4240
T. J. Woltering et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 23 (2013) 4239–4243
amide NH and the pyridyl N. As depicted inFigure 1 the substitution
at the pyridyl residue was found by many research groups to be
Benzoannelation of the HG as in amidine 5 also produced a
moderately active compound, but with much higher basicity
though (pKa = 9.7).
0
0
most favorable in positions marked R3 and R5 where small substit-
0
uents in R3 (e.g., Me and Cl) were preferred.5,12–20 The deep S3
Enlarging the ring size from the aminohydantoin 4 by one CH2
0
channel suggests a para substitution of the S3 pyridyl ring (R5 ) with
group to the 2-aminodihydropyrimidinone 813 resulted in a very
halogens or small linear substituents such as cyano. To evaluate the
active compound (BACE1 enzyme IC50 = 0.015
lM, cellular assay
0
various effects of the different head groups the R5 substituent was
IC50 = 0.001 M), but the basic compound (pKa = 8.4) was also
l
kept to Cl in this study (exception: compound 3; Table 1). The
BACE1 inhibitory activities of the compounds were determined in
a human BACE1 enzyme as well as in a cell-based assay. The pKa
was examined by capillary electrophoresis (cEpKa); exceedingly ba-
sic compounds often suffer from undesired potential liabilities of
phospholipidosis8 and polypharmacology.9,10 The compounds’
properties as a substrate of human P-glycoprotein (P-gp) expressed
as the efflux ratio (ER) were determined. Further in vivo character-
ization of selected compounds for the AD indication was performed
by measuring the reduction of Ab40 in the brain 4 h after adminis-
tration of 30 mg/kg p.o. in our wild type mice model.11 For some
compounds the plasma and brain exposure was also determined
at this time point.
found to be a very good P-gp substrate (hER 18.6) which led to
in vivo inactivity (<10% reduction of Ab40 at 30 mg/kg p.o.; expo-
sure 4 h after 50 mg/kg p.o.: plasma: 2506 426 ng/ml, brain:
586 164 ng/g, brain/plasma ratio: 0.19). Removing the carbonyl
group gave the almost equally potent cyclic guanidine 9, but its ba-
sicity even exceeded the measurable range (pKa >11) and it was
due to very low exposure also inactive in vivo (<15% reduction of
Ab40 at 30 mg/kg p.o.; exposure 4 h after 30 mg/kg p.o.: plasma:
<3 ng/ml, brain: <13 ng/g).
The aminopiperazinone 1014 was much less active than its po-
sition isomer 8 whereas removal of the carbonyl group from HG
in 10 led to the corresponding aminopiperidine 1115 with im-
proved in vitro activity but it is highly basic (pKa = 10.2), a good
P-gp substrate (hER 9.6) and therefore was not tested in vivo.
Enlarging the ring size from the 2-aminooxazoline 2 by one CH2
group to the 2-amino-1,3-oxazine 1216,17 resulted in moderate
The 2-aminooxazoline HG in compound 2 showed a decent
activity (IC50 = 2.02 lM); the corresponding thiazoline 3 was less
0
active also because of the missing Cl in R5 and therefore lacking
the deep penetration into the S3 pocket. Annelation by ring closure
of the methyl group to the central phenyl ring (6 and 7) did not re-
sult in an improvement of activities (both pKa = 8.3).
activity in the enzyme assay (IC50 = 0.137
lM) but high activity
in the cellular assay (IC50 = 0.010 M). Surprisingly, the quite basic
l
compound (pKa = 9.8) showed at least marginal activity of 29%
reduction of Ab40 at 30 mg/kg p.o. despite being a very good P-
gp substrate (hER 10.7). The same experiment in mice revealed a
weak brain penetration with high variability (exposure 4 h after
30 mg/kg p.o.: plasma: 2702 3987 ng/ml, brain: 363 494 ng/g,
brain/plasma ratio 0.13). Although 12 and 13 have quite similar
permeability (PAMPA assay: 12: peff = 6.12; 13: peff = 6.77) and sol-
ubility (LYSA assay: 12: 360 mg/l; 13: 370 mg/l) the more lipo-
The less basic aminohydantoin HG in compound 4 (pKa = 7.3)
has been described as a part of a potent BACE1 inhibitor12 but
when decorated as in 4, it proved to be only moderately active.
H2N
S
H2N
R5'
philic 2-amino-1,3-oxazine 13 (logD: 13: 0.68; 12: 0.26) bearing
0
N
H
N
an extra chlorine substituent in position R3 was found to be even
N
HG
R
N
more potent in vitro (BACE1 enzyme IC50 = 0.039
lM, cellular assay
R3'
IC50 = 0.001 M) and also in vivo (38% reduction of Ab40 at 30 mg/
l
O
MeO
kg p.o.; exposure 4 h after 30 mg/kg p.o.: plasma: 190 54 ng/ml,
brain: 306 44 ng/g, brain/plasma ratio: 0.99) – again despite
being a very good P-gp substrate (hER 14.5). A single dose PK in
mice for compound 13 (9.76 mg/kg p.o.) showed the following pro-
1
compounds 2-25
BACE1, enzyme
IC50 = 41.2 µM
file: tmax = 0.5 h, Cmax = 1835 ng/ml, t = 1.32 h, AUC = 4582 h ng/
½
Figure 1. HTS hit 1 and general structure of compounds described in this study.
ml, F = 111%, brain/plasma ratio 0.14. Determination of the protein
binding in mice revealed an 11% fraction of unbound compound.
This quite promising profile was accompanied by undesired activ-
ities, like, example, cytochrome P450 2D6 isoenzyme inhibition
(IC50 = 0.9
lM) and hERG inhibition (IC20 = 0.9 lM); both effects
were largely attributed to the high basicity of 13.
Another way of enlarging the ring size of the 2-aminooxazoline
2 by one CH2 group led to 3-amino-1,4-oxazine 1418 which was
S1
highly active in vitro (BACE1 enzyme IC50 = 0.031
lM, cellular as-
say IC50 = 0.003 M) but its extremely good P-gp substrate proper-
l
ties (hER 37.2) together with low exposure led to in vivo inactivity
(<10% reduction of Ab40 at 30 mg/kg p.o.; exposure 4 h after
30 mg/kg p.o.: plasma: 106 41 ng/ml, brain: 51 4 ng/g, brain/
D93
plasma ratio: 0.76). Addition of an extra chlorine substituent in
0
R3 gave compound 15, but no improvement of neither in vitro
S3
nor in vivo activity was observed.
A variation of the thiazine fragment by annelation of a cyclopro-
pyl ring led to compound 16 which was not a P-gp substrate (hER
1.1), but only showed moderate in vitro activity.
G291
We also prepared plain 6-ring amidines, but with attached
cyclopropyl groups to hopefully lower the pKa, which resulted in
spiro-compound 17 and bicycle 18 (both pKa >11). Both com-
pounds showed good in vitro activity but neither of them displayed
any in vivo effect (17: <5% reduction of Ab40 at 30 mg/kg p.o.;
Figure 2. HTS hit 1 (yellow) bound to the BACE1 binding site, some flap residues
have been removed for the sake of clarity (PDB code: 4bek). The protonated amidine
motif in the thiazine head group forms tight hydrogen bonds to the catalytic
aspartates D289 (not shown) and D93 (modeled amide compound in green).