Reaction of Cyclopentyl Radical (c-C5H9) with O2
J. Phys. Chem. A, Vol. 105, No. 27, 2001 6653
small amount of OH formation, in the range of what is expected
from the experiments of Handford-Styring and Walker (i.e.
e10%). The OH formed can react with the cyclopentane (k )
-
11
3
-1 -1
2
1
.84 × 10
cm molecule
s
at 753 K) or with radical
species (i.e., OH, HO2, c-C5H9O2, with rate constants ranging
-
11
-13
3
-1 -1 14,36
from 6 × 10 to 10 cm molecule s ).
The reaction
with cyclopentane forms another cyclopentyl, which then reacts
with O2 to form OH and HO2. This cycling should continue
until all OH is depleted by forming the end product HO2 or
removed from the system by radical-radical reactions. With
the initial radical density and cyclopentane concentrations used
in this study, simulations show that a 10% contribution of the
OH-producing channel could still produce a nearly 100% yield
1
of HO2. It is interesting to note that Simon et al. do not report
any observation of 1,2-epoxycyclopentane formation at the
higher temperature of 873 K and explain acrolein formation by
secondary reactions without any direct formation from the
cyclopentylperoxy. Further studies focused on sensitive real time
measurements of OH formation from this reaction are underway
and may clarify the role of the adduct in acrolein and
2
Figure 9. The pressure dependence of the prompt yield of HO from
the reaction of c-C
6
5
H
9
+ O
2
at 638 K and at a constant O
.6 × 10 molecule cm . The mean values are shown as the open
circles O and the individual determinations as the filled circles b. The
2
density of
1
6
-3
-
n
dash-dotted line is the best fit to a P dependence, shown for
1
,2-epoxycyclopentane formation.
reference.
Conclusion
formation from C3H7 + O2 compared to C2H5 + O2. They
postulated that the smaller alkene yield for C3H7 + O2 is due
to more efficient stabilization of the propylperoxy radical relative
to ethylperoxy due to the additional vibrational degrees of
freedom in the propylperoxy radical. Since the cyclopentylp-
eroxy radical is still larger than propylperoxy, it would be
expected to give still lower prompt HO2 yields at low temper-
ature, although the present experimental precision is insufficient
to distinguish the difference.
The reaction of cyclopentyl radicals with O2 has been
investigated as a function of temperature between 296 and 723
K by using laser photolysis/CW frequency modulation spec-
troscopy. The overall yield of HO2 from the cyclopentyl radical
+ O2 has been observed as a function of temperature. The HO2
occurs on two different time scales; a prompt HO2 signal is
observed immediately following the UV flash, and a second
slower delayed rise is also observed at higher temperatures. The
results from the c-C5H9 + O2 reaction are similar to the previous
The prompt HO2 yield produced by the coupled kinetic
mechanism is anticipated to be pressure dependent. The
decomposition pathway of the adduct to HO2 and cyclopentene
competes with the adduct stabilization pathway. The adduct is
stabilized by collisional relaxation with the background gas. An
increase in the pressure should increase in the stabilization rate
and thus a decrease in the observed prompt yield. Kaiser et
3,4
results obtained from the C2H5 + O2 and C3H7 + O2 reactions.
Previous work demonstrated that product formation from C2H5
+
O2 had excellent agreement with the predictions from a
coupled kinetics model, where the formation of an ethylperoxy
3
radical is the antecedent to the ethylene + HO2 formation. The
present paper shows a strong similarity of the HO2 product
formation from the reactions of C H + O and c-C H + O .
8,11-13
al.
have previously established such a pressure dependence
2
5
2
5
9
2
This similarity suggests that c-C5H9 + O2 undergoes a very
similar coupled kinetics scheme, where cyclopentylperoxy
radical is the antecedent to cyclopentene + HO2 formation. The
apparent activation energies of the three reactions are also very
similar, and suggest that the relative energies of the transition
states for the concerted HO2 elimination in the three reactions
are similar as well.
for both C3H7 + O2 and C2H5 + O2. The HO2 prompt yield
from c-C5H9 + O2 also shows an inverse pressure dependence
as seen in Figure 9.
The initial product yields in the experiments of Handford-
Styring and Walker show 9.4% total for acrolein and 1,2-
epoxycyclopentane and 87.8% total for cyclopentene and
cyclopenta-1,3-diene (from column 1 and 5 of Table 4 in ref 2,
with 70 Torr O2 at 753 K). The cyclopenta-1,3-diene observed
is likely formed by further oxidation of cyclopentene, and the
total of the two is a measure of the branching ratio of reaction
Acknowledgment. These experiments described here were
made possible by the able technical support of Leonard E.
Jusinski. We thank Dr. James A. Miller and Dr. Stephen J.
Klippenstein for communicating results prior to publication. This
work is supported by the Division of Chemical Sciences,
Geosciences, and Biosciences, the Office of Basic Energy
Sciences, the U.S. Department of Energy.
1
b. The total amount of acrolein and 1,2-epoxycyclopentane is
an estimate of the branching ratio of the OH producing pathway-
s) (represented by reaction 1c). The review of Walker and
Morley gives the total initial yield of conjugate alkene to be
(
9
4
0% at 753 K with an initial yield of 87% cyclopentene and
% cyclopentadiene.40 These totals imply that ∼10% OH is
References and Notes
formed in reaction 1 at 753 K.
In the present study at 723 K the HO2 yield is still ∼100%,
remaining relatively constant after reaching 100% at 683 K.
The HO2 yields corrected only for self-reaction are also near
(1) Simon, V.; Simon, Y.; Scacchi, G.; Baronnet, F. Can. J. Chem.
997, 75, 575.
1
(2) Handford-Styring, S. M.; Walker, R. W. J. Chem. Soc., Faraday
Trans. 1995, 91 (10), 1431.
(3) Clifford, E. P.; Farrell, J. T.; DeSain, J. D.; Taatjes, C. A. J. Phys.
Chem. A 2000, 104, 11549.
1
00% at these temperatures, so the inference of near quantitative
conversion to HO2 does not depend on the assumed c-C5H9O2
HO2 reaction rate coefficient. This result suggests that no
(
4) DeSain, J. D.; Clifford, E. P.; Taatjes, C. A. J. Phys. Chem. A 2001,
05, 3205.
5) Slagle, I. R.; Ratajczak, E.; Heaven, M. C.; Gutman, D.; Wagner,
A. F. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1985, 107, 1838.
+
1
significant additional product channel is opening up at these
temperatures. However, the HO2 yields are consistent with a
(