S. J. Robinson et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 23 (2013) 4985–4989
4987
Table 1
The IC50 values for the inhibition of recombinant hMAO-A and hMAO-B by furanochalcone derivatives 5a–r
O
R1
R2
R1
R2
IC50
(l
M)a
SIb
MAO-A
MAO-B
5a
5b
5c
5d
5e
5f
5g
5h
5i
5j
5k
5l
5m
5n
5o
5p
5q
5r
3-Cl-phenyl
3-Cl-phenyl
3-OMe-phenyl
3-Cl-phenyl
4-Cl-phenyl
3-Br-phenyl
4-Br-phenyl
3-F-phenyl
Phenyl
2-Furyl
2-Furyl
No inhibitionc
21.1 3.42
19.2 4.21
18.0 5.46
40.9 46.6
15.0 0.342
85.7 8.13
24.0 0.588
18.6 6.17
1.95 0.025
83.7 10.3
31.8 33.0
No inhibitionc
59.5 7.01
28.6 5.03
30.2 3.63
41.8 3.11
61.6 5.35
0.529 0.034
2.10 0.142
3.20 0.366
0.490 0.064
0.616 0.047
0.449 0.048
0.707 0.122
0.619 0.060
0.924 0.197
0.200 0.049
0.288 0.057
0.275 0.038
2.79 0.835
0.344 0.062
0.174 0.033
0.206 0.091
7.67 0.688
0.543 0.047
—
10
6
53
66
33
121
39
20
5-Me-2-furanyl
5-Me-2-furanyl
5-Me-2-furanyl
5-Me-2-furanyl
5-Me-2-furanyl
5-Me-2-furanyl
5-Me-2-furanyl
5-Me-2-furanyl
5-Me-2-furanyl
5-Me-2-furanyl
3-Cl-phenyl
3-Cl-phenyl
3-Cl-phenyl
4-F-phenyl
4-F-phenyl
3-Br-4-F-phenyl
3-CF3-phenyl
4-CF3-phenyl
3-OMe-phenyl
5-Me-2-furanyl
5-Cl-2-furanyl
5-Br-2-furanyl
2-Furyl
10
290
116
—
173
164
147
5
5-Br-2-furanyl
4-F-phenyl
113
a
b
c
All values are expressed as the mean SD of triplicate determinations.
The selectivity index is the selectivity for the MAO-B isoform and is given as the ratio of IC50(MAO-A)/IC50(MAO-B).
No significant inhibition observed at a maximal tested concentration of 100 M.
l
vious studies which reported that chalcones are, in general, MAO-B
selective inhibitors.28,32 The selectivity of the chalcones for MAO-B
is exemplified by compound 5k, which is 290-fold more potent as
an inhibitor of MAO-B than of MAO-A, and compounds 5a and 5m,
which exhibited no inhibition of MAO-A at the highest concentra-
withdrawing group in the meta position of the phenyl ring gener-
ally appears to yield more potent MAO-B inhibitors than substitu-
tion in the para position (e.g., 5d vs 5e; 5f vs 5g and 5h vs 5i).
However, the two trifluoromethyl substituted derivatives, 5k and
5l, exhibited very similar MAO-B inhibitory activities
tion tested (100
l
M). Of the 18 furanochalcones evaluated in this
(IC50 = 0.288
electron withdrawing substituents in both the meta and para posi-
tions (5j, IC50 = 0.200 M) resulted in improved MAO-B inhibitory
activity compared to the monosubstituted homologues, 5i
(IC50 = 0.924 M) and 5f (IC50 = 0.449 M), but caused a decrease
in MAO-A/B selectivity.
Interestingly, when the positions of the furan and phenyl rings
were interchanged, for example, 5n (IC50 = 0.344 M) versus 5d
(IC50 = 0.490 M), comparable MAO-B inhibitory activities were
obtained, although 5n, with the phenyl group in the A-ring posi-
tion, yielded slightly more potent MAO-B inhibition. Substitution
on the furan ring with an electron withdrawing group (chlorine
and bromine), further led to improved MAO-B inhibitory activity,
lM and 0.275 lM, respectively). Incorporating two
study, fourteen compounds exhibited promising MAO-B inhibitory
activities, with IC50 values in the submicromolar range. Compound
5o proved to be the most potent MAO-B inhibitor with an IC50 va-
l
lue of 0.174
lM.
l
l
Some structure–activity relationships could be derived for the
MAO-B inhibitory activities of this series of furanochalcones. For
example, to compare the effects of furan, phenyl and methylfuran
substitution on MAO-B inhibition potency, the activities of com-
pounds 5a, 5b and 5d, as well as 5c and 5m were compared. For
compounds 5a and 5d, similar MAO-B inhibitory potencies were
obtained (although 5a exhibited higher selectivity for MAO-B).
These are the phenyl (5a) and methylfuran (5d) substituted deriv-
atives. The furan substituted derivative (5b) was approximately
four-fold weaker as an inhibitor of MAO-B than 5a and 5d. A sim-
ilar trend was also observed for the methoxy derivatives 5c
l
l
for example, compounds 5o (IC50 = 0.174
lM) and 5p
(IC50 = 0.206 M) versus 5n (IC50 = 0.344 M). Considering these
l
l
results, both steric and electronic effects appear to affect the
(IC50 = 3.20 lM) and 5m (IC50 = 2.79 lM), as furan substitution
MAO-B inhibitory properties of these compounds.
(5c) also yielded a compound with lower MAO-B inhibitory activity
(although the effect was not as pronounced). The notion that the
unsubstituted furyl moiety is less suitable for potent MAO-B inhi-
bition is further supported by the observation that the two weakest
MAO-B inhibitors (5q and 5c), among the chalcones examined,
possess the unsubstituted furyl moiety. This suggests that substi-
tution of the furan ring is required to obtain reasonable MAO-B
inhibitory activity.
The results further show that the combination of a furan or
methylfuran moiety (as the A-ring) with a phenyl moiety (as the
B-ring) substituted with electron withdrawing groups such as
chlorine, bromine, fluorine and trifluoromethyl groups (e.g., 5b,
5d–l) results in better MAO-B inhibitory activity than obtained
with substituting the phenyl ring with the electron donating meth-
oxy (OCH3) group (e.g., 5c and 5m). Substitution of the electron
Kinetic analyses for the inhibition of MAO-B, using kynuramine
as substrate, were carried out for the most potent inhibitor, 5o, as
well as for a less potent compound, 5d. The purpose with these
experiments was to determine the mode of MAO-B inhibition
exhibited by the furanochalcones. A set of Lineweaver–Burke plots
were constructed for each of the test furanochalcones, by measur-
ing the MAO-B catalytic activities at four different substrate
(kynuramine) concentrations, in the absence and presence of three
different concentrations of the test inhibitor. These results are
shown in Figure 4 and indicate that these compounds exhibit com-
petitive inhibition against kynuramine, as the double reciprocal
plots are linear and each set has a common y-intercept. From the
replots of the slopes of the Lineweaver–Burk plots versus inhibitor
concentration, Ki values of 0.294 and 0.144
5d and 5o, respectively.
lM were estimated for