Communication
square crystals by the usual recrystallization method from hot
water; however, the ee value was quite low since it was a twin-
ned crystal. In contrast, the ee values for small single crystals
were high. By regulating the crystal size to be relatively small,
the possibility of convergence to a crystal with high optical
purity is expected.
yield still needed improvement. Finally, ethanol (1.0 mL) was
added as a poor solvent to promote precipitation during dera-
cemization, and the continuous suspension gave 99% ee for
the solid in 71% chemical yield after filtration.
The experiment was repeated several times, and it was con-
firmed that the probability of tilting to either enantiomer was
about 1:1 and that the directionality of the asymmetric amplifi-
cation could be controlled by adding a small amount of enan-
tiomorphic crystals during attrition-enhanced deracemization.
In conclusion, we developed the first example of asymmetric
synthesis of an aspartic acid derivative from prochiral starting
materials involving dynamic enantioselective crystallization
with excellent optical purity of 99% ee without using any ex-
ternal chiral source. This reaction system is an absolute asym-
metric synthesis and will be of interest to many researchers be-
cause the reaction is strongly linked to homochirality on Earth.
Furthermore, this reaction process involving a chemical reac-
tion generating a chiral center followed by deracemization via
dynamic crystallization is simple and applicable to industrializa-
tion.
We examined the asymmetric synthesis of 2 involving attri-
[
22,23]
tion-enhanced deracemization (Viedma ripening).
When an
aqueous solution of maleic acid (0.595 g, 5.12 mmol) and pyri-
dine (0.405 g, 5.12 mmol) was stirred at 908C for 1 h, 2 precipi-
tated by the aza-Michael addition reaction. Subsequently,
acetic acid and glass beads (0.5 g) were added, and the solu-
tion was kept in suspension with stirring at the same tempera-
ture for several days. The change in the ee value for 2 for both
the crystalline phase and the mother liquor was analyzed by
HPLC using CHIRALPAK ZWIX(+) (Figure 3).
Experimental Section
General: NMR spectra were recorded in D O solutions on a
2
1
BRUKER 300 operating at 300 and 75 MHz, respectively, for H- and
13
C-NMR spectroscopy. Chemical shifts are reported in parts per
million (ppm). IR spectra were recorded on a JASCO FT/IR-230
spectrometer. HPLC analyses were performed on a JASCO HPLC
system (JASCO PU-1580 pump, DG-1580-53, LG-2080-02, MD-2015,
and CD-2095 detector). X-ray single crystallographic analysis was
conducted using a SMART APEX II ULTRA (Bruker AXS). Powder
XRD analysis was conducted using a D8 ADVANCE (Bruker AXS).
Figure 3. Asymmetric synthesis of 2 from prochiral maleic acid and pyridine
involving attrition-enhanced deracemization in aqueous acetic acid at 908C.
Using a mixed solvent of water and acetic acid in a ratio of
Asymmetric synthesis of N-succinopyridine via attrition-en-
hanced deracemization: A solution of maleic acid (1) (595 mg,
1
:3 by volume (water 0.25 mL: acetic acid 0.75 mL), deracemi-
zation began after 3 days and the ee value increased to 80%
ee after 6 days (Figure 3, red line). The analyzed sample includ-
ed both crystalline and dissolved compound in the mother
liquor. On the other hand, the filtered solid of 2 was obtained
in 22% chemical yield with 99% ee.
5.12 mmol) and 1.0 equiv. of pyridine (405 mg, 5.12 mmol) in H O
2
(0.25 or 0.40 mL) was stirred using an oval magnetic stirring bar
with or without glass beads (12.0 mm, 500 mg) in a sealed tube
at 908C. After crystalline 2 appeared, acetic acid (0.75 or 0.60 mL)
was added. The solution was kept in suspension with stirring at
the same temperature for several days.
To increase the chemical yield and the ee value, the ratio of
acetic acid was reduced, because acetic acid is the good dis-
solving solvent. Following the addition reaction in water, the
ratio was adjusted to 1:1.5 water (0.4 mL) and acetic acid
The ee value of 2 was monitored by HPLC using a chiral column,
CHIRALPAK ZWIX(+) (Daicel Ind.): eluent: MeOH/MeCN/H O/formic
2
acid/diethyl amine=490/490/20/1.9/2.6 (v/v/v/v/v).
Enantioselectivity of asymmetric reaction: Ten experiments were
(0.6 mL), whereupon the deracemization rate became a little
performed at optimized conditions (H O : AcOH=1:1.5, with glass
2
slower. The ee value started to increase at the ninth day and
reached 93% after 16 days (Figure 3, blue line). In this case,
the yield of the solid product after filtration was improved to
beads) in order to examine the probability of tilting to either enan-
tiomer. As the result, 6 times (À)-2 and 4 times (+)-2 were ob-
tained.
4
7% yield with 99% ee.
Control of chirality by seeding: We also attempted to control
chirality of dynamic crystallization by adding seed crystals. Maleic
acid (0.595 g), pyridine (0.405 g) and water (0.4 mL) were added to
a sealed tube, and the aqueous solution was stirred at 908C. After
crystalline N-succinopyridine 2 was appeared, acetic acid (0.6 mL),
glass beads (12.0 mm, 500 mg), and powdered seed crystal of
A control experiment was carried out to confirm the effect
of the glass beads. Under the same conditions as the blue line
using the solvent (water:acetic acid=1:1.5), asymmetric syn-
thesis followed by deracemization was examined without glass
beads. The rate of deracemization became slower and 28 days
were required to reach 91% ee. The solid succinopyridine after
filtration was obtained in 51% yield with 99% ee (Figure 3,
purple line).
(
À)-form (ca. <5 mg) were added. Next day, the ee value of sus-
pended solution increased to 14% ee (À) form, and ee value
reached 89% ee (À) form after 4 days.
Single-crystal X-ray structure analysis of N-succinopyridine 2 :
3
Asymmetric synthesis of the aspartic acid derivative with
very high optical purity was performed; however, the chemical
Colourless prism (0.20ꢂ0.10ꢂ0.10 mm ), orthorhombic space
group P2
2
1
2
1
, a=7.7020(2) ꢀ, b=7.7485(2) ꢀ, c=14.8933(5) ꢀ, V=
1
Chem. Asian J. 2019, 00, 0 – 0
3
ꢁ 2019 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim
&
&
These are not the final page numbers! ÞÞ