1306
A. Ajaz et al.
tube. One important difference in MFP is the higher effective
concentration of reactants, which favours bimolecular reaction.
Brown first showed that pyrolysis of 2-ethynyltoluene gives
indene, an early example of the reaction named after him.[36]
Our computational models fully support the intermediacy of a
vinylidene intermediate in this reaction but also suggest a sec-
ond pathway through 1,5-sigmatropic shift and ring closure of
o-xylallene (5, Scheme 7). Formation of chrysene is clearly due
to initial formation of indene; dimerisation is a minor process in
FVP but becomes important at higher reactant concentration. It
is astonishing that the thermal dimerisation of indene has now
been known for 121 years![11,45] Computations reported here
support a radical dimerisation pathway and are consistent with
recent proposals by Lu and Mulholland based on related com-
bustion mechanisms.[54] We have shown for the first time that
minor isomers of chrysene, 13 and 14, may arise from a sec-
ondary isomerisation. Further work on arene isomerisations is in
progress. In this series, the pyrolysis of fluorene yields the
clearest evidence for radical dimerisation, with direct observa-
tion of the initial product 29.
spectroscopy and capillary GC. The product consisted of indan
(3 %), indene (76 %), naphthalene (2 %), and chrysene (19 %).
Small amounts of isomers benzo[a]anthracene (13) and benzo
[c]phenanthrene (14) were also seen by NMR spectroscopy.
MFP of 1,1-Bi-indene (17)
Bi-indene (17, 46 mg) and graphite (106 mg) were pyrolysed as
described above. Pyrolysis was carried out using dynamic power
(150 W) for 1 min. 1H NMR and capillary GC analysis showed
the products to be indene (4, 66 %), 3,30-bi-indene (22, 19 %),
naphthalene (12, 3 %), chrysene (7, 11 %), and indan (20,
,1 %). Spectroscopic data for bi-indene isomers 17 and 22
were in agreement with literature values.[55]
MFP of Indan (20)
Indan (20, 30 mg, 0.25 mmol) and graphite (153 mg) were mixed
and pyrolysed as above at 3008C (50 W) for 5 min. The crude
mixture was extracted with dichloromethane, filtered through
neutral alumina, and concentrated to yield 26 mg of oil. Capil-
lary GC analysis showed the following product distribution:
indene (4, 48 %), naphthalene (12, 4 %), chrysene (6, 8 %), and
starting material (30 %).
Experimental
Computational Methods
MFP of Chrysene (7)
All calculations were carried out with Gaussian or Spartan.
Structures were optimised and characterised by frequency
analysis at the B3LYP/6–311þG(d,p) or B3LYP/6–31G(d)
level of theory. Unscaled zero point corrections were applied
to DFT energies.
Caution: To minimise risks of explosion or ruptured reaction
vessels, microwave pyrolysis experiments should be carried out
using quartz reaction tubes and with nitrogen purging before
pyrolysis.
Chrysene (50 mg, 0.22 mmol) and graphite (250 mg) were
mixed by light grinding. Pyrolysis was carried out using fixed
power (300 W) for 3 min. The crude product mixture was fil-
tered through a silica plug using chloroform. 1H NMR integra-
tion indicated chrysene (6, 92 %), benzo[a]anthracene (13,
7.5 %), and benzo[c]phenanthrene (14, 0.5 %).
MFP of Fluorene (28)
Fluorene (50 mg) and graphite (70 mg) were mixed by light
grinding. Pyrolysis was carried out using fixed power (100 W)
for 1 min. The crude product mixture was filtered over a
silica plug using chloroform. 1H NMR analysis indicated
95.4 % of fluorene remaining, with 0.5 % bi-fluorene (29), 1 %
bi-fluorenylidene (30), 3 % dibenzo[g,p]chrysene (31), and
0.1 % rubicene (32). Longer runs showed decreasing pro-
portions of 30, and an increase in 31. All products 29–34
were identified by comparison to known spectra from the
literature.[65–68,71,72]
MFP of 2-Ethynyltoluene (2)
In a typical experiment, 2-ethynyltoluene (2, 30 mg, 0.26 mmol)
was mixed with graphite (50 mg, Aldrich synthetic graphite, 20
microns) by light grinding and then transferred to a quartz tube
(12 ꢀ 70 mm). A small plug of glass wool was placed above the
graphite. The quartz tube was inserted into a Pyrex microwave
reaction tube, purged with nitrogen, and sealed. The pyrolysis
was run in a CEM microwave reactor at 3008C (50 W) for 1–
5 min hold time. After cooling, the crude product mixture was
extracted with dichloromethane, filtered through a small plug of
neutral alumina, and carefully concentrated. Mass recovery was
,50 % in all cases. The product mixture was analysed by a
combination of capillary GC and 400 MHz 1H NMR spectros-
copy. In a typical run held for 2 min at maximum temperature,
GC analysis showed the following: starting alkyne (28 %), 2-
vinyl toluene (2 %), indan (2 %), indene (49 %), naphthalene
(4 %), and chrysene (11 %). NMR analysis further revealed
chrysene isomers benzo[a]anthracene (13, ,3 %) and benzo[c]
MFP of Bi-fluorene (29)
Bi-fluorene (30 mg) and graphite (100 mg) were mixed by light
grinding. Pyrolysis was carried out using fixed power (150 W)
for 30 s. The crude product mixture was filtered over a silica
plug using chloroform. 1H NMR intergration indicated 9 % bi-
fluorene (29), 43 % fluorene (28), 6 % bi-fluorenylidene (30),
34 % dibenzo[g,p]chrysene (31), 1 % rubicene (37), 5 % benz[e]
indeno[1,2,3-h,i]acephenanthrylene (33), and 2 % benz[p]
indeno[1,2,3,4-d,e,f,g]chrysene (34).
1
phenanthrene (14, ,1 %) as determined by H NMR analysis.
These were identified by comparison to known spectra in the
literature.[41,42]
MFP of Bi-fluorenylidene (30)
Bi-fluorenylidene (50 mg) and graphite (100 mg) were mixed by
light grinding. Pyrolysis was carried out using fixed power
(150 W) for 1 min. The crude product mixture was filtered over a
MFP of Indene (4)
Indene (4, 30 mg, 0.26 mmol) was mixed with graphite (150 mg)
by light grinding and pyrolysed as above at 3008C (50 W) for
5 min. After cooling, the crude product mixture was extracted
with dichloromethane, filtered through neutral alumina, and
1
silica plug using chloroform. H NMR integration indicated
74 % bi-fluoreneylidene (30) remaining, 1 % fluorene (28),
22 % dibenzo[g,p]chrysene (31), 0.5 % rubicene (32), 2 % 33,
and 0.5 % 34.
1
concentrated. The crude mixture was analysed by H NMR