selectivity on Cu
nanowires suggested that locally high pH near the electrode
may direct the reaction towards the CO pathway, which
requires fewer protons than that of the COH pathway.[16]
Similarly, a change in the conversion efficiency for formate
(HCOOH) was observed on Cu nanofoams, depending on the
pore size and thickness.[17] However, the nanofabricated
electrodes explored to date had a high variability in size,
tortuosity, and crystal structure, so that it remains a challenge
to assess the exact role of morphology. Moreover, the possible
interplay between the morphology and retention time of
intermediates, generally observed in chromatography[18] and
drug-delivery studies,[19] has never been investigated (Sup-
porting Information, Table S1). Herein, we prepared Cu
mesopore electrode with a precisely controlled morphology,
while maintaining its physical characteristics, and studied the
effect of nanomorphology on the product selectivity. By
performing specific activity analysis and an electrohydrody-
1 Gwanak-ro, Gwanak-gu, Seoul, 08826 (Korea)
E-mail: nkitae@snu.ac.kr
W. R. Ko,[+] Prof. M. H. Lee
Department of Applied Chemistry, Kyung Hee University
Yongin, Gyeonggi 17104 (Korea)
E-mail: minhlee@khu.ac.kr
Prof. S. J. Kim
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, Big Data
Institute, and Inter-University Semiconductor Research Center
Seoul National University
1 Gwanak-ro, Gwanak-gu, Seoul, 08826 (Korea)
Prof. H. Lee
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering and Institute of
Advanced Machines and Design
Seoul National University
1 Gwanak-ro, Gwanak-gu, Seoul, 08826 (Korea)
E-mail: nanofluidics@snu.ac.kr
[+] These authors contributed equally to this work.
Supporting information, including experimental details, for this
article can be found under:
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2016, 55, 1 – 6
ꢀ 2016 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
1
These are not the final page numbers!