Communications
DOI: 10.1002/anie.201001765
Aromaticity
Mꢀbius Antiaromatic Bisphosphorus Complexes of [30]Hexaphyrins**
Tomohiro Higashino, Jong Min Lim, Takahiro Miura, Shohei Saito, Jae-Yoon Shin,
Dongho Kim,* and Atsuhiro Osuka*
Aromaticity is a fundamental concept in organic chemistry
and is important in understanding, for instance, that the
energetic stability of benzene originates from cyclic p-
electron delocalization. The Hꢀckel rule is very useful, and
helps us to predict that cyclic [4n+2]p- and [4n]p-conjugated
systems should be aromatic and antiaromatic, respectively,
given that their p systems lie on two-sided normal planes. On
the other hand, Mꢁbius aromaticity, which complements the
Hꢀckel aromaticity, predicts that the above [4n+2] and
[4n] Hꢀckel rule should be reversed for those p systems that
lie on a singly twisted Mꢁbius topology.[1] The concept of
Mꢁbius aromaticity, first proposed by Heilbronner in 1964,[2]
is simple and elegant, and has considerably stimulated both
experimental and theoretical approaches toward Mꢁbius
aromatic molecules.[1b,c,3] However, the realization of
Mꢁbius aromatic systems is difficult, since the implementa-
tion of two conflicting structural features, that is, cyclic full
p conjugation and a singly twisted topology, within a single
macrocycle is not easy. Despite this difficulty, a seminal report
by Herges and co-workers described the synthesis and
moderate aromaticity of a twisted [16]annulene molecule.[4]
Importantly, this work revitalized the interest in Mꢁbius
aromaticity. In recent years, meso-aryl-substituted expanded
porphyrins have emerged as a remarkably effective platform
to realize stable Mꢁbius aromatic systems. The attributes of
these porphyrins include conformational flexibility, which
allows flipping of the constitutional pyrrole rings, and the
availability of the neutral states for two-electron oxidation
and reduction by releasing two protons from aminopyrrole
parts and accepting two hydride ions at the iminopyrrolic
parts, respectively.[5]
However, despite the increasing number of [4n]p Mꢁbius
aromatic molecules, [4n+2]p Mꢁbius antiaromatic species
still remain rather elusive. As a rare example of these species,
´
Latos-Graz˙ynski and co-workers reported that a cationic
palladium(II) vacataporphyrin displayed a weak paratropic
ring current (Dd = 1.63–2.67 ppm, nucleus-independent
chemical shift (NICS): + 4.0–6.0 ppm), which was ascribed
to the 18p antiaromatic character based on the calculated
Mꢁbius structure, but without crystal structure evidence.[6]
Thus, it can be said that structurally well-characterized
Mꢁbius antiaromatic species with a distinct paratropic ring
current have not been reported to date.[7]
In general, the evaluation of aromaticity relies on
energetic, geometric, and magnetic parameters. The most
sensitive and widely applicable techniques for studying the
1
magnetic properties are H NMR chemical shifts, NICS,[8a]
and anisotropy of the induced current density (AICD).[8b] In
addition, our recent studies have demonstrated common
photophysical properties for aromatic and antiaromatic
porphyrinoids.[9] These antiaromatic expanded porphyrins
exhibit several unique features that are not observed for their
aromatic congeners: 1) broad and ill-defined absorption
spectra without Q-like bands in the near-IR region, 2) weak
or practically no fluorescence, 3) small two-photon absorp-
tion (TPA) cross-section values, and 4) very short excited-
state lifetimes. These features are attributable to electronic
features such as the relatively narrow HOMO–LUMO gap
(HOMO = highest occupied molecular orbital, LUMO =
lowest unoccupied molecular orbital) with perturbed degen-
eracy of HOMO/HOMO-1 and LUMO/LUMO + 1, and the
presence of an optically forbidden S1 state. These features are
not observed for aromatic expanded porphyrins. Herein, we
report a bisphosphorus complex of [30]hexaphyrin as the first
example of a structurally well-characterized and stable
[4n+2]p Mꢁbius antiaromatic molecule, in which the two
incorporated phosphoramide moieties play important roles in
rigidifying a singly twisted Mꢁbius conformation and render a
highly reduced [30]hexaphyrin stable.
[*] J. M. Lim, J.-Y. Shin, Prof. Dr. D. Kim
Spectroscopy Laboratory for Functional p-electronic Systems and
Department of Chemistry, Yonsei University
Seoul 120-749 (Korea)
Fax: (+82)2-364-7050
E-mail: dongho@yonsei.ac.kr
T. Higashino, T. Miura, S. Saito, Prof. Dr. A. Osuka
Department of Chemistry
Graduate School of Science, Kyoto University
Sakyo-ku, Kyoto 606-8502 (Japan)
Fax: (+81)75-753-3970
E-mail: osuka@kuchem.kyoto-u.ac.jp
[**] This work was supported by Grants-in-Aid (A) (No. 19205006 (A)
and 20108001 “pi-Space”) for Scientific Research from MEXT. The
work at Yonsei University was supported by the Star Faculty and
World Class University (R32-10217) programs from the Ministry of
Education, Science, and Technology (MEST) of Korea and the
AFSOR/AOARD grant (FA2386-09-1-4092). The AICD calculations
were performed by using the supercomputing resource of the Korea
Institute of Science and Technology Information (KISTI). S.S.
acknowledges a JSPS Fellowship for Young Scientists. J.M.L
acknowledges the Seoul Science Fellowship.
Phosphorus insertion into porphyrinoids has proved a
useful means to realize isophlorin-type fully reduced annu-
lenic p conjugation.[10] Encouraged by these results, we
attempted the reaction of meso-pentafluorophenyl [28]hexa-
phyrin(1.1.1.1.1.1) (1a) with POCl3 (100 equiv) in the pres-
ence of triethylamine at room temperature for 24 h, which
gave monophosphorus [28]hexaphyrin 2a in 65% yield after
aqueous workup. We also found that a further treatment of 2a
Supporting information for this article is available on the WWW
4950
ꢀ 2010 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2010, 49, 4950 –4954