Evaluation Only. Created with Aspose.PDF. Copyright 2002-2021 Aspose Pty Ltd.
Full Papers
doi.org/10.1002/open.202000092
ChemistryOpen
are required in solution to rival the results obtained in gel
(Table 1, entry 1 vs. 2; entry 4 vs. 5) in terms of regioselectivity,
kinetics, conversion and yield. No reaction occurred in the
absence of either Ir-catalyst or blue light irradiation (Table 1,
entries 6–7).
(Table 3). Similarly to solution, different solvents in aerated gel
media also affects to some extent the d.r. The lowest
diastereoselectivity was found in DMSO (d.r.=83:17), while
toluene and methylene chloride afforded the highest selectivity
(d.r.=91:9). Ratios within this range were found for
cyclohexane, acetonitrile, DMF and acetone. It should be
emphasized that this behavior is not necessarily extrapolated to
other gelators and/or substrates. Overall, these results demon-
strate that photoredox reactions in supramolecular gel systems
may be modulated by changing the LMW gelator and/or the
solvent for a given substrate.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
With these results in hand, we focused our attention on the
influence of the gel medium on the diastereomeric ratio by
using different LMW gelators (G1–G5) and cinnamate 1a (R1 =
H) as model substrate (Table 2). Both the gelator concentration
and the solvent were modified in order to optimize the reaction
conditions in gel media. The results suggested that both
parameters are important and they should be evaluated
simultaneously during the optimization experiments of photo-
redox processes in gel. Thus, a good balance in terms of lower
gelation concentration, conversion and diastereoselectivity was
obtained with the gel systems increasing the diastereoselectiv-
ity from 87:13 in solution to 89:11 (entry 10) in stable gel
media. However, from Table 2 it is evident that depending on
the parameter of interest there is some flexibility within these
conditions.
Furthermore, due to the presence of substrates and catalyst
which do not take part of the supramolecular gel network, it
should be kept in mind that the minimum gelator concen-
tration suitable for the experiments does not necessarily
correspond to the critical gelation concentration (CGC), being
defined as the minimum gelator concentration required to form
a pure gel in a given solvent. In general, the incorporation of
external additives tends to tilt the metastable equilibrium of a
supramolecular gel towards the most stable thermodynamic
phase (e.g. crystallization, precipitation) over time.[13,15] Such a
reduced gel stability could be compensated, at least to a certain
extent, by increasing the gelator concentration. The effect of
the solvent on the d.r. 2:3 was assessed more in detail taking
substrate 1a (R1 =H) and gelator G1 as a model system
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
Applying the best reaction conditions found for 1a, i.e.
highest diastereoselectivity for systems in which a stable gel
can be formed, we evaluated the outcome of the photo-
dimerization for substrates 1b–1f in gel media (Table 4), which
had given poor selectivities in homogeneous solution.[28] For all
substrates the diastereoselectivity could be slightly increased
by carrying out the reactions in gel media rather than in the
respective solvent alone. In general, the use of gel media has a
greater effect in polar solvents like DMF or CH3CN on the
diastereoselectivity than in unpolar solvents (toluene), suggest-
ing a greater stabilization of diradical intermediate A in the
latter. For all substrates the diastereoselectivity could be
increased significantly by carrying out the reactions in a less
polar solvent (toluene) compared to previously used DMF,
suggesting a greater stabilization of the diradical intermediate
A in the first.[28] In comparison to that, gel media showed a
rather small effect on the diastereomeric outcome of the
reaction and tended to have a relatively greater impact in polar
solvents like DMF or CH3CN than in unpolar solvents (toluene).
In agreement with this rational, we found that the reactions
proceed efficiently on water, increasing the amount of the cis-
diastereomer, which is presumably the kinetically preferred one
(Table 5). The most dramatic result was obtained with sub-
strates 1b (R1 =CO2Me) and 1c (R1 =CN), for which the d.r. was
inverted in favor to the cis product 3 (β-diastereomer) (Table 5,
entries 4–5). Moreover, under these conditions the catalyst
loading could be efficiently decreased from 1.0 mol% to
0.02 mol% while maintaining the conversion �95% (Table 5,
entry 3). Surprisingly, although substrate 1e (R1 =NO2) was
poorly converted on water (11%) even after 72 h (Table 5,
entry 7), only the cis diastereomer 3 was obtained. In sharp
Table 2. Screening of solvents, gelators and gelator concentrations for the
[2+2]-cycloaddition of substrate 1a (R1 =H).[a]
Entry
Solvent
Gelator [gLÀ 1
]
Conv. [%][b]
d.r. (2/3)[b]
1
DMF
G1 (15)
G1 (15)
G1 (15)
G1 (30)
G2 (15)
G2 (15)
G3 (5)
G3 (10)
G3 (10)
G4 (5)
G4 (15)
G4 (10)
G4 (20)
G5 (15)
G5 (20)
G5 (20)
G5 (40)
100
100
100
100
100
46
100
100
–
85
100
63
95
88:12
87:13
93:7
88:12
88:12
88:12
88:12
87:13
–
89:11
86:14
89:11
89:11
86:14
88:12
91:9
2
CH3CN
Toluene
DMF
DMF
Toluene
DMF
3[c]
4
5
6
7
8
Table 3. Solvent screening for [2+2]-cycloaddition of 1a in gel made of
G1.[a]
DMF
9[d]
10
11[c]
12
13
14
15[c]
16[c]
17[c]
Toluene
Toluene
CH3CN
Toluene
Toluene
CH3CN
DMF
Entry
Solvent
Gelator
Conv. [%][b]
d.r. (2/3)[b]
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
DMSO
Cyclohexane
CH3CN
DMF
Acetone
Toluene
DCM
G1 (15)
G1 (20)
G1 (15)
G1 (15)
G1 (15)
G1 (20)
G1 (20)
72
100
99
100
100
100
100
83:17
88:12
89:11
88:12
91:9
96
89
84
49
Toluene
Toluene
93:7
91:9
91:9
[a] Reaction conditions: Cinnamate 1a (0.5 mmol), photocatalyst [Ir{dF(CF3)
ppy}2(dtb-bpy)]PF6 (1.0 mol%), solvent (1 mL), LED455, 24 h, RT, air.
Abbreviations: Conv.=conversion; d.r.=diastereomeric ratio (2=δ-dia-
stereomer; 3=β-diastereomer). [b] dDetermined by 1H NMR analysis of the
reaction crude. [c] Gel melted (unstable) [d] No gel formation.
[a] Reaction conditions: Cinnamate 1a (0.5 mmol), photocatalyst [Ir{dF(CF3)
ppy}2(dtb-bpy)]PF6 (1.0 mol%), dry solvent (1 mL), LED455, 24 h, RT, in air.
Abbreviations: Conv.=conversion; d.r.=diastereomeric ratio (2=δ-dia-
stereomer; 3=β-diastereomer); DCM=dichloromethane. [b] Determined
1
by H NMR analysis of the reaction crude.
ChemistryOpen 2020, 9, 1–9
3
© 2020 The Authors. Published by Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA
��
These are not the final page numbers!