C. Zhang et al. / Journal of Molecular Catalysis A: Chemical 383–384 (2014) 101–105
103
Table 1
Effect of different ILs on nitration of chlorobenzene.
Table 2
Effect of reaction time on nitration of chlorobenzene.
Ionic liquid
Isomerdistribution(%)
Para/ortho
Yield (%)
Reaction time/h
Isomerdistribution(%)
Para/ortho
Yield (%)
Ortho
Para
Ortho
Para
[CP]HSO4
[CP]pTSA
[CP]BSA
12.35
11.38
31.14
74.49
67.78
65.85
6.04
5.94
2.12
50.45
39.75
10.90
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
23.94
19.55
12.35
12.32
16.45
70.96
77.25
74.49
85.48
81.40
2.98
3.95
6.04
6.94
4.95
27.22
35.43
50.45
56.30
48.26
3. Results and discussion
than that of [CP]BSA, which may be due to the structure of p-
to benzenesulfonate anion. So the intermiscibility of [CP]pTSA is
3.1. Characterization and acidity determination of ionic liquids
The spectroscopic datas of ionic liquids synthesized above by
1HNMR and FT-IR are as follows.
+
better and the ability to carry NO2 into the organic phase is
1. [CP]BSA: 1H NMR(D2O), ı(ppm) 1.47–1.63(m, 6H), 2.33(t,
J = 5.3 Hz, 2H), 3.11(t, J = 4.5 Hz, 2H), 7.44(t, J = 7.7 Hz, 3H), 7.68(d,
J = 7.6 Hz, 2H). FT-IR(KBr, /cm−1), 3406(w), 2938(w), 2864(m),
1641(s), 1511(m), 1445(s), 1035(s), 761(s), 694(m), 497(w).
2. [CP]HSO4: 1H NMR(D2O), ı(ppm)1.34–1.54(m, 6H),
2.23–2.29(t, J = 5.7 Hz, 2H), 3.01–3.07(t, J = 5.0 Hz, 2H). FT-IR(KBr,
ꢀ/cm−1), 3101(w), 1919(m), 1603(s), 1422(s), 1056(s), 1012(s).
3H), 2.49(t, J = 3.6 Hz, 2H), 3.26(t, J = 4.6 Hz, 2H), 7.38(d, J = 7.9 Hz,
2H), 7.71(d, J = 7.9 Hz, 2H). FT-IR(KBr, ꢀ/cm−1), 2948(w), 1678(m),
1505(m), 1179(s), 1026(w), 821(m), 681(s), 566(s), 484(w).
The Brønsted acidic strength of these caprolactam-based ILs
to the same concentration solutions (0.32 mmol/L) of the above-
mentioned ILs dissolved in methanol. UV–vis spectrophotometer
was used to measure the absorption of Hammett indicator, and
the results were shown in Fig. 3. The curve a in Fig. 3 is the
absorption curve of the dimethyl yellow solution without ionic
liquid, which showed that the absorption of the unprotonated
form of dimethyl yellow only at a wavelength of 350–460 nm.
After adding the ionic liquid, the ionized H+ from ionic liquid
is combined with dimethyl yellow to form protonated structure,
then the absorption peak appears at 460–570 nm in the spec-
trum. For the same amount of the ionic liquid, the greater the
Brønsted acidic strength and more the ionized H+. If the protonated
structure is formed more with dimethyl yellow, the absorption
at 460–570 nm will become stronger while the absorption at
350–460 nm becomes weaker accordingly. The analysis results
show that the Brønsted acidic strength of the three ionic liquids
is in the order of [CP]HSO4 > [CP]pTSA > [CP]BSA.
stronger, which make it show higher catalytic activity. Further-
more, it can be seen from Table 1, the magnitudes of the para/ortho
selectivity are affected by the nature of the ILs. This suggests
that a correlation exists between the degree of para-selectivity
and the ability of electron-withdrawing substituent to induce an
electrostatic attraction between substrate and ILs, causing greater
hindrance at ortho-positions to such substituent [24,25]. For the
same substrate and the same cation in the three ILs, the electron-
withdrawing of anions generate great effect on the para-selectivity.
For [CP]HSO4 the effects were stronger, thus enhanced the elec-
trostatic attraction between chlorobenzene and the IL, causing a
greater hindrance at ortho-position. So it showed the best para-
selectivity. As described above, the para-selectivity of [CP]pTSA is
higher than that of [CP]BSA due to the higher polarity of [CP]pTSA,
which give it good affinity to chlorobenzene. Therefore, [CP]HSO4
was chosen as the catalyst for further study.
3.3. Effect of reaction time on nitration of chlorobenzene
optimized, effect of reaction time on the yield and para-selectivity
was first investigated. Taking caprolactam hydrosulfate ionic liquid
as catalyst, other reaction conditions were the same as the previous.
The results are showed in Table 2.
As known in Table 2, with the reaction time increases, the
yield and regioselectivity increases rapidly within 2.5 h. When reac-
tion time reaches to 2.5 h, the yield and the ratio of para/ortho
achieve the maximum, which indicates that nitration reaction
has almost been completed in 2.5 h. At the beginning, ortho-
nitrochlorobenzene is formed quickly. But with the reaction
proceeding, it is more beneficial to form para-nitrochlorobenzene.
This may be because the increasing conversion of chloroben-
zene leads to that the ratio of ionic liquid to chlorobenzene is
gradually increasing, which provides ionization atmosphere for
chlorobenzene and is helpful for its polarization. After the reac-
tion time is extended to 3 h, however, the yield decreases slightly
and para/ortho also significantly reduces. The result indicates that
with the extension of reaction time, the dinitro-products are prob-
ably formed. So 2.5 h should be chosen as the appropriate reaction
time.
3.2. Effect of different ILs on nitration of chlorobenzene
gate the influence of different anions on the reaction. The conditions
50 ◦C for 2 h. The results are listed in Table 1.
As shown in Table 1, the catalytic activities of the three ILs
are in the order of [CP]HSO4 > [CP]pTSA > [CP]BSA. According to
the literature reported [23], for Brønsted acidic ionic liquid, the
stronger the acidity is, the more hydrogen protons it can provide.
In nitric acid and acetic anhydride nitration system, nitronium
3.4. Effect of reaction temperature on nitration of chlorobenzene
conditions were the same as before, to examine the impact of the
reaction temperature on nitration of chlorobenzene. The results are
shown in Table 3.
It can be seen from Table 3, nitration of chlorobenzene is more
sensitive to temperature. The nitration is an endothermic reac-
tion, and below 40 ◦C the nitrification is not easy to carry out so
that the yield is low. With the reaction temperature increasing, the
+
NO2 dissociated from nitric acid attacked chlorobenzene, so as
to facilitate the formation of nitrochlorobenzene. The determina-
tion of acidity demonstrates that the acidity of [CP]HSO4 is the
strongest among the three ILs. [CP]HSO4 also can further provide
one proton as Brønsted acid to promote nitric acid to form active
agent nitronium ion favors to nitration reaction, so the yield is the
highest. Also the catalytic activity of [CP]pTSA is obviously higher