T. Fang, et al.
Bioorganic&MedicinalChemistryLettersxxx(xxxx)xxxx
Table 1
however a 9-fold loss in aPTT clotting activity (EC1.5x = 2.6 μM) was
seen. The trifluoroethylamine proved to be a good replacement for the
amide moiety in the 12-membered macrocycle but not the 13-mem-
bered macrocycle 14, where a 330-fold loss in FXIa affinity (FXIa
Ki = 53 nM) was observed. Since 12-membered macrocycles with an
amine linker were more potent, additional substitutions were explored.
Diastereomer (R)-CHF2 11 was equipotent to (R)-CF3 10. When the
fluoro alkyl groups were replaced with either CH3 as in 12 or hydrogen
as in 13, a loss in both FXIa affinity (> 6-fold) and metabolic stability
was observed. The difference in FXIa binding affinity can be rationa-
lized based on the electron withdrawing ability of the R-substituent.
Specifically, the stronger electron withdrawing ability of the fluoro
alkyl substituents in 10 and 11 makes the adjacent NH a better H-bond
donor for Leu41 compared to either the methyl or hydrogen substituent
in 12 and 13.
12- and 13-membered macrocyclic FXIa inhibitors (the macrocyclic amide
linker is highlighted in blue).
Compd #
n
Saturation/unsaturation
(ring size)
1
2
0 (12)
1 (13)
saturated
E-alkene
1.0
0.30
0.27
An X-ray crystal structure of 10 bound to human FXIa active site
(2.2 Å resolution, Fig. 1) was obtained.20 The compound occupies the
S1, S1 prime, and the S2 prime binding pockets. The absolute stereo-
chemistry of the trifluoroethylamine moiety was determined to be the
R-configuration. An overlay of trifluoroethylamine linker 10 and amide
linker 1 is shown in Fig. 2 and highlights the interaction of the tri-
fluoroethylamine moiety. As postulated in the design, the tri-
fluoroethylamine moiety maintains the key H-bond (3.0 Å) with Leu41
and mimics the amide interaction. Interestingly, the X-ray crystal
structure also revealed that the CF3 group, known to be a weak H-bond
acceptor,21 is within hydrogen bonding distance (3.0 Å) to Arg39. This
weak H-bonding interaction may also be contributing to the FXIa
binding affinity of the fluoro alkyl analogs 10 and 11, but not 12 or 13.
In order to explore this potential interaction between the CF3 group
and Arg39, the CF3 moiety was replaced with other potential H-bond
acceptors (Table 4). We focused on 12-membered macrocycles since the
much less potent. Replacing the CF3 with methyl ester 15 resulted in a
2-fold increase in FXIa affinity (FXIa Ki = 0.46 nM) and a 5-fold im-
0.16
His40 and the carbonyl of the carbamate forms an H-bond to Ile151 via
a water molecule) and it was not clear how the loss of these interactions
would affect FXIa affinity.12 Removing the carbamate moiety in 12-
membered macrocycle 3 lowered PSA (130 Å2) but also led to a sig-
nificant loss in FXIa affinity (48-fold; FXIa Ki = 48 nM), aPTT potency
(> 100 fold; EC1.5x > 40 μM) and metabolic stability [15-fold; human
liver microsome (HLM) t1/2 = 6 min]. A similar loss in FXIa binding
affinity (32-fold) and metabolic stability was observed when the car-
bamate was removed in the 13-membered macrocycle 4; however, a
single-digit nanomolar FXIa inhibitor (FXIa Ki = 5.1 nM) with good
aPTT potency (EC1.5x = 2.9 μM) was realized. Encouraged by this result
in the 13-membered macrocycle, additional substituents were explored
at the 4- and 5-positions of the P2 prime phenyl group with the goal of
improving metabolic stability. Whereas introduction of a fluoro at C5
(5) resulted in a slight loss in FXIa affinity, C4-F (6) was equipotent
with 4. Unfortunately, neither 5 nor 6 improved HLM stability.
Compound 8, with a carboxylic acid group at C4, was the only analog
that maintained FXIa affinity and improved metabolic stability
(HLM t1/2 = 94 min), but unfortunately PSA (168 Å2) was high. Since
efforts to reduce PSA in the P2 prime region led to a loss in both FXIa
affinity and metabolic stability, we turned our attention to modifying
the amide moiety in the macrocyclic linker.
provement in aPTT clotting potency (EC1.5x
= 0.55 μM). The
ethyl ester 16 was similar in potency to methyl ester 15. These ester
analogs had high PSA values (178 Å2) and poor metabolic stability
(HLM t1/2 ≤10 min). Acid 17 was similar in potency to the corre-
sponding ester analogs and exhibited improved metabolic stability
(HLM t1/2 = 70 min). Amide 18 and hydroxymethyl 19 analogs dis-
played good FXIa affinity and aPTT potency but also suffered from poor
metabolic stability. Homologation of methyl ester 20 led to a 4- to
5-fold loss in FXIa affinity. The NH moiety in the macrocyclic linker
proved to be the major contributor to FXIa affinity, as removal of the
NH led to a 50-fold loss in FXIa binding affinity for the all-carbon linker
21.22 In general, the imidazole-based macrocycles containing the sub-
stituted amine linkers in Table 4 had high PSA values (≥172 Å2)
and, aside from acid 17, suffered from poor metabolic stability
(HLM t1/2 ≤ 14 min).
During our initial exploration of the imidazole-based macrocyclic
series, the macrocycles with an amide linker were identified as giving
the most potent FXIa inhibitors.12 It was demonstrated by X-ray crys-
tallography that the NH of the amide moiety forms a key H-bond with
Leu41 (2.8 Å) which contributed significantly to FXIa binding affinity
but proved to be deleterious for oral bioavailability.12 The literature
suggests that amide isosteres may be a means of modulating polarity
and oral bioavailability.17 We were particularly interested in replacing
the amide moiety with a suitable isostere that had the potential to
maintain the key H-bonding interaction with Leu41 such as a tri-
fluoroethylamine [–CH(CF3)NH–] group. The trifluoroethylamine unit
has been adopted as an effective amide isostere in drug design since it is
a non-basic amine with excellent H-bond donating ability.18,19 How-
ever, it was not clear whether the trifluoroethylamine moiety, once it
was incorporated into the linker, would be able to adopt the desired
conformation to maintain the key H-bond with Leu41. Moreover, an
unsubstituted macrocycle linked by an amine was prepared earlier in a
13-membered macrocycle and it showed a significant loss in FXIa af-
X-ray crystal structures of methyl ester 15 (2.12 Å resolution, Fig. 3)
active site were obtained.23 The carbonyl of the methyl ester in 15
formed an H-bond to Arg39 (2.8 Å). The ether oxygen forms an H-bond
to the Cys58 backbone carbonyl via two water molecules. Interestingly,
the ethyl ester in 16 does not form an H-bond to Arg39. Rather, the
ethyl ester is flipped so that the ethyl portion forms a van der Waals
contact with a small pocket created by residues 39–41 and the carbonyl
makes an H-bond to Cys58 carbonyl through two water molecules
Previous work from our lab on the macrocyclic series showed that
the imidazole scaffold can be replaced with a pyridine ring system and
maintain FXIa binding affinity.16c As a result, the optimized amine
linkers were combined with a pyridine scaffold (Table 5). The tri-
in FXIa affinity (FXIa Ki = 16 nM) and a 5-fold loss in aPTT activity
(EC1.5x = 13 μM) when compared to imidazole-based analog 10.
Due to the synthetic route, two diastereomers were produced by
incorporating the trifluoroethylamine group into the macrocyclic
backbone. In the 12-membered macrocycle, both diastereomers (S)-CF3
9 and (R)-CF3 10 (Table 3) exhibited a desired, lower PSA value (152 Å2
loss (370-fold) in FXIa affinity, while diastereomer (R)-CF3 10 showed
similar FXIa binding affinity (FXIa Ki = 1.1 nM) compared to amide 1,
2