Tetrahedron Letters
A reaction based chromofluorogenic turn-on probe for specific
detection of fluoride over sulfide/thiols
⇑
Sharad Kumar Asthana, Ajit Kumar, Neeraj, K. K. Upadhyay
Department of Chemistry (Centre of Advanced Study), Faculty of Science, Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi 221005, India
a r t i c l e i n f o
a b s t r a c t
Article history:
A new reaction based probe fluorescein nosylate (R1) has been designed and synthesized for selective
recognition of FÀ in acetonitrile (CH3CN) by exploiting both its nucleophilic and basic character. Probe
R1 consists of fluorescein dye as a signalling unit while 4-nitrobenzenesulfonyl chloride as the masking
unit. The FÀ plays the role of de-masking agent to set free the fluorescein moiety in its open form from R1
leading to significant changes in its absorption/emission profile. The detection of FÀ amidst of sulfide/thi-
ols through receptors undergoing nucleophilic scission is a tedious job due to similarity in their extent of
basicity/nucleophilicity. Here, we present a convenient solution for the same in the form of R1 which
detects FÀ selectively over sulfide/thiols in CH3CN with a high detection limit of 4.6 Â 10À7 M and
2.75 Â 10À8 M determined through UV–visible and fluorescence titration data, respectively.
Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Received 11 July 2014
Revised 9 September 2014
Accepted 10 September 2014
Available online xxxx
Keywords:
Fluorescein
Chemodosimeter
Fluoride ion
Nucleophilicity/basicity
Optical sensors
The recognition and sensing of anions have attracted a great
deal of attention because of their biological and environmental
importance.1 Being very small in size and having high charge den-
sity the fluoride ion (FÀ) contributes towards diverse health and
environmental issues.2 The pivotal role of FÀ in dental care as pre-
venting cavities and strengthening teeth is well known.3 However,
a high intake of FÀ may cause most widespread side effects like
fluorosis, urolithiasis, osteoporosis etc. in human beings.4 Fluorides
also enter the environment from various anthropogenic activities
besides the fluoridation of drinking water.5 For these reasons, con-
siderable efforts have been devoted towards the development of
novel receptors for the selective detection of FÀ. The optical probes
for the analysis of different analytes have been in the process of
development for the last few decades owing to their simplicity,
high selectivity and sensitivity.6
Till now, a number of diverse sensing mechanisms have been
employed for optical detection of FÀ,4a,7 including hydrogen bond-
ing interactions, Lewis acid/base coordination, FÀ induced leaving
of the trialkylsilyl group,8 FÀ substitution for p-dimethylaminopy-
ridine,9 FÀ induced B–N bond cleavage10 and de-protection of dini-
tro/nitrobenzenesulfonyl (DNBS/NBS)-protected fluorophores.11
Out of the above the hydrogen bonding interaction based receptors
are generally non-selective and face interferences from a number
of anions of comparable basicity, for example, OHÀ, AcOÀ, H2PO4À
etc.12 To overcome the same, researchers have synthesized
reaction based probes, that is, chemodosimeters7,13 which utilize
chemical affinity between FÀ and silicon/boron involving facile
cleavage of the C–Si, O–Si or B–N/O bond by FÀ.8–10 Moreover fluor-
ide is most electronegative, and has a strong nucleophilic character
which may lead to FÀ induced nucleophilic cleavage of C–S bond
also.11
The basic synthetic approach of these kinds of probes mainly
involves FÀ directed cleavage of the protecting group and release
of fluorophore in the solution which leads to appropriate optical
changes. For this purpose a variety of fluorophores viz., resorufin,
BODIPY, fluorescein, coumarin etc. were used by various workers.13
Fluorescein is an inexpensive, practical and reliable molecular tool
for the construction of optical probes due to its large visible-range
extinction coefficients and high fluorescence quantum yields.14
Although a few FÀ responsive probes incorporating the fluorescein
moiety have been explored previously11,15–19 (Fig. 1), a few com-
mon drawbacks are associated with these probes viz., moderate
detection limit, selectivity, poor off–on response, tedious synthetic
approach etc.
In order to tackle the above limitations of the current FÀ probes,
herein we devised a highly selective reaction based chromofluoro-
genic turn-on probe (R1) for FÀ which incorporates fluorescein as
the fluorophore and 4-nitrobenzenesulfonyl (NBS) as the masking
agent (Fig. 1). Previously reported fluorescein based probes/
chemodosimeters are associated with some limitations. For exam-
ple, Shiraishi and co-workers.15 reported an unmodified fluores-
cein (R2) as fluorescent sensor for FÀ but it experiences
interferences from AcOÀ and H2POÀ4 due to their comparable
⇑
Corresponding author. Tel.: +91 542 670 2488.
0040-4039/Ó 2014 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.