Journal of the American Chemical Society
Article
alkanes to radical 10 thermodynamically favorable. The second-
order rate constant for the abstraction of a hydrogen atom from
adamantane is not a suitable substrate for this experiment (see
the Supporting Information).
2
by 4-methoxybenzoyloxy radical (14) was measured to be on
The reaction of peroxide 15 with alkane 16 in the presence of
5
−1 −1
the order of 10 M s , whereas the first-order rate constant for
2 equiv of CBr furnished 17a in 10.4% yield and 17b in 5.5%
4
4
5
−1 44
decarboxylation of 14 was measured to be 10 −10 s . Given
the similarity between the structures of m-chloro- and p-
methoxy-substituted benzoyloxy radicals 10 and 14, it is likely
that the rate constants for abstraction of a hydrogen atom from
3
an unactivated C(sp )−H bond by these two radicals are similar
and that the rate of abstraction of a hydrogen atom by 10 would
be similar to that of the decarboxylation. This prediction based
on the literature values fits with the observed oxidation process
and formation of chlorobenzene.
However, reliable data on the selectivity of aroyloxy radical 10
for the abstraction of hydrogen atoms from alkanes were needed
to assess more precisely whether this radical cleaves the C−H
bonds in Ni-catalyzed oxidations. Thus, we generated radical 10
in situ via the thermal decomposition of bis(3-chlorobenzoyl)-
peroxide (15), measured its selectivity for hydrogen-atom
abstraction of a model alkane, 2,2,4,4-tetramethylpentane (16),
and compared the selectivity of the metal-free bromination of 16
Figure 6. Illustration of the GC experiment for the detection of alkyl
hydroperoxide intermediates designed by Shul’pin.
The Ni-catalyzed bromination of 16 by mCPBA formed 17a in
35.2% yield and 17b in 17.9% yield, corresponding to a 2°/1°
ratio of 2.0 ± 0.2 (Figure 6B). The similarity between the
selectivity of the bromination reactions with diaroyl peroxide 15
and the process with the nickel complex and mCPBA strongly
suggests that radical 10 is the species that cleaves the C−H bond
in the catalytic system.
To assess further our proposal that the aroyloxy radical
derived from the aromatic peracid is the species that cleaves the
C−H bond in the catalytic reaction, we conducted reactions
with a different peracid. We envisioned that the selectivity for
the Ni-catalyzed bromination of 16 would be different for
reactions with aromatic peracids bearing different substituents
than the chloride in mCPBA. Indeed, the Ni-catalyzed
bromination of 16 by 3,5-bis(trifluoromethyl)perbenzoic acid
(
18) furnished 17a in 14.7% yield and 17b in 13.4% yield,
corresponding to a 2°/1° ratio of 1.1 ± 0.1 (Figure 6C). This
ratio is lower than those from reactions involving m-
chlorobenzoyloxy radical 10 (Figure 6A,B) and further
corroborates our hypothesis that aroyloxy radicals derived
from aromatic peracids cleave the C−H bonds of alkanes in the
catalytic system.
5. The C−O Bond Formation Step. Having identified the
free radical responsible for C−H bond cleavage, we investigated
the step that forms the C−O bond. Three possible pathways can
lead to the formation of a C−O bond from the carbon-centered
radical generated by hydrogen-atom abstraction of the alkane by
Figure 5. Bromination of alkane 16 by (A) peroxide 15, (B) mCPBA
and Ni complex 1a, and (C) peracid 18 and Ni complex 1a. Conditions:
aroyloxy radical 10 (Scheme 2): (1) trapping by O to generate
(
A) 0.0625 mmol of 15, 10 equiv of 16, 4 equiv of CBr , DCM (0.0625
2
4
an alkylperoxy radical, which subsequently decomposes to form
alcohol and ketone products (eq 2−1); (2) trapping by a
putative nickel(III) hydroxide species, which would be
generated by the oxidation of the Ni(II) complex by mCPBA,
to form the alcohol product and a Ni(II) species (eq 2−2); (3)
trapping by mCPBA to afford the alcohol product and radical 10
(eq 2−3).
M), 80 °C under N ; (B) 0.125 mmol of mCPBA, 5 equiv of 16, 2 equiv
2
of CBr , 0.1 mol % 1a, DCM (0.125 M), 50 °C under N . (C) 0.125
4
2
mmol of 18, 5 equiv of 16, 2 equiv of CBr , 1 mol % 1a, DCM (0.125
4
a
b
M), 50 °C under N . Average of eight repeated experiments. Average
2
of three repeated experiments.
reactions were conducted in the presence of CBr , which is well-
4
known to trap carbon-centered radicals rapidly. In this case, the
distribution of products 17a and 17b from bromination at the
secondary and primary C−H bonds accurately reflects the
selectivity in the hydrogen-atom transfer step. The model
substrate 16 was chosen because radicals derived from CBr4,
The decomposition of alkylperoxy radicals usually forms the
45
corresponding alcohol and ketone products in an ∼1:1 ratio,
whereas the Ni-catalyzed oxidation of 2 gave A/(K + E) ratios
between 3.1 and 3.5 (Table 1A). Furthermore, the yield and
selectivity of the catalytic oxidations of 2 and 3 under an
such as CBr ·, do not cleave the strong primary and secondary
atmosphere of N were similar to those of the reactions under
air. These straightforward observations suggest that the
3
2
C−H bonds in alkane 16 and, therefore, do not interfere with
the measurement of the selectivity of hydrogen-atom abstraction
by aroyloxy radical 10. The tertiary C−H bonds in adamantane,
formation of the C−O bond does not involve O and that the
2
steps in eq 2−1 are unlikely to be the major ones forming the C−
however, can be cleaved by these radicals derived from CBr , so
O bond in the Ni-catalyzed oxidations. Nonetheless, we decided
4
F
J. Am. Chem. Soc. XXXX, XXX, XXX−XXX