M. Ji et al. / Bioorg. Med. Chem. Lett. 15 (2005) 1701–1705
1703
Compounds 9a–c were designed to investigate if a much
longer biphenyl can be used to replace the 4-flurophenyl
ring in compound 5c as the tail. Consistent with the data
obtained for compound 5b, compound 9a with a 2-car-
bon linker only has a weak affinity (Ki = 23 lM) to the
D3 receptor. In contrast to 5c and 5d, compounds 9b
and 9c with a 3-carbon and 4-carbon linker, have very
different affinities to the D3 receptor. While compound
9b has a relatively weak binding affinity (Ki = 2.5 lM)
to the D3 receptor, compound 9c is a potent D3 ligand
(Ki = 22 nM). Interestingly, compound 9b has higher
affinities at the D1-like and D2-like receptors than at
the D3 receptor. In contrast, compound 9c has a higher
affinity at the D3 receptor than at the D1-like and D2-
like receptors, thus displaying a selectivity of 12- and
10-fold.
pound 12b with the 8-methoxyl substituent on the phen-
yl ring has a Ki value of 244 nM at the D3 receptor, 13-
time less potent than 10c. However, compound 12b was
found to be completely inactive at the D1-like and D2-
like receptors at the highest concentration tested
(250 lM). Hence, 12b is a moderately potent D3 ligand
but has an excellent selectivity over the D1-like and
D2-like receptors. Compound 12c with the 9-methoxyl
substituent on the phenyl ring has a Ki value of 45 nM
at the D3 receptor, 130-fold selectivity over the D1-like
receptors and 25-fold selectivity over the D2-like recep-
tors. Thus, 9-methoxyl substituent on the phenyl ring
has a marginal influence on both the binding affinity
and selectivity. Compound 12d with the 10-methoxyl
substituent on the phenyl ring has a Ki value of
2.6 nM at the D3 receptor, >2000-fold selectivity over
the D1-like receptors and 99-fold selectivity over the
D2-like receptors. Hence, 10-methoxyl substituent on
the phenyl ring of 10c improves the binding affinity by
seven times at the D3 receptor and selectivity more than
45-fold between the D3-like receptor and the D2-like
receptors. Compound 12d is a potent D3 ligand with
an excellent selectivity over the D1-like receptors and a
good selectivity over the D2-like receptors.
Previously, it was shown that a naphthyl ring can be
used as the tail in D3 ligands to improve binding affinity
and/or selectivity. Accordingly, compounds 10a–c were
designed and synthesized. Consistent with the data ob-
tained for compounds 9a and 9b, compounds 10a and
10b with either a 2- or 3-carbon linker only has a weak
affinity to the D3 receptor. Similar to 9c, compound 10c
with
a 4-carbon linker is a potent D3 ligand
(Ki = 18 nM). But 10c is more selective than 9c and
has a selectivity of 44- and 87-fold over the D1-like
and D2-like receptors. These data indicate that a bulky
naphthyl tail and a 4-carbon linker afford compound
(10c) with a potent binding affinity to the D3 receptor
(Ki = 18 nM) and a good selectivity over both the D1-
like and the D2-like receptors.
To directly compare 12a and 12d with other known D3
ligands, we have evaluated BP 897, a known selective
D3 ligand,6 in our assay conditions and the results are
provided in Table 1. As can be seen, BP 897 has Ki val-
ues of 1.1 nM at the D3 receptor, 162 nM at the D2-like
receptors, and 636 nM at the D1-like receptors, respec-
tively. These values are in good agreement with the re-
ported Ki values of 0.92 nM at the D3 receptor, 61 nM
at the D2 receptor and 3 lM at the D1 receptor, respec-
tively, using the CHO cells expressing recombinant hu-
man D1, D2 and D3 receptors.6 Of note, although it is
known that assay conditions can have a significant influ-
ence on the binding affinity of a ligand at the D3 recep-
tor and the selectivity over other dopamine subtype
receptors,18 our results on BP 897 indicate that our as-
says using membranes prepared from rat brains and as-
says using CHO cells expressing recombinant human
D1, D2 and D3 appear to produce quite consistent re-
sults in both binding affinity and selectivity. Based upon
our data, compound 12d and BP 897 have similar bind-
ing affinities at the D3 receptor (2.6 vs 1.1 nM for their
Ki values). Compound 12d has a better selectivity than
BP 897 over the D1-like receptors (>2000-fold vs 578-
fold) and has a slightly worse selectivity than BP 897
(99- vs 147-fold). Taken together, our data indicate that
compound 12d represents a promising new lead com-
pound for further optimization towards our goal of
obtaining highly potent D3 ligands with outstanding
selectivity over the D1-like and D2-like receptors.
Finally, based upon the potent binding affinity activity
of BP 897 to the D3 receptor and its good selectivity over
the D1 and D2 receptors, it appears that a methoxyl sub-
stituent on the phenyl ring in the hexahydropyrazino-
quinoline core structure may further improve the
binding and/or selectivity of compound 10c. This idea
is supported by our modeling studies on 10c (data not
shown), which suggests that a methoxyl substituent on
the phenyl ring may form hydrogen bonding interaction
with one of the three serine residues, namely Ser192,
Ser193 and Ser196 in the D3 receptor. To explore the
influence of a methoxyl substituent on binding affinity
and selectivity, compounds 12a–d were synthesized and
tested.
Compound 12a with the 7-methoxyl substituent on the
phenyl ring has a Ki value of 5.8 nM at the D3 receptor,
793-fold selectivity over the D1-like receptors and 131-
fold selectivity over the D2-like receptors. The 7-meth-
oxyl substituent on the phenyl ring improves the binding
affinity by three-fold at the D3 receptor as compared to
10c. Furthermore, the 7-methoxyl substituent improves
the selectivity by 18 times between the D3 receptor and
the D1-like receptors as compared to 10c. This improved
selectivity over the D1-like receptors is the combination
of an increased binding affinity at the D3 receptor and a
decreased binding affinity at the D1-like receptors. The
selectivity of 12a between the D3 receptor and the D2-
like receptors is only improved marginally by 1.5-fold
as compared to that of 10c (131-fold vs 87-fold). Com-
The synthetic route for compounds 5a–d is outlined in
Scheme 1. The key intermediate 4 was synthesized using
known methods with some modifications.19–21 Briefly,
condensation of 2-quinoline-carboxaldehyde 1 with
ethanolamine generated the SchiffÕs base, which was
reduced to 2-substituted aminomethylquinoline 2 with
NaBH4.19,20 Reduction of 2 with nickel–aluminium
alloy in aqueous KOH readily produced 2-substituted