Y. Zhang et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. 22 (2014) 2992–2997
2993
Considering the success of this effort, it was hypothesized that trun-
cated analogs that eliminated the cleavage sites could provide
improved templates for analog design.
Deletion of Phe-13 (2) caused ꢀ50-fold decrease in activity
(EC50 = 19.8 nM) while deletion of Pro-12 (3) did not cause any fur-
ther reduction in agonist potency (EC50 = 19.2 nM), illustrating an
important role of Phe-13 for agonist potency. These data agree
with previous alanine scanning mutagenesis data demonstrating
that [Glu-1, Ala-13] apelin-13 has pEC50 of 7.08 0.19 using a sim-
ilar calcium mobilization assay.13 Further truncation of apelin-13
by removal of Met-11 (4) decreased activity by >2500-fold com-
pared to apelin-13. Truncations of Pro-10 (5), Gly-9 (6), Lys-8 (7),
and His-7 (8) did not provide analogs with activity as either ago-
nists or antagonists. This demonstrated that peptides truncated
from the C-terminal beyond Met-11 had significantly reduced
activity and suggested that either the overall architecture of the
peptide was being disrupted due to a lack of residues to stabilize
a particular ensemble of secondary structures or that the amino
acid side chains or backbone atoms of C-terminal residues were
participating in important receptor interactions.
C-terminal truncation studies provided 3 (apelin-13, 1–11) as
the shortest active fragment of the parent peptide. Our studies
indicated that pyroglutamate or glutamine in position 1 on ape-
lin-13 did not play a significant role in determining either agonist
potency or efficacy (Table 1). Therefore, Apelin-13 (N-acetyl 2–
11-amide) 9 was tested in which the N-terminal glutamine was
removed from 3 and capped with acetic acid (Table 2). Interest-
ingly, peptide 9 demonstrated a ꢀ5-fold enhancement in agonist
potency over 3, with an EC50 of 4.4 nM. Since previous studies also
indicated that the RPRL motif in apelin-13 was critical for agonist
potency, it was concluded that the 10-mer (9) was the smallest
contiguous fragment that could be obtained from truncating
apelin-13. Confirmation of this hypothesis by mutating Arg-2 to
Ala-2 resulted in peptide 13 that had significantly reduced potency
(EC50 = 1383 nM). Once it was determined that 9 was the shortest
fragment that retained agonist potency, contributions of each side-
chain to secondary structure stabilization and receptor potency
were evaluated.
Substitution of Met-11 with hydrophobic residues like Phe (10,
EC50 = 4.7 nM) or Leu (12 EC50 = 1.9 nM) provided peptides with
potent agonist activity. However, a reduction in steric volume
through substitution with Val provided 11 with an EC50 of
691 nM and Emax ꢀ63%, indicating that hydrophobic volume was
playing a role in both receptor function and potency at position
11 consistent with past studies.9 The calculated volume of Met,
Leu, Phe, and Val residues are: 92.9 Å3, 92.5 Å3, 114 Å3, and
87.3 Å3 respectively suggesting a steric volume threshold must
be exceeded at this site to effectively interact with the APJ recep-
tor. Substitutions at Gly-9 were not conducted at this time and
could form the basis of future interrogation of the effect of hydro-
phobic volume at this position in conjugation with other changes.
Identification of peptide 12 (EC50 = 1.9 nM) suggested that sub-
stitution of Leu in position 11 for Met would provide a more chem-
ically tractable and metabolically stable residue to further pursue
SAR and in vitro studies (Table 2). Previous studies indicated a
limited role for the side-chains of Ser-6 and His-7 in [Glu-1]-
apelin-13.13 Substitution of Ser-6 and His-7 with Ala in the shorter
10-mer (12) resulted in peptide 14 having an EC50 of 1.1 nM and a
max efficacy of 104% confirming the limited role of Ser-6 and His-7
for APJ activation or secondary structural stabilization.
One of the primary goals for probe development throughout
this study was to limit the total number of amino acids and flexible
side-chains so that key receptor interactions could be identified
and a more comprehensive pharmacophore defined. In support of
this strategy, Ala was substituted for Pro-3 (15) causing a 16-fold
reduction in potency compared to 12, supporting the probable role
of Pro-3 in orienting the secondary structure of the RPRL motif.
Replacement of Arg-4 (16), Leu-5 (17) Lys-8 (18), and Pro-10 (19)
with Ala resulted in a 5-fold, 492-fold, 335-fold, and 124-fold
A comprehensive pharmacophore for apelin and its proteolytic
fragments has not yet emerged although there have been recent
advances. Conformational preferences of apelin-17 have been
studied using NMR at various temperatures and these studies indi-
cate that the fragment Arg-6 to Leu-9 (RPRL sequence in apelin-13)
contains a highly structured backbone and has an increased pro-
pensity to form b-turns.10 It is well recognized that peptide turn
motifs often correlate with biological activity for a diverse set of
GPCR receptors. Macaluso and co-workers have examined the role
of turn motifs in APJ receptor antagonists by analyzing apelin
(aqueous solution) molecular dynamics trajectories. In doing so,
they described a possible role for these motifs in the RPRL region
of apelin-13.11 This effort produced di-RPRL two-ring antagonists
with a high turn character in each of the cyclized-CRPRLC-rings
with intervening spacers resulting in a purported antagonist with
moderate binding affinity.12
The translation of features found in large peptides to small
molecule peptidomimetics remains a significant challenge. This is
because identification of the bioactive secondary structure or shape
of the backbone and the requisite three-dimensional display of key
amino acid side-chains is often uncertain from both experimental
and computational perspectives. One of the goals of this study
was the identification of analogs that could provide additional
SAR information for apelin-13 analogs and suggest sites that were
either altering the secondary structure of the modified peptide, or
were disrupting key ligand-receptor interactions. Such a paradigm
would be of value for ultimately transitioning from peptidergic
ligands towards small molecule analogs for the APJ receptor.
In order to improve the probability of successfully transitioning
from a peptide core to a small molecule template, use of C- and or
N-terminal truncations can assist with identification of the small-
est bioactive core. Unfortunately, this only provides information
for activity of key peptide structural features that are present in
a small fragment of contiguous residues. Rather, key determinants
of activation might also be present in non-contiguous strings of
early (N-terminal) and late (C-terminal) chain residues requiring
a thorough experimental dissection of the larger peptide fragment.
In this study we focused on identifying the smallest active frag-
ment of apelin-13 that avoids the ACE2 cleavage site with the goal
of understanding SAR on the truncated analogs. This was initially
accomplished by producing a number of truncated apelin peptides
and assessment of their potency using a functional assay for APJ.
Once the smallest peptide with reasonable potency was identified,
a series of peptides with substitutions at Arg-2, Arg-4, Lys-8, and
combinations thereof were produced and functionally evaluated.
2. Results and discussion
2.1. Structure–activity relationships
Systematic truncation studies of apelin-13 have been limited
with only two truncated peptides previously produced and studied
by Murza et al.9 It was further reported that cleavage of apelin-13 at
either position 5 or 8 resulted in inactive fragments of apelin-13.13
Both N-acetyl-apelin-13 (8–13) and N-acetyl-apelin-13 (5–13)
displayed pEC50 values of <4.5 M.13 Thus, we focused on the impor-
tance of amino acids 6–13 on apelin-13 because evidence already
suggested that the RPRL motif on apelin-13 prefers to form b-turns
and is critical for activity.10,12 As a result, seven analogs were
synthesized and tested by progressively deleting C-terminal resi-
dues using a functional calcium mobilization assay for APJ.13,14
The activities of these analogs are summarized in Table 1.