Journal of the American Chemical Society
Communication
a
lective protonation. We wondered if such radical intermediates
could subsequently add to an unsaturated double bond,
thereby affording the desired all-carbon quaternary stereo-
center α to azaarenes. In consideration of the high reactivity of
radicals in additions to imines,31,32 we were fascinated by the
possibility of an enantioselective [3 + 2] cycloaddition between
cyclopropylamines33−36 and α-branched 2-vinylazaarenes
under cooperative photoredox and chiral Brønsted acid
catalysis (Scheme 1b).5−7,18,20,31,32 The envisaged bimolecular
chemical transformation might involve a sequential two-step
radical process, namely, a radical conjugate addition of distonic
ions to alkenes and radical addition to iminium ions. The
method would provide the first access to the biologically
important highly enantioenriched molecular architectures that
are azaarene-substituted cyclopentanes featuring an all-carbon
quaternary stereocenter.37−40
The implementation of this reaction scenario will inarguably
face two significant challenges. (a) Chemoselectivity. Because
α-azaarene radicals can act as oxidants,6,18,41,42 the high steric
hindrance is likely to make the competitive single-electron
reduction and protonation more favorable. (b) Enantioselec-
tivity. Through H-bonding interactions with the N atom of
azaarenes, a chiral Brønsted acid catalyst can provide a chiral
environment for the formation of stereocenters by activating
the system for the radical conjugate addition.6,20 However, this
interaction will decrease the electron density on the α-azaarene
radical species, which disfavors the subsequent radical addition
to the iminium. To overcome this deactivation, the H-bonding
interaction tends to dissociate, which weakens the stereo-
controlling effect of the chiral Brønsted acid in the
simultaneous formation of the two stereocenters. In addition,
the highly enantioselective construction of all-carbon quater-
nary stereocenters is always a formidable challenge in radical
chemistry.32,43−45
Table 1. Optimization of the Reaction Conditions
b
c
d
entry
cat
solvent
T (°C) yield (%)
ee (%)
dr
1:1.5
>19:1
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
toluene
toluene
toluene
toluene
toluene
toluene
toluene
toluene
toluene
benzene
Et2O
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
25
−40
−60
33
76
79
78
74
77
78
79
79
78
60
63
76
80
80
83
N.A.
11
21
16
22
31
50
50
60
68
65
47
61
63
79
91
4a
4b
5a
5b
6a
6b
6c
6d
6d
6d
6d
6d
6d
6d
6d
>19:1
>19:1
>19:1
2:1
>19:1
>19:1
>19:1
15:1
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
15:1
THF
CPME
>19:1
>19:1
>19:1
>19:1
>19:1
e
m.s.
m.s.
m.s.
e
f
e
16
a
0.05 mmol scale: 1a:2a = 2.0:1, 1.0 mL solvent, irradiation distance
= 3.0 cm. Entries 1−14, t = 12 h. Entry 15, t = 48 h. Entry 16, t = 60
b
c
h. Yield of isolated product. Determined by HPLC analysis on a
d
e
chiral stationary phase. Determined by crude 1H NMR analysis. m.s.
f
= mixed solvent: Et2O/CPME/benzene = 1/1/1 (3.0 mL). 20 mol %
We began our investigation by selecting cyclopropylaniline
(1a) and 2-(1-phenylvinyl)pyridine (2a) as the model
substrates (Table 1). Our developed dicyanopyrazine-derived
chromophore (DPZ, for *DPZ, Et(S*/S•−) = +1.42 V vs SCE
in CH3CN)46 was chosen as the photoredox catalyst because
its excited state is theoretically able to perform the single-
electron oxidation of 1a (E1/2red = +0.92 V, +1.30 V vs SCE in
CH3CN). We first evaluated the reaction using 0.5 mol % DPZ
in toluene as the solvent at 25 °C with irradiation by a 3 W
blue LED (entry 1). It was found that racemic [3 + 2]
cycloaddition adduct 3a, the desired product, was obtained in a
33% yield with a 1:1.5 dr. The result shows an enantiocontrol
challenge due to the occurrence of the background reaction.
We then tested a series of (S)-BINOL-based chiral phosphoric
acids (CPAs), such as 4a−b (entries 2−3), and (S)-SPINOL-
based CPAs, such as 5a−b (entries 4−5) (for more details, see
enantioenriched product 3a with unsatisfactory ee values.
Importantly, the diastereoselectivity was reversed and became
excellent. The results indicate the suitability of chiral Brønsted
acids as catalysts. We wondered if the highly rigid and confined
C2-symmetric imidodiphosphoric acids could achieve better
enantioselectivity since they can provide extremely sterically
demanding chiral environments, geometrically restraining the
α-pyridine radical intermediate.47−50 In addition, the greater
distance between the catalytically active bifunctional acid/base
pair might increase the probability of interacting with the
iminium, which can weaken the negative influence of the
racemic background reaction by lowering the energy barrier to
of 6d was used, and irradiation distance = 6.0 cm. N.A. = not
available.
the radical addition. As such, we screened a range of
imidodiphosphoric acids based on the BINOL backbone,
such as 6a−d, with different substituents at the 3,3′-positions
(entries 6−9). To our delight, 3a could be obtained in 60% ee
with a > 19:1 dr when 6d was used (entry 9). A solvent
screening revealed that benzene, Et2O, and cyclopentyl methyl
ether (CPME) gave higher enantioselectivities (entries 10−
13). However, benzene has a higher freezing point (5.5 °C),
and neither Et2O nor CPME as the medium could provide
sufficient enantioselectivity even when the temperature was
decreased (see Table S1). This dilemma prompted us to test
mixed solvents involving on the most suitable solvent
(benzene) to decrease the freezing point. As a result, 3a was
obtained with a promising 63% ee when using the mixed Et2O/
CPME/benzene in a 1:1:1 ratio as the solvent (entry 14).
When the reaction was conducted at −40 °C, the ee of 3a was
improved to 78% (entry 15). Finally, 3a was obtained in 83%
yield with 91% ee and >19:1 dr after 60 h, when using 20 mol
% of 6d at −60 °C and increasing the distance to the radiation
source from 3.0 to 6.0 cm (entry 16). Several control
experiments supported that DPZ, chiral Brønsted acid, visible
light, and an oxygen-free environment were essential to this
With the optimal reaction conditions in hand, the scope of
this asymmetric [3 + 2] cycloaddition protocol was examined
(Table 2). A wide range of 2-(1-arylvinyl)pyridines (2)
B
J. Am. Chem. Soc. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX