A. Chiva et al. / Tetrahedron Letters 51 (2010) 2720–2723
2721
have been used in solid-phase peptide and carbohydrate synthe-
sis.8 They have been classified as exo- or endo-linkers which can
be cleaved by exo- or endo-enzymes, respectively.8 Exo-Linkers
have been developed by several groups for applications in carbohy-
drate assembly and combinatorial chemistry.9,10
trichloroacetimidate derivatives using trichloroacetonitrile and
DBU,19 then reacted with 8 and boron trifluoride etherate to give
the coupled resins 10 and 11. PEGA-NH2 1900 g/mol (0.20 mmol/g)
and PEGA-NH2 800 g/mol (0.40 mmol/g) were reacted with the
succinimidyl carbonate of 8 to give resins 12 and 13.
The arrangement of endo-linkers is linear and cleavage normally
results in partial retention of the enzyme recognition group with
the target molecule.8 Several endo-linked systems have also been
described,11,12 including an aminopropyl silica support and ester
Enzymatic hydrolysis of the resins was then performed. The
cleavage to give 7 was monitored by HPLC analysis. The level of re-
sin loading in each case was determined by resin hydrolysis using
1 M NaOH (24 h) and quantitative determination of 7 by HPLC.
Enzymatic cleavage levels were then calculated relative to the total
loading of 8. Resin-conjugate 10 was submitted to enzymatic
hydrolysis with a range of enzymes previously screened against
2. No substantial hydrolysis was observed (Table 2, entry 1) due
to poor diffusion of the enzyme into the resin. For enzyme cleavage
experiments using 11, low hydrolysis yields of up to 6% were
determined (Table 2, entries 2 and 3). Several studies using Tenta-
Gel adducts with enzymes have been reported with variable re-
sults, including a 50% cleavage yield with penicillin amidase
(MW 60 kDa);9 lipase RB001-05 to hydrolyse an acetate group in
73% yield, although penicillin acylase (MW 80 kDa) was used to
cleave a related exo-linker but gave only 1% hydrolysis,10,20 and
using papain (MW 23 kDa) to cleave a resin-bound fluorescently
labelled peptide (MW 23 kDa) where very low yields were ob-
served.21 Our data suggest that the majority of the cleavage with
the TentaGel-conjugate 11 is ‘surface-based’ with poor accessibil-
ity to the enzymes used.1
PEGA resins can swell up to 60-fold the weight of the polymer
in aqueous buffers and allow large proteins to diffuse into the inte-
rior of the polymer, although they are not as easy to handle as the
TentaGel resins.1,21 Resin-conjugates 12 and 13 were used with se-
lected enzymes, predominantly from the family of Pseudomonas,
which proved to work well with the solution-based analogue.
Again regioselective cleavage of the ester to give 7 was observed,
but the levels of hydrolysis were much higher than those for 10
and 11. Lipoprotein from Pseudomonas sp. andPseudomonas cepacia
lipase showed the best catalytic efficiency with both 12 and 13,
and total hydrolysis was achieved using the former with 12 (Table
2, entry 5). Reports in the literature using PEGA in enzyme cleav-
able reactions have highlighted that the higher the molecular
weight of the enzyme, the lower the cleavage. Specifically, near
quantitative yields were achieved with enzymes of MW up to
50 kDa, and above this, reaction yields were normally low.1,20,22
These data agree with our studies where P. cepacia lipase (MW
25 kDa)23 and lipoprotein lipase from Pseudomonas sp., (MW
33 kDa)24 using 12 and 13 gave high hydrolysis yields (Table 2, en-
tries 4, 7 and 5, 8) while the Pseudomonas fluorescens and Aspergil-
lus oryzae lipase with MWs of around 50 kDa24,25 gave lower
cleavage yields (Table 2, entries 6, 9 and 10).
cleavable linker which was readily hydrolysed using a-chymotryp-
sin.13 Our approach was to use an endo-linker strategy based upon
compound 1 possessing a hydrocarbon chain as a spacer, an ester
linker to be enzymatically cleaved, a diethylene glycol unit to en-
hance the solubility of the signalling molecule when cleaved and
in aqueous solution and a signalling moiety. In this study a fluores-
cent pyrene species was used. To assess the ease of cleavage in
aqueous solution, compound 2 was synthesised possessing a ben-
zyloxy group to mimic the solid support (Scheme 2).
Compound 314 was coupled to Boc-protected 2-(2-aminoeth-
oxy)ethanol 415 using DCC and HOBt. Removal of the Boc group
gave 5 which was then reacted with commercially available N-
hydroxysuccinimide pyrene (6) to give 2 in 95% yield. Compound
7, the corresponding hydrolysis product, was readily prepared by
reacting pyrene butyric acid with 2-(2-aminoethoxy)ethanol and
DCC and HOBt in 65% yield. Several esterases, proteases and lipases
were assessed for the cleavage of analogue 2–7 to enable selection
of a smaller number of hydrolytic enzymes to use with resin ana-
logues. Representative cleavage data after 1 h is summarised in Ta-
ble 1. Several lipases (entries 4, 7, 9, 10 and 11) demonstrated good
levels of hydrolysis and these were explored further in resin-based
reactions.
The choice of the resin solid support was crucial: it must be
compatible with the biocatalyst, swell in the reaction solvent and
enable accessibility of the enzyme to the interior of the resin.16
Several resins were initially selected for the preparation of enzyme
cleavable systems. Polystyrene-based supports were considered,
despite the fact that they are known to shrink in aqueous media,
because the loading level is higher than that in many available res-
ins and they might be useful in exploring non-aqueous-based
chemistries. TentaGel resin, which swells well in aqueous solu-
tions, was investigated, although the polystyrene core can limit
the access of macromolecules for cleavage purposes.16 Polyacryl-
amide resin PEGA has been recognised as highly suitable for use
in enzyme-based chemistries, and was also investigated.17
Initially compound 8 was synthesised for attachment to resins
(Scheme 3). 6-(Tetrahydropyranyloxy)hexanoic acid18 (9) was
coupled to 4 using DCC and HOBt. Deprotection and reaction with 6
gave 8. The Wang (p-benzyloxybenzyl alcohol [HMP] 0.80 mmol/g)
and TentaGel HMP (0.35 mmol/g) resins were converted into their
Two further potential supports were then investigated. PAM-
AMs are commercially available polyamido amine dendrimers with
a high loading capacity, and different generations are available,
reflecting the degree of loading possible.26 They have been used
as a dendrimeric support to synthesise a polysaccharide with the
enzyme cellodextrin phosphorylase.27 Attachment to latex beads
was envisaged to generate multiply-functionalised amine resins
for use in immunoassays. To explore the use of PAMAMs alone in
preliminary studies, a generation 1 PAMAM was coupled to 8 to
yield dendrimer 14 (Scheme 4). Enzymatic cleavage experiments
were performed: however, only lipoprotein lipase from Pseudomo-
nas sp. hydrolysed the ester moiety in low yield (Table 3) and this
approach was not explored further.
position of ester cleavable group
O
O
O
signalling group
1
is a polymeric support
O
N
H
n
m
O
Boc
O
O
HO
OH
N
H
4
Ph
O
O
Ph
O
5
NH2
O
5
5 3
O
a,b
O
pyr
c
6
N O
3
pyr is pyrene
O
O
O
O
O
pyr
Ph
O
O
pyr
HO
N
H
O
N
H
Polyethylene glycol has been successfully used as a soluble
polymeric support in liquid-phase organic synthesis (LPOS).28,29
After reactions, the polymer can be precipitated by the addition
of diethyl ether, which allows ease of separation and purification
and having a solubilised support will enable the enzyme to ap-
3
5
3
7
2
Scheme 2. Cleavable signalling molecule 1, synthesis of solution-phase analogue 2
and structure 7. Reagents and conditions: (a) Et3N, HOBt, DCC, 52%; (b) TFA, 95%; (c)
6, DMAP, 95%.