CHEMMEDCHEM
COMMUNICATIONS
DOI: 10.1002/cmdc.201300042
Selective Bisubstrate Inhibitors with Sub-nanomolar
Affinity for Protein Kinase Pim-1
Ramesh Ekambaram,[a] Erki Enkvist,[a] Angela Vaasa,[a] Marje Kasari,[a] Gerda Raidaru,[a]
Stefan Knapp,[b] and Asko Uri*[a]
The human provirus integration site for Moloney murine leuke-
mia virus (Pim) protein kinase (PK) family includes three consti-
tutively active serine/threonine kinases: Pim-1–3. At the amino
acid level, Pim-2 and Pim-3 show 61% and 71% identity to
Pim-1, respectively.[1] Pim kinases participate in several normal
biological processes, including cell survival, proliferation, differ-
entiation, and apoptosis.[2] Elevated expression levels of Pim-
1 and Pim-2 have been observed in hematologic malignancies
and prostate cancer, and increased Pim-3 expression has been
detected in some solid tumors.[2d] These findings suggest that
Pim kinases are the products of proto-oncogenes, which could
play an important role in the initiation and progression of
human cancer. The first small-molecule inhibitor of Pim-1 stud-
ied in the clinic was the imidazo[1,2-b]pyridazine SGI-1776,[2f]
used to treat refractory prostate cancer and relapsed/refractory
non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma; SGI-1776 was withdrawn from clini-
cal development because of dose-limiting toxicity through car-
diac QTc interval prolongation.[2e] Despite this, structurally di-
verse small-molecule inhibitors have continued to be devel-
oped for regulation of Pim kinase activity both as research
tools and drug candidates.[2e,3,4] More than 400 small-molecular
Pim-1 inhibitors with Ki (IC50) values <10 mm have been regis-
tered in the ChEMBL database.[3]
Several research groups,[8] including our own,[9] have previ-
ously used the bisubstrate approach for development of
highly potent inhibitors of various PKs. Bisubstrate inhibitors
incorporate two conjugated fragments, each targeted to the
binding site of a distinct substrate.[10] Chemically, the inhibitors
are conjugates of adenosine derivatives (or adenosine ana-
logues) and d-arginine-rich peptides (ARCs).[9a] Several ARCs
possess very high affinities for PKs—Kd values in the low pico-
molar range have been reported for protein kinase A (PKA)[11]
and Rho-associated protein kinase (ROCK)[12]—and high biolog-
ical and chemical stability.[9] ARCs labeled with fluorescent dyes
have revealed good cell-plasma-membrane-penetrative proper-
ties that have enabled their application for measurement of
kinase activity in living cells.[13] Although ARCs are generally
group-selective inhibitors that bind with high affinity to many
basophilic PKs (mostly belonging to the AGC group of PKs), in
the course of structure–activity relationship studies, structural
elements of ARCs were established[9c] that affected the kinase-
selectivity profile of the inhibitors.
In a recent paper,[14] we showed that, with a rational selec-
tion of the conjugate moieties targeted to distinct substrate
binding pockets of the PK, the bisubstrate approach can be
used for construction of fairly selective inhibitors for PKs. In
this way, an inhibitor with sub-nanomolar affinity and remark-
able selectivity was developed for casein kinase 2 (CK2), an
acidophilic PK that catalyzes phosphorylation of protein sub-
strates rich in acidic amino acid residues aspartic acid and glu-
tamic acid in close proximity to the phosphoryl acceptor site.
In the present study, we have developed selective and
potent bisubstrate inhibitors for Pim kinases. Since 2005, nu-
merous crystal structures of ligand–Pim-1 complexes have
pointed to the uniqueness of hydrogen-bond networks and
hydrophobic interactions important for binding of the co-sub-
strate ATP (and its analogues) and inhibitors to Pim kinases.[15]
Most PKs form two hydrogen bonds with the adenine moiety
of ATP through residues in the hinge region, while Pim-
1 forms only one hydrogen bond, between the N6 atom of ad-
enine and the backbone carbonyl oxygen atom of the first
hinge residue (Glu121). Other kinases additionally form a hy-
drogen bond between the N1 atom of adenine and the back-
bone NH of the third hinge residue. The proline residue at po-
sition 123 in Pim-1 precludes the kinase from this capability.[3]
In the present study, this distinctness in the protein structure
was used for the construction of selective bisubstrate inhibi-
tors, ARC(PIM) compounds. We demonstrate that Pim selectivi-
ty and inhibitory potency of the ATP-competitive compounds
can be substantially improved by their conjugation with pep-
Most reported Pim inhibitors target the ATP binding site of
the enzymes. Some of these compounds have shown rather fa-
vorable Pim kinase inhibition profiles, at least in a small panel
of PKs.[5] Two recent reports have shown that peptides binding
to the substrate-protein binding domain of Pim-1 might also
possess nanomolar inhibitory potency and therefore be of in-
terest for biological research or even drug development ef-
forts.[6] The crystal structures have been solved of Pim-1 bound
to a high-affinity peptide substrate in complex with both an
ATP analogue (phosphoaminophosphonic acid-adenylate ester;
AMP-PNP) and a bisindolylmaleimide-based kinase inhibitor,[7]
that aids construction of protein-substrate-competitive inhibi-
tors.
[a] Dr. R. Ekambaram, Dr. E. Enkvist, Dr. A. Vaasa, Dr. M. Kasari, G. Raidaru,
Dr. A. Uri
Institute of Chemistry, University of Tartu
14A Ravila St., 50411 Tartu (Estonia)
[b] Prof. S. Knapp
Nuffield Department of Clinical Medicine
Structural Genomics Consortium, University of Oxford
Roosevelt Drive, Oxford OX3 7DQ (UK)
Supporting information for this article is available on the WWW under
ꢀ 2013 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
ChemMedChem 2013, 8, 909 – 909 909