Angewandte Chemie International Edition
10.1002/anie.202013067
COMMUNICATION
can destabilize the formation of this complex, thereby preventing
the reaction from occurring. Most critically, sterically bulky
alkenes bind less well to Cu(I) and thus are poor substrates for
this strategy. 13 Consequently, many of the most interesting
complex cyclobutane natural products cannot be efficiently
synthesized using the Salomon–Kochi protocol or indeed by any
known photocycloaddition methodology (Figure 1C). This
represents a significant gap in chemists’ ability to synthesize the
diverse family of cyclobutane-containing natural products.
reaction and were delighted to observe increased reactivity, with
a correlation between the calculated gas-phase acidities16 of the
WCA conjugate acids and the yield of the cycloaddition (entries
5–7). The optimal SbF –
complex afforded 94% yield of the [2+2]
6
cycloadduct in just 1 h. Indeed, the reaction proceeds essentially
to completion in only 30 min (entry 8), highlighting the substantial
rate improvement using this optimal catalyst over the canonical
triflate salt.
To test the importance of the Cu(I):COD stoichiometry, we
One notable consequence of the relative instability of the
cationic copper bis(alkene) intermediate is a strong dependence
on the coordinating ability of the counteranion. Salomon reported
that photocycloadditions catalyzed by CuOTf occur at least an
2 6
next independently prepared [Cu(COD) ]SbF and found it to be
a less effective catalyst (entry 9), consistent with the expected
slow rate of exchange of the second COD ligand with substrate.
Excess COD ligand also has a strong inhibitory effect on the
cycloaddition (entry 10). Similarly, the use of CuCl as a
precatalyst in the absence of COD ligand proved ineffective (entry
11). 17 Finally, control experiments excluding the Cu catalyst,
silver salt, or light source resulted in no observable consumption
of the substrate (entries 12–14), demonstrating the necessity of
each of these reaction components.
9
order of magnitude faster than those conducted using CuCl. This
observation was attributed to the ability of more nucleophilic
counteranions to displace the labile olefin ligands. We
hypothesized that complexes bearing even more weakly
coordinating counteranions (WCAs) than triflate would result in a
more electrophilic Cu(I) metal center that could productively
engage bulky alkenes in this reaction.
Table 1: Optimization of in situ catalyst generation with silver salts of WCAs
As a platform to test these ideas, we first examined the
photocycloaddition of diene 1, which Salomon had reported was
a poor substrate.13a Consistent with precedent, conditions that
have most commonly been utilized for the Salomon–Kochi
Cu(I) cat.
OTBS
or
Me
OTBS
Me
[
Cu(COD)Cl]2/AgX
2
cycloaddition (1 mol% [Cu(OTf)] •benzene) afforded only 28% of
0
.025 M Et2O, 254 nm, 0.5-1 h
Me
Me
cyclobutane product (Table 1, entry 1). The reaction does not
proceed to completion upon extended irradiation times, and the
observation of Cu0 depositing in the reaction vessel indicated
significant catalyst decomposition (entry 2). We imagined that
Cu(I) complexes bearing even more weakly coordinating anions
might increase the reaction rate. However, attempts to synthesize
Cu(I)•benzene complexes featuring a range of WCAs, either
alone or in situ, were not successful due to the propensity of these
unstabilized Cu(I) salts to undergo rapid decomposition. We
wondered if alternate ancillary ligands might better stabilize the
cationic Cu(I) center. Nitrogen and phosphine donor ligands
commonly utilized in copper catalysis, however, have been shown
to inhibit photocycloaddition, either by disfavoring formation of the
bis(alkene) complex or by producing other low-energy charge-
transfer excited states that outcompete formation of the requisite
alkene MLCT state.12a,14
1
2
Entry
[Cu]
[Ag]
Time
Yielda,b
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
1 mol% [CuOTf]
1 mol% [CuOTf]
2
•C
•C
6
H
6
6
-
1 h
18 h
1 h
28% 4:1 d.r.
42% 4:1 d.r.
33% 4:1 d.r.
91% 4:1 d.r.
52% 4:1 d.r.
57% 8:1 d.r.
94% 4:1 d.r.
81% 4:1 d.r.
18% 4:1 d.r.
0%
2
6
H
-
1 mol% [Cu(COD)Cl]
1 mol% [Cu(COD)Cl]
1 mol% [Cu(COD)Cl]
1 mol% [Cu(COD)Cl]
1 mol% [Cu(COD)Cl]
2
2
2
2
2
AgOTf (299.5)c
AgOTf (299.5)c
18 h
1 h
(288.0)c
4
AgBF
AgNTf
AgSbF
(286.5)c
(255.5)c
1 h
2
6
1 h
1 mol% [Cu(COD)Cl]2
2 mol% Cu(COD) SbF
AgSbF6
-
0.5 h
0.5 h
0.5 h
0.5 h
0.5 h
0.5 h
0.5 h
2
6
1
0d
1 mol% [Cu(COD)Cl]
2 mol% CuCl
2
2
2
,
AgSbF
AgSbF
-
6
6
We hypothesized instead that a diene ligand such as
cyclooctadiene (COD) might stabilize the highly electron-deficient
Cu(I) center without engendering competitive low-energy charge-
transfer states. Because displacement of a COD ligand by a less
conformationally rigid bis(alkene) substrate would likely be
11
9%
1
1
2
3
1 mol% [Cu(COD)Cl]
-
0%
AgSbF
AgSbF
6
6
0%
14e
1 mol% [Cu(COD)Cl]
0%
Cu(I) complexes15
thermodynamically unfavorable, known (COD)
2
seemed unlikely to be suitable precatalysts. We wondered
instead if coordinatively unsaturated Cu(I) complexes could be
[
a] Reactions conducted in quartz tubes equipped with a cold finger. Irradiation
took place in a Rayonet RP-100 photoreactor with 254 nm bulbs. [b] NMR yields
taken with TMS-Ph as internal standard. [c] Gas phase acidity constants of
corresponding acid. [d] Reaction conducted in the presence of 50 mol%
additional COD ligand. [e] No UV irradiation.
generated in situ by anion metathesis of dimeric [Cu(COD)Cl]
2
with Ag(I) salts of WCAs (Figure 1D). This strategy would enable
use of bench-stable catalyst precursors in this reaction instead of
the air- and moisture-sensitive [Cu(OTf)]
has been the catalyst of choice for this reaction for decades.
As a control, we first treated [Cu(COD)Cl] with AgOTf in situ,
and the resulting complex performed similarly to the standard
Cu(OTf)] •benzene catalyst (entry 3). However, extended
2
•benzene complex that
Studies examining the scope of the photocycloaddition
using this new catalyst system are summarized in Table 2. We
first examined the reactivity of variously substituted 1,6-
2
heptadienes
(2–8).
/AgSbF
•benzene catalyst in all cases examined. This
As
expected,
the
optimized
[
2
[
[
Cu(COD)Cl]
Cu(OTf)]
2
6
catalyst system outperforms the standard
irradiation results in complete conversion, demonstrating that
diene ligands are indeed able to stabilize the highly electron-
deficient cationic Cu(I) center without attenuating its photoactivity
2
advantage became more evident with greater steric bulk on the
alkene, consistent with our catalyst design strategy. Cyclization of
naturally occurring terpenes linalool and nerolidol demonstrate
(
entry 4). We next examined the use of a series of WCAs in this
2
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.