NEW MEDIUM USEFUL FOR THE RECOVERY OF DERMATOPHYTES
87
deactivators when antifungal drug-containing clinical
specimen from the infected hosts are subjected to culture
studies to recover viable fungi for mycological evaluation
of efficacy of antifungal chemotherapy they received.
However, there is virtually no information available on
the deactivator of antifungal drugs for clinical use. The
only exception is previous papers reporting that several
phospholipids and nonionic surfactants lecithin with an
unsaturated fatty acyl group, including as egg lecithin and
polysorbate 80, are also effective as the antagonist of the
two first-generation imidazole-antifungal drugs, clotri-
mazole and miconazole (15, 16).
For these reasons, our initial studies were attempted to
see whether and how egg lecithin and polysorbate 80 are
antagonistic against the two second-generation imidazole
drugs BFZ and LCZ, as well as against an allylamine
drug TBF. The results of interaction studies demon-
strated that both deactivators dose-dependently reversed
the anti-dermatophytic activity of the three drugs, and,
moreover, that a combination of the two deactivators at
their respective highest concentrations tested (1% for
egg lecithin and 0.7% for polysorbate 80) showed a
greater level of antagonistic effect. These results led us
to the possibility that an agar medium supplemented
with this combination of deactivators (CDSAM) would
be more efficient in recovering dermatophytes from clin-
ical specimens than a conventional agar medium thus far
used, such as SDA (BAM). The antagonistic effect of
higher concentrations of either or both of the two deac-
tivators was not examined for a technical reason which
made it difficult to prepare culture media good enough
for the culture study. When added to the basal medium,
egg lecithin at levels above 1% formed insoluble aggre-
gates in the medium, and polysorbate 80 at levels above
the recovery of surviving fungi. Although there is no
direct evidence available for either possibility, the latter
looks more probable because our previous studies in
which experiments were conducted using the same ani-
mal model of tinea pedis as well as the same therapeutic
regimen demonstrated that the 7 day- to 14 day-treatment
with 1% LCZ or TBF resulted in complete inhibition of
relapse of the infection, suggesting achievement of
mycological cure or eradication of infecting fungi (9, 13,
14).
It remains to be answered as to the mechanism of
antagonistic action of egg lecithin and polysorbate 80
toward the imidazole or allylamine drugs. Since both
deactivators are surface-active, they form micelles in
an aqueous medium, into which these drugs of strong
hydrophobic and lipophilic nature may be entrapped,
eventually keeping the drug molecule from contact with
the surface of fungal cells. However, for the moment no
data are available for supporting this postulation, and fur-
ther physicochemical analyses of the deactivator-drug
interaction are warranted.
The results of the present study lead us to the possi-
bility that in vivo activities of various imidazole and
allylamine drugs or related antifungal compounds thus
for evaluated in animal model of dermatophytosis using
a conventional medium for recovery culture would lead
us to overestime their efficacy. And this culture problem
could be overcome partly, at least, by the use of CDSAM
or some other media equally capable of inactivating the
antifungal drug carried over for recovery culture in place
of a conventional medium. It is also suggested that
CDSAM may also be useful for mycological examina-
tions in the clinical settings. A clinical study of patients
with tinea pedis receiving treatments with BFZ and LCZ
to test the fungal recovery on this newly developed
medium is currently under way.
0.7% rendered the medium foamy.
The expectation of the usefulness of CDSAM was
met by subsequent animal studies using the guinea pig
model of tinea pedis. The results of recovery culture of
skin tissue specimens taken from infected animals
demonstrated that CDSAM gave a significantly increased
yield of viable fungi compared with BAM, when infect-
ed animals received a 7 day-treatment with BFZ, as
well as with the two more potent drugs LCZ and TBF.
This was also the case for animals with tinea pedis treat-
ed for 14 days with BFZ but not for those with LCZ or
TBF. All or almost all tissue specimens from infected
animals were culture-negative on both BMA and
CDSAM after the 14 day-treatment with LCZ or TBF,
leading us to the two possible explanations for the results.
One is that infecting fungi were actually eradicated.
The other is that prolonged treatment with such potent
drugs caused their accumulation to levels too high for the
deactivator combination to sufficiently inactivate to allow
We thank Shinichi Watanabe MD for his encouragement and
helpful discussions.
References
1) Brummer, B. 1976. Influence of possible disinfectant trans-
fer on Staphylococcus aureus plate counts after agar contact
sampling. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 32: 80―84.
2) Erlandson, A.L., Jr., and Lawrence, C.A. 1953. Inactivating
medium for hexachlorophene (G-11) types of compounds and
some substituted phenolic disinfectants. Science 118: 274
―
2
76.
3
) Espinel-Ingroff, A., Dawson, K., Pfaller, M., Anaissie, E.,
Breslin, B., Dixon, D., Fothergill, A., Paetznick, V., Peter, J.,
Rinaldi, M., and Walsh, T. 1995. Comparative and collabo-
rative evaluation of standardization of antifungal suscepti-
bility testing for filamentous fungi. Antimicrob. Agents