Communications
oxalic acid were inefficient because neither bromo-substituted
nor unsaturated species were formed (Table S6).
2BrPA was formed with only 7% selectivity under otherwise
identical conditions.
Higher selectivity towards AA and 2 was obtained when the
reaction temperature was raised to 150 or 1758C with TBAB or
PPh4Br as bromide sources (Table S7 and Table 1, entries 4 and
5). Unfortunately, when the reaction was run at 1758C for 16 h,
the mass balance decreased to 60% (for both bromide sour-
ces), and when the reaction was run at 2008C, the mass bal-
ance dropped to 30% in TBAB or a mere 2% in PPh4Br. A ten-
tative explanation for the loss of mass balance may be the for-
mation of polyacrylates under these harsh conditions. Further-
more, TBAB partially decomposes at these higher tempera-
tures, as indicated by the observation of butyl bromide in the
reaction mixture. The PPh4Br/sulfolane system is more suitable
for the use under harsher reaction conditions because of the
higher thermal stability of these species.
We hypothesized that bromopropionic acid itself can also be
used as a source of acid because it can eliminate HBr to afford
AA.[18] The rearrangement of lactide also occurred in the ab-
sence of a strong acid but with 2BrPA added at the beginning
of the reaction (Table S10, entries 1–3): when lactide
(0.69 mmol) and 2BrPA (0.35 mmol) were stirred in BrPPh4/
sulfolane for 16 h at 1508C, the resulting reaction mixture was
found to contain AA (0.54 mmol), 2 (0.31 mmol), and 2BrPA
(0.10 mmol). The compound 3BrPA could also be used
(Table S10, entries 4 and 5): a reaction of lactide (0.69 mmol)
and 3BrPA (0.35 mmol) in BrPPh4/sulfolane for 16 h at 1508C
resulted in
a
mixture containing AA (0.62 mmol),
2
(0.31 mmol), and 3BrPA (0.18 mmol).
Finally, oligo-LA and PLA were submitted to the PPh4Br/
sulfolane/HOMs reaction medium at 1508C for 16 h. Starting
from oligo-LA (100 mg), AA (23 mg) and 2 (26 mg) were ob-
tained. Additional signals in the acrylate region of the NMR
spectrum were attributed to the tri-ester 3 (comprising two LA
units and one acrylate unit, see Scheme 2 and Figure S2),
which was obtained in 11 mg yield (Table S11, entry 1). When
PLA (100 mg) was used as a starting material, AA (24 mg), 2
The rearrangement of lactide was monitored over 10 h at
1758C in the HOMs/PPh4Br/sulfolane reaction medium
(Figure 1 and Table S8). Under these conditions, lactide quickly
(26 mg) and
3 (16 mg) were obtained (Table 1, entry 9;
Table S11, entry 2). Besides pure commercial PLA, to show that
this transformation can be applied for the recycling of PLA, we
also used a piece of plastic cutlery (consisting of 67% PLA and
33% inert filler) from the university canteen. The results were
virtually identical to those obtained when bulk PLA was used
(Table S11, entry 3).
Mechanistic considerations
The various intermediates found in the reaction mixtures
helped us to devise a mechanism for the transformation of lac-
tide to AA, as shown in Scheme 3. The cyclic lactide ester is
first opened by a proton and a bromide ion to give 2-(2’-bro-
mopropanoyloxy)propanoic acid (1) (first nucleophilic substitu-
tion). Compound 1 then either eliminates HBr to afford 2-
(acryloyloxy)propanoic acid (2) (first elimination) or may react
with a second equivalent of HBr to yield two equivalents of
2BrPA. Compound 2 can also be hydrobrominated to afford AA
and 2BrPA (second nucleophilic substitution). Finally, 2BrPA
eliminates HBr to yield AA (second elimination reaction). The
presence of small amounts of 3BrPA in the reaction mixture
could be the result of the reversible addition of HBr to AA.
At high temperatures, secondary alkyl halides can be trans-
formed to alkenes through the E1 mechanism involving
a carbo-cationic intermediate. However, in the case of 2BrPA,
the involvement of such a carbo-cationic intermediate is not
likely owing to its a-position with respect to the carboxylic
acid group. A strict E2-type mechanism for this elimination
step is also not very probable owing to the extremely acidic re-
action medium. An E2C mechanism with bromide ions acting
as a weak base is more likely to be operative.[19] Alternatively,
an intramolecular carboxylic acid-assisted E1-type elimination
Figure 1. Rearrangement of lactide to acrylic acid at 1758C as a function of
time. Reaction conditions: lactide (0.69 mmol), HOMs (0.83 equiv), PPh4Br
(5 equiv), sulfolane. Lines are only given as a guide to the eye.
disappeared from the reaction mixture: 97% was consumed
within 2 h. The selectivity towards 2 reached a maximum after
2 h (50% selectivity at 94% conversion) and then decreased,
whereas the selectivity towards 2BrPA increased to 14% in the
first hour and then slowly decreased to reach 0% after 10 h.
The amount of 3BrPA reached a maximum at 4 h with 7% se-
lectivity and then remained stable until the end. The selectivity
towards AA increased continuously over the 10 h reaction time
to reach 58%. In the first few hours of the reaction, the overall
mass balance was initially quite good, but after 6 h it de-
creased significantly.
The chloride salt PPh4Cl can also be used for the reaction, al-
though the selectivity towards rearrangement products is
lower than when PPh4Br is used. Whereas AA and 2 were ob-
tained in 32 and 44% selectivity at full conversion in PPh4Br,
under otherwise identical conditions AA and 2 were obtained
in 11 and 29% selectivity at 86% conversion in PPh4Cl (see
Table S9). A significant amount of 2-chloropropionic acid
(2ClPA) was formed in the reaction (26% selectivity), whereas
ChemSusChem 2017, 10, 1 – 6
3
ꢁ 2017 The Authors. Published by Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
&
These are not the final page numbers! ÞÞ