B. Xu, et al.
Bioorganic Chemistry 104 (2020) 104205
Table 1
The EC50 (50% effective concentration), CC50 (50% toxic concentration) and SI
(
selectivity index, CC50/EC50) of these compounds.
a
To Vero cell lineb
CC50 (μM) SI
Cmpd
EC50 (μM)
To SNB-19 cell line
CC50 (μM)
SI
(
(
±
±
)-2
1.56 ± 0.21
7.40 ± 0.37
> 100
> 100
> 64.1 27.00 ± 0.61 17.3
> 13.5 59.30 ± 0.43 8.0
)-3 (trans/
cis 5/1)
)-4
c
d
(
(
(
(
±
±
±
±
NA
> 100
/
/
/
> 100
/
/
/
)-5
NA
NA
> 100
> 100
)-6
94.60 ± 1.0
50.40 ± 0.16
)-7
3.40 ± 0.38 52.60 ± 1.1 15.5
44.00 ± 1.18 12.9
a
b
c
Incubated for 24 h.
Incubated for 48 h.
NA: not active as EC50 values are higher than 40 μM.
not available.
d
screening to generate EC50 values with at least 7 gradient concentra-
tions. The cytotoxicity (Table 1) of each compound in this study was
tested in SNB-19 cells (24 h treatment) and Vero cells (48 h treatment)
for the duration corresponding to the incubation time in anti-ZIKV
screening. Among the compounds reported in this study, three com-
pounds of ( ± )-2, ( ± )-3 and ( ± )-7 were active against ZIKV infec-
tion as shown in Table 1. In particular, compound ( ± )-2 exhibits low
micromolar EC50 value (1.56 μM) with SIs of higher than 64.1 in SNB-
19 cell line and 17.3 in Vero cell line. Compound ( ± )-6 with two
hydroxyl groups at 3′- and 4′-positions and compound ( ± )-5 with 3′-
methoxy group and 4′-hydroxyl group are inactive; in contrast, com-
pound 3 with 3′-hydroxyl group and 4′-methoxy group is active against
ZIKV infection with 7.40 μM of EC50 value and SI values of 13.5 and 8.0
in SNB-19 and Vero cell lines, respectively. As trans isomer of ( ± )-3 is
the major isomer, the inhibitory activity of ( ± )-3 may be attributed to
its trans isomer; however, the precise EC50 value of trans isomer of
( ± )-3 against ZIKV can only be determined after the pure trans isomer
of ( ± )-3 is obtained. Silylation of 4′-hydroxyl group of compound
( ± )-5 makes compound ( ± )-2 exhibit very potent anti-ZIKV activity,
which is possibly attributed to the introduction of TBS group consistent
with a previously reported observation [28]. Whereas, bis-silylation of
3′,4′-hydroxyl groups of compound ( ± )-6 is not able to enhance the
anti-ZIKV activity of compound ( ± )-4. Interestingly, compounds of
( ± )-4, and ( ± )-5 are almost not cytotoxic to SNB-19 and Vero cell
lines. 4′-Chloride compound ( ± )-7 possesses good anti- ZIKV activity,
with an EC50 of 3.40 μM and SIs are 15.5 in SNB-19 cell line and 12.9 in
Vero cell line. Some images from the titer plates used to calculate the
EC50 values of the compounds are shown in Fig. S3. With these anti-
ZIKV results, we further conducted the virucidal tests (Supplementary
data-2) [29–31] of these active compounds of ( ± )-2, ( ± )-3 and
( ± )-7 at 4 concentrations around their EC50 values, and virucidal test
results showed that they are not virucidal, indicating that anti-ZIKV
activity of this series of compounds is not due to virucidal (neutralising)
effect. As a whole, these results revealed that this structural scaffold has
a valuable pharmacological feature and it is possible that the reduced
N10′s basicity is not the key for the antiviral activity, and importantly,
tuning of some pharmacophore/s including substituents can produce
effective antiviral drug candidates against ZIKV infection.
Fig. 2. The crystal structure of compound ( ± )-7 trans isomer (CCDC
1
915004).
isomer and two isomers are quite difficult to isolate by silica gel
chromatography, pure trans isomer and the mixture of trans and cis
isomers were used for the structure analysis (Supplementary data-1,
1
Fig. S2). Compared with H NMR data (Scheme 1) of pure ( ± )-7 trans
isomer with the mixture of ( ± )-7 trans and cis isomers, the chemical
shifts (δ) of C1-H and C3a-H of ( ± )-7 trans isomer are recognized 5.81
and 4.54 ppm while those of ( ± )-7 cis isomer are 6.12 and 4.25 ppm
(
Supplementary data-1, Fig. S2). Based on the current and previous
facts that the chemical shift of C1-H of cis isomer is higher than that of
trans isomer but the chemical shift of C3a-H of cis isomer is lower than
1
that of trans isomer, it is concluded from H NMR data of the mixture of
trans and cis isomers of ( ± )-3 that the chemical shifts (δ) of C1-H and
C3a-H of ( ± )-3 trans isomer is 5.62 and 4.44 ppm while those of
(
± )-3 cis isomer is 5.92 and 4.18 ppm (Supplementary data-1, Fig.
S1). The chemical shift (δ) difference of C3-H between two isomers is
around 0.6 ppm in the reported results of 1H-pyrrolo[1,2-c]imidazol-1-
one derivatives; meanwhile, the chemical shift (δ) difference of C1-H
between two isomers is about 0.3 ppm in this study. Even though the
chemical shift (δ) difference of C7a-H between two isomers is not ob-
vious in the reported results of 1H-pyrrolo[1,2-c]imidazol-1-one deri-
vatives, the chemical shift (δ) difference of C3a-H between two isomers
is significantly 0.2 to 0.3 ppm for compounds ( ± )-3 and ( ± )-7 in this
1
study. H NMR data of C1-H and C3a-H of compounds of ( ± )-2 to
(
(
±
±
)-7 are in Scheme 1 and the stereochemistry of the major isomers of
)-2 to ( ± )-6 was designated as trans configuration as ( ± )-7 trans
isomer even though no pure cis isomer was got for the structure analysis
in this study. The weak electron-withdrawing group (EWG) property of
chloro at para-position makes higher chemical shifts of C1-H and C3a-H
of ( ± )-7 compared with ( ± )-2 to ( ± )-6 bearing two electron-do-
nating groups (EDGs) of hydroxyl, methoxy and t-butyldimethylsilyloxy
(
OTBS) at 3′- and 4′-positions.
Anti-ZIKV activity of compounds ( ± )-2, ( ± )-3 and ( ± )-7 were
confirmed with additional assays including Western Blot (Fig. 3) and
ELISA (enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay) (Fig. 4). As shown in
Fig. 3, Western Blot experiments indicate that expressions of both ZIKV
NS5 and NS1 were effectively reduced by treatment of 5 µM of ( ± )-2,
( ± )-3 and ( ± )-7 as 5 µM of the positive control Niclosamide com-
pared to vehicle control (ZIKV DMSO). Meanwhile, ELISA experiments
(Fig. 4) demonstrate that amount of ZIKV NS1 in the supernatant of
infected cell culture was also decreased by 10 µM of Niclosamide,
( ± )-2, ( ± )-3, and ( ± )-7 relative to vehicle control (ZIKV DMSO). It
should be noted that ZIKV NS1 expressions detected by ELISA were
For the compounds of ( ± )-2 to ( ± )-7, we investigated their in-
hibitory activity against ZIKV infection in a viral titer assay (in Vero
cells for 48 h) [26] (Supplementary data-1). We measured ZIKV pro-
duction in compound-treated human glioblastoma cells (SNB-19 line)
(
incubation for 24 h) infected by PRVABC59 strain at multiplicity of
infection (MOI) of 1 as illustrated in Supplementary data. Niclosamide,
one of the previously identified active compounds against ZIKV infec-
tion, [26–27] was used as a positive control in each antiviral assay. We
conducted initial antiviral screening using one concentration in triple
experiments and then advanced the active compounds from initial
3