.
Angewandte
Communications
assigned as sodiated adducts of dimethoxybenzenemethanol
21) and of dimethoxybenzaldehyde dimethyl acetal (23) and
(
as the hydride abstraction product of dimethoxybenzyl
methyl ether (22), respectively, as verified by tandem MS
and exact mass measurement (see Figure S17 and Table S1 in
the Supporting Information). In agreement with the classical
benzenemethanol pathway, 3,4-dimethoxybenzaldehyde is
first hydrogenated to give dimethoxybenzenemethanol (m/z
1
1
91), then converted into dimethoxybenzyl methyl ether (m/z
81), and finally the dimethoxytoluene (m/z 151) product is
produced. However, this sequence does not explain the
appearance of dimethoxybenzaldehyde dimethyl acetal (m/z
2
35). The observed sodiated adduct ions of dimethoxyben-
zaldehyde dimethyl acetal suggest a second pathway of
hydrogenlysis, in which benzaldehyde acetal is an intermedi-
ate instead of benzenemethanol. In the recent publication by
Figure 3. Selective ion chronograms of the reagent 9, intermediates
1), (2), and (3) assigned (see text) as 11, 12, and 13, and product 10
in the Pd/C-catalyzed hydrogenolysis of 3,4-dimethoxybenzaldehyde
over the time range 0–130 min (the arrows indicate when the reagent
and excess Pd/C were added).
(
[
10a]
Hu and co-workers,
a similar benzylaldehyde acetal
intermediate was separated and confirmed. The authors
noted that when lower alcohols such as methanol (as in our
case) and ethanol were used as solvents, only the benzylalde-
hyde acetal intermediate rather than benzenemethanol was
produced as an intermediate. We used the same solvent and
conditions as Hu and co-workers, but saw an intermediate,
benzenemethanol, which was not seen previously. This is not
surprising, as the lifetime of this intermediate was only 5 s, as
monitored by the inductive ESI-MS system. Transient inter-
mediates are easily missed in traditional studies of the
mechanism. Online inductive ESI-MS monitors reactions
continuously and so provides virtually real-time structural
information on the intermediates and products in the mixture.
As such, it should have great strength in capturing transient
intermediates. We suggest a new two-way three-stage path-
way involving three intermediates 21, 22, and 23 as shown in
Scheme 3. In this scheme, the functions of each reaction
intermediate are recognized.
In summary, inductive ESI-MS is a versatile method for
the direct and continuous monitoring of organic reactions
in situ while avoiding the need for physical contact of the high
voltage with the reaction solution. Sheath gas was used to
assist in the nebulization process and minimize size variation
in the droplets. Sample splitting decreased the time offset in
the measurement while avoiding contamination of the MS
inlet. Three important reactions with different features—
reductive amination, Negishi cross-coupling, and Pd/C-cata-
evident 0.34 min and 0.38 min, respectively, after that at m/z
1
91. Just 0.3 min later, the signal at m/z 235 had disappeared,
while the signal at m/z 181 dominated the reaction mixture
spectrum. At the same time, the deprotonated form of the
hydrogenolysis product 10 (m/z 151) began to appear, became
the base signal at 18 min, and dominated the spectrum of the
reaction product mixture at 75 min. Three separate inter-
mediates (m/z 191, 235, and 181) were evident during the
course of the reaction, as were two forms of the product (m/z
1
51 and 153 are the deprotonated and protonated forms of the
final product) which are favored at different times (see the
Supporting Information for a discussion of the observation of
+
both forms of [M Æ H] and the reasons for this in the time-
dependent composition of the total reaction mixture).
The detection of transient intermediates in the study of
reaction mechanisms is significant, especially because their
short lives challenge classical methods of monitoring reac-
tions. Online inductive ESI-MS monitors reactions continu-
ously and provides virtually real-time structural information
on the intermediates and products in the mixture, including
transient intermediates with half-lives as short as 5 s (see
Figure S16, part 1 in the Supporting Information) in reactions
that take several hours to complete. The selected ion chrono-
gram in the time interval 2.5–3.5 min (see Figure S16 in the
Supporting Information) suggests that the intermediate at
m/z 191 was the first of the three intermediates formed,
appearing at almost at the same time as reagent 9 was added.
Its signal maximized at 3 min. The intermediate ion at m/z 235
was followed by one at m/z 191 in the time range 2.9–3.2 min.
The full lifetimes of these two intermediates were both less
than 0.3 min. With the decrease of the former intermediates,
the intermediate ion at m/z 181 increased, and the conversion
of this intermediate into product 10 then occurred in what
appears to be the rate-limiting step.
Pd/C-catalyzed hydrogenolysis of benzaldehydes to meth-
ylbenzenes has been described as proceeding via a benzene-
[
10d,e]
methanol intermediate
because benzenemethanol has
been isolated as an intermediate or as a major by-product. In
Scheme 3. Two-way three-stage pathway of the Pd/C-catalyzed hydro-
our experiment, intermediate ions at m/z 191, 235, and 181 are
genolysis of 3,4-dimethoxybenzaldehyde in methanol.
5
934
ꢀ 2014 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2014, 53, 5931 –5935