Communication
modeling suggested that Watson–Crick-like base pairs to both
A and T were achievable, we hypothesized that the anomalous
behavior observed in standard Tm analysis may have been due
to partial protonation of N9 (Scheme 1, purple) at physiological
pH (pKa was calculated to be ca. 7.5), leading to a dynamically
equilibrating mixture of standard base-pairing interactions
with the free base and pseudo-base-pairing interactions with
a cationic (protonated) form (not shown).
Because further synthetic elaborations of heterocycles capa-
ble of acting as Janus-AT nucleosides are needed to probe un-
natural base-pairing interactions, we expanded this work to in-
clude a second-generation Janus-AT nucleotide, in which the
inclusion of an endocyclic nitrogen would render the heterocy-
cle considerably less basic, thereby minimizing the potential
for protonation to a cationic species capable of mispairing.
N
Therefore, the optimized structure, referred to as JAT, differs by
substitution of the C7ÀH group by a nitrogen atom to signifi-
cantly lower the pKa of the conjugate acid of N9, as suggested
by empirical calculation (Scheme 1, orange).[7,8] This would
more closely mimic the structure of a diaminopurine to pro-
vide an additional hydrogen bond. Finally, we substituted the
canonical deoxyribose with a cyclopentane analogue to pre-
clude potential depurination-like elimination, enhance associa-
tion DNA, and increase nuclease stability.[9] With these aims in
mind, synthetic design necessitated a new synthetic approach
that has never been elaborated for this Janus-AT nucleoside
analogue. Hereafter, we refer to the T-face and A-face by analo-
gy with their base-pairing behavior (the T-face binds to A, and
vice versa) as we report preliminary biophysical data, whereby
we conclude that this new heterocycle has improved proper-
ties in terms of recognizing either a complementary A or T.
N
Figure 1. Geometries of the N-methylated JAT-A and NJAT-T base pairs ob-
tained by BP86/TZ2P DFT calculations. Carbon in grey, hydrogen in white, ni-
trogen in blue, oxygen in red, and computed hydrogen bonds as purple
dashes. Bases are quasi co-planar, with acceptor-/donor-group distance con-
sistent with Watson–Crick hydrogen bonding.
N
mary amines. The potential of base pairing by JAT with T or A
is thus supported by 1) the compatibility of electrostatic po-
tentials for hydrogen bonding; 2) the electron-density localiza-
tion; 3) the deformation of the NÀH and C=O bonds involved
in hydrogen bonding; 4) the stabilization observed for the
complexes; and 5) the quasi co-planarity of the bases. To test
N
To gauge the capability of the JAT for base pairing with A or
N
T, we conducted BP86/TZ2P DFT geometry optimization on the
these in silico predictions, we tackled the synthesis of the JAT
nucleotide and its corresponding phosphoramidite that ena-
N-methylated structures of A, T, and NJAT bases,[10] and their cor-
N
N
N
responding base pairs.[6,11] The JAT-A and JAT-T complex geo-
metries feature quasi co-planar bases (10–158 between the
planes defined by the interacting cycles, Figure 1), and electron
densities before and after binding appear compatible with hy-
drogen bonding (Figures S1 and S2 in the Supporting Informa-
tion). Interestingly, the intramolecular N10ÀH···O6 hydrogen
bled its incorporation into a JAT-modified oligonucleotide.
Janus-type nucleotides typically have very low solubility in
organic solvents, which can impede the solid-phase synthesis
of modified oligonucleotides.[12] Moreover, JAT heterocycles
proved refractory to standard acylation or phthaloylation
under several conditions (data not shown) that otherwise
would have afforded a protected heterocycle with increased
solubility that would undergo normal deprotection with am-
monia. In light of this, we opted for the synthesis of a sulfone-
masked Janus-AT heterocycle that ultimately provided a phos-
phoramidite of much greater solubility, owing to a disrupted
hydrogen-bonding pattern, hence avoiding self-aggregation
(see below). The other advantage of such a target compound
is that upon global deprotection following solid-phase oligo-
nucleotide synthesis, the sulfone is converted to the desired
exocylic amine by nucleophilic displacement.[6] Initially, we in-
vestigated the feasibility of a “west/east” disconnection analo-
gous to the one we used for the JAT nucleotide, that is, in
which the T-face is elaborated first followed by closure of the
A-face (Scheme S1 in the Supporting Information). The key in-
termediate 3 was prepared by condensation of carbamate
1 with the carbocyclic deoxyribose analogue 2, by following
a protocol that we and others reported previously.[9b,12] Un-
N
bond observed for the isolated JAT is disrupted upon binding
with A and, to a lesser extent, T, consistent with the change in
electron density as a consequence of intermolecular hydrogen
bonding. Hydrogen bond donor/acceptor-atom distances
(Table S1 in the Supporting Information), as well as the bind-
ing-induced deformations of the NÀH and C=O bonds involved
in hydrogen bonding only (Tables S2 and S3 in the Supporting
Information), are consistent with extant hydrogen-bonding in-
teractions. Notably, donor/acceptor distances of the A-face, but
not of the T-face, are globally shorter than previously found for
JAT, which is likely due to the inclusion of the ring nitrogen of
this heterocycle. Finally, the complexes lie in the same energy
range as an AT base pair, suggesting efficient hydrogen bond-
ing (Table S4 in the Supporting Information). Notably, G or C
N
bases cannot form co-planar complexes with either face of JAT,
most likely because of important electronic repulsion due to
electron-rich oxygen atoms and steric constraints due to pri-
Chem. Eur. J. 2014, 20, 1495 – 1499
1496
ꢂ 2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim