400
X. Dong et al. / Journal of Molecular Structure 984 (2010) 396–401
charged analytes, the addition of Clꢀ at a much lower concentra-
tion does lead to a great enhancement in SERS signal. However, it
can be observed from Fig. 2 that the addition of NaCl at a low con-
centration (0.01–0.04 mol dmꢀ3) mainly causes the modification of
the silver surface chemistry but causes little aggregation, and
aggregation occurs when the concentration of NaCl increases to
0.05 mol dmꢀ3. The experiment results imply that the modification
of silver surface caused by Clꢀ changes the binding affinity of MB
and it leads to a variation in SERS intensity that can be attributed
to the ‘‘activation’’ effect in SERS but not due to the aggregation
of silver particles. The optimal concentration of Clꢀ is
0.02 mol dmꢀ3. When adding more Clꢀ to the colloidal solution,
the SERS intensity of MB drops, and it may be due to the collapse
of colloidal particles. At the same time, the band of Ag–Cl bonds
is in proportion to MB bands. The result is reflected in the
241:1627 cmꢀ1 ratio, which is 0.886, 0.916, 0.805, 0.722, corre-
sponding to 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.4 mol dmꢀ3 NaCl. The reason has been
discussed above. Fig. 8 shows the SERS spectra of MB when adding
Brꢀ and Iꢀ to the colloid. It is observed that Brꢀ and Iꢀ give low
enhancement though they have a high affinity for silver surface.
From these detections it can be easily calculated that silver colloid
with appropriate concentration of anions can enhance the Raman
signal several orders of magnitude: The enhancement factor of
SERS can be calculated from the formulation [12,29,32].
volume, and the Nsol is the number of MB molecules in aqueous
solution in laser activation volume. Nads and Nsol are directly pro-
portional to the concentration of MB in colloid and in aqueous solu-
tion, respectively. From the calculation, the enhancement factors for
MB with optimal concentration of Clꢀ, NO3ꢀ, SO4ꢀ2, Brꢀ, and Iꢀ are
1.72 ꢁ 107, 1.45 ꢁ 107, 6.27 ꢁ 106, 1.02 ꢁ 107 and 4.9 ꢁ 106, respec-
tively (for the SERS/Raman band at 1626/1626 cmꢀ1). The result
shows that Iꢀ, the most strongly binding anion, gives the least
enhancement for SERS. Clꢀ gives the greatest enhancement among
the series anions. From previous studies [33,34], the aggregation
of silver particles (electromagnetic mechanism) plays a key role in
SERS while the modification of silver surface chemistry (charge
transfer mechanism) only enhance the SERS signal a few fold. How-
ever, in this study the strongly binding anions, such as halides, give
greater enhancement factors than 105. This can be attributed to the
cooperative effect of the two mechanisms for halides. From the
above discussion, the addition of Iꢀ does not cause any aggregation.
So, it can be concluded that the poor enhancement of Iꢀ may be due
to its poor aggregation effect after adding MB to the colloid. The
problem why the most strongly binding anions cause the least
aggregation of silver particles is not clear yet and need to be further
investigated. The poor enhancement of SO24ꢀ may be also due to its
poor aggregation effect. From what has been discussed above,
aggregating agents mainly lead to two effects on the greatest
enhancement of SERS. As for the weak binding anions (weaker than
the residual ions on the silver particles), the effect of anions is to
aggregate the silver particles. As for the strong binding anions
which can displace the residual ions on the silver particles, the main
effect is to cause the modification of silver surface chemistry, but
the aggregation effect also occurs. So it may be due to the coopera-
tive effect of the two effects.
G ¼ ðIAg=NadsÞ=ðIsol=Nsol
Þ
where IAg and Isol are the intensities of the same band for MB in the
SERS spectrum and in the normal Raman spectrum, respectively.
Nads is the number of MB molecules in the colloid in laser activation
4. Conclusions
From this study, it is found that relative affinity of residual ions
in BRSC is weaker than that of halideions and the bands of residual
ions can be removed by the added halideions. The addition of the
most strongly binding anions-Iꢀ does not cause any aggregation
of silver particles. The addition of Clꢀ leads two effects on the col-
loid: the aggregation of the colloid and the modification of the sur-
face chemistry of the silver particles. The addition of NaCl at a low
concentration mainly causes the modification of the silver surface
chemistry but causes little aggregation. From the SERS of MB, it is
found that the Clꢀ with optimal concentration which gives the
greatest enhancement mainly leads to the modification of silver
surface chemistry, and the surface modification makes the MB
molecules to adsorb on silver surface easily and lead to great
enhancement. However, the aggregation effect also occurs. So it
may be due to the cooperative effect of the two effects. For the
weak binding anions, such as NOꢀ3 and SOꢀ4 2, the only effect of an-
ions is to aggregate the silver particles. The purpose of this study is
to further investigate the effect of anions on silver colloid and clar-
ify the interaction mechanism between anions and borohydride-
reduced silver colloid. It will help to find some general principles
that could be used to make the experimental conditions suitable
for detecting some analytes in high efficiency.
Acknowledgement
This research is supported by the National Natural Science
Foundation of China (60678050).
References
Fig. 8. (a) SERS spectra of MB when adding increasing concentrations of Brꢀ to the
colloid. (b) SERS spectra of MB when adding increasing concentrations of Iꢀ to the
colloid.
[1] M. Fleishman, P.J. Hendra, A.J. McQuillan, Chem. Phys. Lett. 26 (1974) 163.
[2] D.L. Janmaire, R.P. Van Duyne, J. Electroanal. Chem. 84 (1977) 1.